From the UKAuthors Collection
A Noble Lie?
By franciman · Originally published 12 November 2012
For the Workshop Challenge -A Noble Lie.
'Cup o' tea, Sir?' said Rab, regarding the lieutenant from under lowering brows. You've been on edge for days, he thought.. What are you going to be like after a week or two of this? Alistair Aird stared at the walls of the dugout. He played with the buttons on his breast pocket, whilst his right foot beat a tattoo against the dugout floor. 'I've still got a big piece of Madame's cake', said Rab.
****
Eck shivered each time a shell exploded. His eyes darted along the top of the trench and he pulled heavily on his cigarette. Lips almost touching the boy's ear, Alan spoke softly in the interval between each explosion.
'We need a plan if we are tae make something of our lives when this lot is finished. Something we can both be involved in.' Alan used his shoulder to stir Eck's attention. 'C'mon Eck, think.'
'I don't know; I can't think wae all this noise,' shouted Eck, eyes wide, 'All I know is fish.' Suddenly he was laughing, they both were; a ridiculous contagion that lifted them beyond the barrage. Martin and the Gourlay brothers found them then. They huddled up against the warm comfort of their friends' delight.
'What the fuck can you two find tae laugh at in all this?' shouted Davy.
'We jist made a plan, Alan and I,' Eck answered, collapsing in hysterics.
****
Brodie watched his Uncle Colin make his way down the trench. Major Colin Aird, a merchant to trade but a soldier by nature, he thought. The Corporal watched the way his uncle created the illusion of peace and calm wherever he went, whoever he met. He knew the company valued 'Old Aird'. He also knew the value of such trust.
'Morning Brodie. Any news from my sister recently?'
'No Sir. Not since Christmas mail.'
'Well I'll be going home soon. So if you need me to take a letter, I'd be only too happy to oblige.'
'Thank you Sir. I'll be sure to let you have one.' The Major raised a hand to the brim of his hat then moved on down the trench.
'Morning Alistair, morning,' said the major, dipping his head to miss the low beam of the dugout.
Rab marvelled at his Lieutenant's broad smile. Moments before he had been cringing at every explosion.
'Morning Dad.' Alastair made to salute but the Major quickly drew his son to him. 'Will you take some tea Sir?'
'Indeed Lieutenant I will.'
'Hughes. Some of your excellent tea please.'
'I'm being promoted Alastair. Lieutenant Colonel Aird no less. What do you say to that, eh?'
'Well done Dad. You deserve it. Everyone knows that.' Alastair became larger than the dugout. He knocked over the lantern and the ammo box it stood on, blundering against the side wall, his excitement apparent.
'The only drawback is that I have to leave the Battalion. I'm to takeover the training Battalion at St Andrews. I'll leave as soon as we mount this offensive.'
Rab felt a little of the warmth and joy that surrounded father and son. As he stood aside to allow the major to leave the dugout, old Aird leaned close.
'I need you to take good care o' my laddie Rab. He’s all I've got. And you keep safe too.'
****
Wullie stood on top of the parapet. From down in the trench bottom, the background was an embroidered sky of black and gold and violet. The noise was incredible with the rat-tat-tat of machine guns underpinning the crump of mortars and mills bombs, and the deep throated roar of shells. Wullie blew lustily, his right elbow jabbing the bag of his pipes. 'Hey Johnnie Cope are ye wakened yet'
Douglas stamped his feet, watching the water splash in the base of the trench. The rest of the men watched Wullie; spell-bound by the act of bravery. Half way up the ladder, directly below the Lieutenant, Rab studied the white upturned faces of his mates. A short, local action to help straighten the line they'd said. A single battalion assault against a small German salient.
'These bastards know we're coming,'whispered Martin, bending to the level of Brodie's ear. 'We'll be lucky tae make the wire.' The big Corporal nodded, his eyes fixed on Wullie directly above. He grinned back; a savage rictus of a smile, and then they were clambering up the ladders.
****
Six hundred kilted warriors dipped their heads at the high-pitched scream. Major Aird of the Black Watch heard the scream as he marched in front of his men. Many of the men were too absorbed watching gutsy auld Aird, to notice the first of the heavy salvoes. Regimental Sergeant Major Grant heard that Banshee scream. It was the last sound he would ever hear. Wullie the Piper lay face down and curled over. The major saw that Wullie's uniform was in ribbons. There were no marks on his body, just a trickle of blood at each ear. As his lifeless arm fell, the bag-pipes squealed in final protest. Colin Aird heard that unholy squeal too, as he sat with his back against the shallow crater. The entire HQ section had been swept away, the grotesque posture of death robbing them of dignity. He couldn't raise himself. His right arm was useless. It hung from a single thread-like tendon, swinging gently in an unseen breeze. Something was pining him down. He could see around the curve of his chest, a blunt pointed object. With his good arm he felt around his belly, locating a metal bar centred at his navel. The point of the bar held a gobbet of shiny, bloody flesh; and the sudden movement seemed to send his body sliding down the spike. A barbed-wire stanchion had him pinned like a butterfly.
Chick Murray, the HQ messenger, returned to the section. Standing on the edge of the crater, he struggled to comprehend the loss. He heard Auld Aird intone a ragged Lord's Prayer over his fallen men, then he bolted. Major Aird was sure that the Lord of Battles would excuse his left hand salute as, raising his hand to his brow, he spent the last of his reserves in a warrior's farewell.
****
'The Germans will be back boys. They can't afford to leave us sitting across their front line.' Sergeant Campbell stood above his breathless, wide-eyed charges. Billy and Brodie exchanged glances. A study in concentration, Eck trailled his fingers through the muddy red water in the foot of the trench. Alan grabbed the lingering arm and pulled the boy round to face him. The dull, bestial expression hid the madness that crawled behind the youthful eyes. Alan's open hand smashed against Eck's jaw, the noise turning all heads.
'You bastard,' shouted Eck, throwing himself at his pal with both hands reaching for Alan's neck. The Sergeant pulled the two pals apart, thrusting Eck against the side of the trench.
'You stupid sod. Don't ever do that again tae one o' yer own. All we've fucking got is each other.' As Eck burst into tears, Alan held him in a close embrace.
'It's aright Eck, c'mon. Get a grip o' yersel. shue, shue,' he crooned, massaging the boy's tousled hair. The others looked away. By the time Lieutenant Aird arrived, Campbell had them all lining the firestep, in anticipation of the counter-attack. Rab watched the anger build in his young gentleman, as Sergeant Campbell gave his report.
Why don't you just take charge? thought Rab. Then he wouldn't have too.
'Lieutenant, Lieutenant Aird Sir. You've got to come. It's your father. It's the Major; Auld Aird. He's been badly hit sir.'
'What was that Murray? What did you say? Quickly man.'
'Yer father Sir. He's hanging... You hiv tae come Sir; he's dying,' he said more slowly. Without a word or backward glance, Aird was gone. Rab took off in pursuit.
No Man's Land was empty but for the cries of the wounded. A heavy smoke hung over the pockmarked ground so that the cries sounded detached. Rab cocked an ear as the German barrage resumed, this time over their own lines. He felt like they were running away. The quivering hiss of shrapnel seething through the air sounded from up ahead. A piercing scream and then Rab was stumbling against bodies.
'What the fuck?' Rab, not given to cursing, whispered 'Sorry' under his breath as he came upon the Lieutenant kneeling over Chick.
'The...crater...over there,... Twenty yards...he's there...your fath.....' Chick Murray had delivered his last message, his throat almost severed by the flying shrapnel. Aird and Rab saw the bubbling scarlet hole at the soldier's windpipe. Rab leaned across his young gentleman and closed the staring eyes.
'We'll never find him in this Sir.' whispered Rab. 'You have to get back to the boys. The Huns have them zeroed in.' But Aird was gone. Rab rose to his feet. Within a few yards he found father and son, and wished he hadn't. Alastair was down on both knees, hands to the sides of his head. He screamed soundlessly. His father's eyes were fixed on his son, his left arm flailing the air as he tried to catch the boy's attention.
'Oh God,' whispered Rab, biting his lip. They've not noticed me, thought Rab, turning around and moving back through the smoke.
'Rab. Rab Hughes.' He turned back in response to that voice. Colin Aird's failing command tore at his conscience and he stumbled across the crater towards the two men.
'Help him son,' croaked the old man. 'I need to speak to my boy. Please Rab - hurry.' Alastair's blank, soundless scream made the Private's skin crawl. He grabbed his Lieutenant with both hands and shook him, then pulled him toward the Major. The Lieutenant broke the silence then. The groan he gave was high pitched and seemed to Rab to go on forever. His father's hand reached up to touch his face, and he shuddered into sobs. The soldier turned away, unable to watch. Alastair quietened as his Dad mouthed breathless farewell. When Rab could bear to look, Alistair was grunting with the effort of trying to lift his father off the spike. As he helped to lift Auld Aird, Rab was aware of a bond now formed. A token of allegiance that left him troubled. He had time to ponder this as he stood over his two masters, rifle at the ready, peering into the now dispersing smoke. He turned in the direction of a loud approach from out in front, to see Sergeant Campbell enter the crater.
'Hughes? what are you two doing here?' He walked beyond Rab and stood over the kneeling Lieutenant.
'Leave him Sarge. His Dad's just gone.' Rab looked close to tears. 'Gie him a couple o' minutes, wid ye?'
'Mister Aird sir. You have to get back to the men. The Germans are pressing us sair; they want us out sir.' Aird pushed his father's hair from out of his eyes, unaware of the Sergeant's presence. 'Mister Aird. Your Dad's gone. There's nothing you can do for him noo. It's the men that need ye now. C'mon Sir.'
'My Dad was to be Colonel of this regiment. Did you know that Sergeant?' Alastair remained on the ground his back to the angry NCO. Campbell strained to catch the soft-spoken words. 'He was to be back in Scotland with my mother in two or three weeks.' The look of despair in his 0fficer's eyes stopped Rab's breath. 'And God flung him on that bloody spike,' he whispered. 'Now fuck off!' The shout flew naked above the earth. It reverberated against the banks of smoke, and Rab felt it raise the hair at his neck.
'C'mon Sir, your men are depending on you.' The change of tone drew the Lieutenant's attention. Ewan Campbell took hold of the Lieutenant's shoulder belt and hauled him to his feet. 'Now get a grip Sir, this is your job.'
The gunshot froze the tableau. Aird stood, the pistol held rigid before him. Campbell stood. head tilted in stupefied question. Hughes stood, petrified, horrified. The Sergeant's body, dropping like a sodden sandbag, broke the spell. The exit wound behind Ewan Campbell's left ear was enormous.
'You stupid, stupid bastard.' screamed Rab. 'You killed Ewan. Slaughtered um where he stood.'
'Oh God,' Alastair groaned. 'Oh God. what have I done? They'll hang me for this.' His hand opened and the pistol fell to the ground. Both hands wide, he stood looking at his batman. 'Please Hughes; please Rab. Help me.'
Rab crossed the space, put the muzzle of his rifle to the bloody mess behind the Sergeant's ear, and pulled the trigger. The face came apart under the impact.
'Sorry Ewan,' he whispered. 'We have to leave Sir. We have to go Alastair. Back to the men.' Aird stood motionless, uncomprehending. Hughes lifted the pistol and stuffed it in his Officer's holster. 'We have to leave your Dad for them to find.' Rab stood inches from the Lieutenant's face. 'We couldn't locate your Dad and we never saw the sarge. ok? We have to go.'
As they re-crossed No Man's Land Rab pondered the unseen lines he'd crossed since the assault began.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A Noble Lie?
Very powerful stuff. There's some beautiful description too; the sky embroidered with black and gold and violet really stood out for me. Those occasional images of beauty amidst the horror make for strong juxtapositions.
The quick inclusion of the German POV - I'm not sure about it. I think it works at giving the story some pace but it feels a bit underdeveloped.
Is there a break missing somewhere in the last section break? I got a bit lost between:
As they re-crossed No Man's Land Rab pondered the unseen lines he'd crossed since the assault began.
'All I'm saying is it's strange that they didnae find his father. Then Ewan goes looking for them and they don't run into him either.' Davy peered at his brother from neath the brim of his helmet. 'What, what? I'm just making a point. Just saying what everybody else is thinking.'
We switched to other characters, another conversation, without any indication and it was difficult to follow. But I found it very moving and well written, generally.
A Noble Lie?
a lot of this is very involving and full of action, but I must admit (despite having no other distraction when I read it) to being totally confused as to what happened. At the beginning, there is an 'Aird' who fills the bunker - which one? but then the second half just lost me. why did Alan hit the other bloke? I thought it was the younger Aird on the spike at first. I did not understand all the interplay and certainly not the 'Lord' stuff at the end. What was that all about?
sorry. it may be just me, but this just whistled past my ear :-)
A Noble Lie?
My feeling about this one, being perfectly honest, was that you tried to cram too much in, which made it difficult to follow the main story line. I think a much more restricted view from a single character's POV might have worked better. Trying to paint the whole panorama of horrors doesn't really add anything – I think we could identify more easily with one man's pain, and the power of the piece would not have been diminished.
My other reservation is about the ending. It seemed to come as a bit of an anticlimax after the drama of the shooting incident. We were back to the formalities of military procedure, which seemed a bit trivial after the enormity of what had just happened. Maybe this was deliberate, but I felt it made a very dramatic story tend to fizzle out rather than end on a high.
While the description was, by and large, a strong point of the story, there were a couple of odd phrases that I thought grated somewhat:
His eyes darted along the top of his brow
as he marched across the front of his men
head tilted in stupefied question
A good piece of work though, and as you said in the forum, very appropriate for the date.
A Noble Lie?
Again, bit late to the party here, but I had a lot of trouble picking the characters apart here too, not the least because of the shared names. Perhaps keep the name Aird for the Lieutenant and the rank for the Major? I was a little confused as to who it was who went back to the front as well. I'd also be inclined to lose the German PoV because the story is the confusion within the unit so you don't need it.
That said there are some suitably potent and gruesome images here that befit the content. The scream of the deflating bagpipes in particular stuck in my mind. That other-worldy sound that shocks even those living with death on a daily basis. And yes, it is the right time of year, lest we forget.
A Noble Lie?
franciman. I speak as I find, as honestly as I can.
on this occasion, I pointed out the holes (for me) in the piece, assuming you are capable of putting them right if you agree. I admit my generalised ' didn't understand it' (and that was in more than one place) might not be that helpful, but the alternative would be for me to go through and practically rewrite the story (provided I could understand it with repeated reading). I didn't want to do that, and I'm sure you wouldn't want me to.
You have written some excellent stories in the past, and I have said so. But I have to be honest. People here have offered you 'band-aids' to stick on it as it is. I won't do that because I believe it simply does not work as it stands, so can't be fixed by tinkering in a few places. My own suggestion would be to take a deep breath and rewrite from scratch with one eye on the original, perhaps more slowly and more focused in your approach. I know you have the capability to do this, otherwise I wouldn't suggest it at all.
But that's just my view.
A Noble Lie?
I would be delighted to read the re write if you take the advice given by E-GRIFF. You are to good to let this go; and so is the story, I found it gripping to say the least. Mike