From the UKAuthors Collection
You Never Close Your Eyes
By Mikeverdi · Originally published 7 December 2012
amended after taking in the comments and critique kindly offered
Observation on the end of an affair
We lay together
in the darkening room.
I asked her if she had ever loved me.
Waited for her to answer,
watching smoke from her cigarette
curl towards the ceiling.
‘What do you think?’ she replied
reaching for her robe.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
You Never Close Your Eyes
Aye! Sounds like one of those bumpy roads you might bottom out on.
Good 'un, Mike!
Greg :-)
You Never Close Your Eyes
Smoking in bed - very risky, need to keep your eyes open !! If you value your property, you would be well free of her. :-) Good one Mike.
Val
You Never Close Your Eyes
Thats happened to me a few times, I can tell you.
You Never Close Your Eyes
She sounds a bit of a tough nut Mike.
Really well written and captured the scene perfectly. The last lines rounded it off with applomb. ;-)
Alison x
You Never Close Your Eyes
We lay together
in the darkening room.
I asked her if she had ever loved me.
I waited for her to answer,
watching smoke from her cigarette
curl towards the ceiling.
‘What do you think?’ she replied
reaching for her robe.
Mike this worked up to this point for me, and i would have enjoyed thinking on the answer....D
You Never Close Your Eyes
A very neat observation, Mike. The vagueness of the reply reveals the ambivalence of the relationship and sows the seed of doubt as to the cogency of the affair. A good write.
You Never Close Your Eyes
Made me think of this
You Never Close Your Eyes
Hi Mike,
Japanese wind nailed it for me. The poetry is all in the answer. From that point on it's telling where the first part has been show. It is good but it deserves to be great imho.
The reader already knows you are at home with her nakedness. Sorry if this seems harsh, but you are capable of so much more mate.
cheers,
Jim
You Never Close Your Eyes
agree with japanesewind on this one, mike, and also believe it's one of my favourite reads of your writing.
You Never Close Your Eyes
Hi Mike,
I'm in agreement with those who recommend stopping at the question. Short stuff, be it poetry or prose, needs to let the reader provide the ending. It's likely that what you write after the question is exactly what will occur to the reader. That's a good thing. If they imagine a different ending that's good too.
You Never Close Your Eyes
Mike, read your answers with interest, it's always a dilemma isn't it when pruning back and when each reader has a slightly different take on our poems?
I dig this version, its got a lot of power and sharper imagery.....D
there's a guy that keeps telling me to mess about with my
layout and slightly different wording, I do and am constantly amazed at the subtle changes...see ya ..D
You Never Close Your Eyes
It's tremendously powerful Mike. Into my favourites.
cheers,
Jim
You Never Close Your Eyes
"Hello, I have left an extensive reply on Jim's comment, he also agrees with Japan. Its hard for me on this one but I do see where your all coming from; and yet you still like it. Do I take it that had I stopped at the question and left out the answer, it would then be something I could be proud of? I really am confused. Thanks for commenting. Mike"
Your rewrite is the voice of poem that was there all along, mike - the other stuff you had was the author inserting himself into the piece :)
For a poem to work best, the author has to virtually disappear as it's all about the poem. It makes no difference how personal a write is to the author, how deeply we are invested in it ... the reader doesn't know and, in most instances, doesn't especially care. A poem can be littered with 'I's and 'me's but if the reader can engage with the write well enough they can place themselves in the narrator/protagonist's shoes and experience the emotional content vicariously.
I applaud you for the brave edit, mike, because you took the chance to allow the write to shine by stepping back from something that meant a lot to you. Should you be proud of this piece? ABSOLUTELY! You have shown yourself to be a better 'pruner' than many of us here by stepping back and allowing it to speak for itself, and hope you can enjoy your creation without feeling you've lost the essence of what was so important to you about it. You can always keep both versions, after all :)
For the reader, this version works 100% because it's clean, captures imagery, makes every single word earn its place, and makes the reader invest in it by inviting them to think about how/where the poem ends. Once a reader invests in a write, they will always be more pleased about having read it. I would happily revise my score now to a 9.5 but will have to make that a 9 since they don't do the half thingies! congratulations, mike, and yes be proud :D