From the UKAuthors Collection
Eclipse
By amman · Originally published 10 December 2012
Fiction · Poetry · New Voices
From the UKAuthors Collection
By amman · Originally published 10 December 2012
Around the UKAuthors table
Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.
Log in to join the conversation.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Eclipse
Quite lovely Amman - very poignant.
Eclipse
Tony, this is such great poetry. Understated and to my mind elegant.
cheers,
Jim
Eclipse
For me, a poem of two halves that don't really marry up as well as I would have hoped. V2 is rather better than V1 as its imagery is more original and therefore fresher.
The problem I have with V1 is 'like a guttering candle/snuffed by an unseen hand': whilst the guttering candle is a strong image in its own right, using 'like a' renders it more cliché than I feel comfortable with as a reader. Not only that, there's a suddenness about the word 'snuffed' that conflicts with the more ethereal nature of the eclipse image... eclipses take some time, and feel a more gradual taking of the light than 'snuffed' implies.
I would also say I feel your last line adds nothing to the concept that a reader can't insert themselves, and wonder - - should you be intent on extending the metaphor further - if it should be an absence of the flaming corona/diamond ring thing you focus on. I'm not sure if that was your intent or not with your final line, but I wasn't getting the diadem thing from it.
looking at this again today, if you lost L's 3&4 entirely, and made this into one V, it would shine brighter. x And thanks for accepting my words as intended. I always try to look at a write subjectively when critique's looked for.
obviously this may please others far more than me, and I trust you take my thoughts in the spirit they are offered :rose:
Eclipse
It's very poignant - I wouldn't really dare to comment as it might be autobiographical and I wouldn't want to upset.
Eclipse
Aye, my friend!
Moving moment in my mind. To be by her side as she leaves you when she never would by choice.
Greg :-)
Eclipse
Beautiful and moving.I like this
Eclipse
I also like this one, I didnt feel the need to dig deep for hidden meanings, for me it was all there. Mike
Eclipse
Oh that is so poignant and beautiful.
Well written
Eira