From the UKAuthors Collection
The Death of Good Writing
By franciman · Originally published 24 December 2012
I want to refute the growing belief that poetry is simply an incisive sparing write. I believe it has a duty to be so much more. Lyrical for one thing.
Roethke's Straw for the Fire
is combustible rubbish
passing for poetry.
A magical spliff,
a suede-walled spitball
of seminal shit,
posing as the philosopher's stone.
His disciples advocate
a minimalist approach
to an English that is,
at best, his second language.
The problem with glib rhetoric,
with Pilgrim father engineering,
is in hewing prosaic verse
from a lyrical mosaic.
Write your message on a Post-it,
not the beauty of a song.
Paint acrylic on a building,
scrawl it on a toilet wall.
Tell it like it is,
Not like it matters.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Death of Good Writing
franciman: straw for the fire is a compilation of roethke's notebooks, not poetry. he was not a minimalist. he turned out a number of prominent poets through his u. of washington writing program including james wright and david wagoner (neither minimalist), though they were devoted to roethke and might be called disciples. "to an english that is,/at best, his second language./ suggests you don't know that roethke was american born and raised (perhaps it's the prussian name). 2x nat'l bk award winner, pulitzer winner, short listed for the nobel which he probably would have won had he not died at 55. "suede-walled spitball/of seminal shit", really. elegy for jane, the waking, in a dark time, i knew a woman, the lost son would be a good introduction to his work. swep
The Death of Good Writing
merry christmas jim: i would only say that you went off on a poet about whom you had no prior knowledge which is pretty tricky. people like roethke talking about poetry is what a lifelong writing program professor does, and with the body of work supporting him to give credence to his thoughts. as for roethke, he's a strong writer that was more interesting in the past to me than now, but still interesting, worth listening to. now, i guess ro the crux of your reply, whether you think poets should suggest re-writing or re-structuring of a fellow's work is beside the point. pound massively bluelined eliot's wasteland, writing programs are about that very thing i.e. good line-by-line criticism, every good poet i know "considers" he who offers hard line-by-line criticism to be their "best friend." i know i do and so do the people i regularly criticize and who criticize me. the reason for suggestions are not because of a "mantra" but to help the writer improve his piece. those most open to such criticism in my experience make exponential leaps in their writing through the crtic/poet dialogue, on uka poets such as chant. your comments on my comments on butters poem brings me to something i consider odious, the height of bad form i.e. 3rd parties commenting on commentary by a reader on a poster's work. there is no elitism at play here, simply a desire to, in this case, help her improve her poem and share my vision on how to do it. anyway, i appreciate your wish for a great xmas and say have a great one yourself. swep
The Death of Good Writing
Tryin' to catch up a bit.
Tell it like it is,
Not like it matters.
I like that line best as it is the one that makes it matter, if you get my meaning...
Good job, Jim!
Greg :-)
The Death of Good Writing
I'd just like to say poetry needs its champions, Jim - and there is room for all manner of styles, voices, and messages despite the fact individual publishers or editors might prefer certain types.
above all else, what matters most isn't the author, but the voice of the poem; it's the poet's job to allow their poem to speak. whether or not others listen to its voice . . . well, we can only hope :D