From the UKAuthors Collection

Eclipse

By amman · Originally published 10 December 2012

Poem

Photobucket

I sat by her side and watched
her life force extinguished,
like a guttering candle
snuffed out by an unseen hand.

Like the moon embracing the sun
she slipped into darkness,
enveloped within that ecliptic
celestial shadow

to shine no more.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

ValDohren

Eclipse

Quite lovely Amman - very poignant.

franciman

Eclipse

Tony, this is such great poetry. Understated and to my mind elegant.

cheers,

Jim

butters

Eclipse

For me, a poem of two halves that don't really marry up as well as I would have hoped. V2 is rather better than V1 as its imagery is more original and therefore fresher.

The problem I have with V1 is 'like a guttering candle/snuffed by an unseen hand': whilst the guttering candle is a strong image in its own right, using 'like a' renders it more cliché than I feel comfortable with as a reader. Not only that, there's a suddenness about the word 'snuffed' that conflicts with the more ethereal nature of the eclipse image... eclipses take some time, and feel a more gradual taking of the light than 'snuffed' implies.

I would also say I feel your last line adds nothing to the concept that a reader can't insert themselves, and wonder - - should you be intent on extending the metaphor further - if it should be an absence of the flaming corona/diamond ring thing you focus on. I'm not sure if that was your intent or not with your final line, but I wasn't getting the diadem thing from it.

looking at this again today, if you lost L's 3&4 entirely, and made this into one V, it would shine brighter. x And thanks for accepting my words as intended. I always try to look at a write subjectively when critique's looked for.

obviously this may please others far more than me, and I trust you take my thoughts in the spirit they are offered :rose:

Andrea

Eclipse

It's very poignant - I wouldn't really dare to comment as it might be autobiographical and I wouldn't want to upset.

Texasgreg

Eclipse

Aye, my friend!

Moving moment in my mind. To be by her side as she leaves you when she never would by choice.

Greg :-)

cooky

Eclipse

Beautiful and moving.I like this

Mikeverdi

Eclipse

I also like this one, I didnt feel the need to dig deep for hidden meanings, for me it was all there. Mike

Capricorn

Eclipse

Oh that is so poignant and beautiful.

Well written

Eira

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…