From the UKAuthors Collection

Peredelkino

By franciman · Originally published 23 November 2012

For the Poetry challenge - Film Muse - Inspired by Dr Zhivago.

I hear your voices,
held inside the wind.
The chant is hollow,
empty as the Steppes.
Love veiled but everlasting.
My ancestry revealed,
as starry-eyed I see into the past.
You whisper of
needs left unfulfilled;
appetites beyond the ken
of mortal souls;
and anger at lives lost,
whiles still incomplete.
Behind this bitter song,
the sweetest melody
is carried by the leafless silver birch.
A balalaika
croons the old refrain.
Rippling chords
vibrate against my heart.
And a chestnut's fallen leaves
chatter like a child again.
'Come back to me, come back my darling boy'.
You urge my step
to pierce the darkling veil.
And yet, within your own
sweet dulcet tone,
resounds a prayer
much older than creation.
That you might leave behind
the vale of shadows.

In truth then,
you would live in place of me?

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Mikeverdi

Peredelkino

Truly beautiful in my opinion Jim. Mike

Andrea

Peredelkino

Beautiful pome - loved that movie!


Nomenklatura

Peredelkino

Hi Jim,

hard to find fault with this at all. You do have a typo at line 13 (I think)

whiles still incomplete. should be whilst, no? Although I do like the idea of an incomplete while...

Myself I would have gone for conventional word order in the last couplet and put 'would you '... but I can respect your choice as it is.

So, not much of anything in terms of real crit, I think that shows how good this is. Respect

Ewan

butters

Peredelkino

Another big THANKYOU, Jim, for rising to the occasion!

I'm going to have to come back to the rest of these challenges (and other posted writes) Sunday as I have no spare time till then but will catch up thoroughly, promise! So busy at work and tomorrow night going straight from work to the book launch! This piece looks as if it's captured the essential mood encapsulated by the film. lovely

Texasgreg

Peredelkino

Aye, Jim! catching up a bit...

I don't do the challenges well, but it appears you have no problems.

Good job...

Greg :-)

Ionicus

Peredelkino

A very commendable composition, Jim.

butters

Peredelkino

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peredelkino

so you made me go look up what I needed to know about the title and how it related to the intrinsic beauty of the "zhivagoness" of your write.

so, first of all, the title doing what a title should - adding dimension to a piece by way of explanation/lead-in/layering.

as always, my thoughts only - use or discard as you see fit :)

I hear your voices,

held inside the wind.

just lovely - I'm reading this as the voices of writers and the concept of them being 'held inside the wind' rather than going down the clichéd route of being blown on the wind, so the idea of the wind bearing this containment of voices, almost personified by them, its nature summing up all that it holds and all it holds defining its nature.

The chant is hollow,

empty as the Steppes.

Love veiled but everlasting.

My ancestry revealed,

as starry-eyed I see into the past.

A cold, almost moaning sound comes through with this. I found myself questioning the need for 'empty' - after all, 'hollow' can imply that already and refers back to the idea of the voices inside the wind, yet 'empty' works to spread out that idea into a flatter plane as you introduce the image of the Steppes.

I would question the full stop after Steppes, though, as the following line feels a part of the same image, and also the comma after 'revealed'; do you intend the 'love veiled ...' line to be part of what goes before, what comes after, or a stand-alone? If 'My ancestry ...' is separate from the thought before, you could make that 'My ancestry's revealed' and allow the line-break to do the work of the comma in this instance, but the way I'm really hearing this part is:

The chant is hollow,

empty as the Steppes;

Love veiled but everlasting,

my ancestry revealed

as starry-eyed I see into the past.

You whisper of

needs left unfulfilled;

appetites beyond the ken

of mortal souls;

and anger at lives lost,

whiles still incomplete.

typo aside, I like how you're holding the theme of 'voices' with 'chant' beforehand and now 'whisper'. Still feel you've a touch more punctuation than really required, i.e after 'lost'; line-breaks can do a lot of the work in poetry, allowing focus on a thought, an image, even if it's a part of the same phrase in a write.

Behind this bitter song,

the sweetest melody

is carried by the leafless silver birch.

truly beautiful image here *sighs*

A balalaika

croons the old refrain.

Rippling chords

vibrate against my heart.

just the word 'balalaika' is musical in its own right!

Again, though, I'm feeling there's an overuse of full stops which chops this up rather than letting the words do as their very nature implies - a running on of musicality. I am absolutely loving the conceit of 'rippling chords vibrate against my heart'. Such a rich image you create there. 'slovely.

And a chestnut's fallen leaves

chatter like a child again.

Your theme of voices, different voices, ties this together right the way through. All different and yet all encapsulating that 'feel'.

'Come back to me, come back my darling boy'.

You urge my step

to pierce the darkling veil.

And yet, within your own

sweet dulcet tone,

resounds a prayer

much older than creation.

That you might leave behind

the vale of shadows.

After 'creation', a colon might work better as the following lines are an expansion to let the reader know what desire/emotion makes up the prayer.

In truth then,

you would live in place of me?

Not as familiar with the details of the film as some here, so do these lines link more to that or are they more in reference to the writers who lived in Peredelkino? It looks as if my not getting these final lines is all about my ignorance rather than anything you're doing wrong :blush:

sorry for coming back to this as late as I have, but hope you find something of use in my reply - even if it's only food for thought. :)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…