From the UKAuthors Collection
Old School Ties
By franciman · Originally published 9 November 2012
Written in anger; and maybe an irrational hatred of the English Public School.
Balding-Young minor is now
a Major in the Grenadier Guards.
He once was de-bagged here; a really nice fag dear;
yet he never bragged, cheered or cried.
I read in the paper, sent out here by mater
In the mess drinking claret, he died.
Yes it's true; such a bugger
He was rotten at rugger
But terribly good with a bat.
Seems the claret was stolen
made his airway quite swollen
So he died at the Front, and that's that.
There's some talk of a medal
Seems he downed many bottles
even after his Regiment fled.
He's a credit to England.
To Windsor and Eton.
It's really a pity he's dead.
Isn't that so ironic,
but in the same paper
On the Somme Sixty thousand have died.
There's no call to be tearful.
Only five came from College
So they're probably not on our side.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Old School Ties
Ha! I like the juxtaposition of jaunty rhyming with serious content. It may appear that things are still the same, what with the Silver Spooners being in charge in Westminster, but - in my experience at least - the modern military is no place for the chinless wonder.
Good poem.
Old School Ties
The pompous elitism is beautiful in this. A breed apart. Nice one.
Old School Ties
Love the angry irony in this.
Old School Ties
A nice ironic piece. One or two lines limp a bit for me:
'Seems he downed several bottles' - (many bottles)?
and
'So I'm not sure they're on the same side.' - (on our side)?
Free advice, Jim, no charge for a friend.
Cheers.
Old School Ties
this has so much meat, so much flavour - leaves behind an acidic bite and a posthumous promotion?
i would have liked it even better if your first verse had the same rhythm as the following three, which were tight as a drum. that's not to say i disliked v1 at all, i just had to get my head around the difference in the rhythm this set up as i continued on down through the poem:
Balding-Young minor is now
a Major in the Grenadier Guards.
He once was de-bagged here; a really nice fag dear;
yet he never bragged, cheered or cried.
I read in the paper, sent out here by mater
In the mess drinking claret, he died.
it might be trying to keep it to the 6 line layout that's causing me a problem - if it were 8 lines... oh, i don't know. there's just something that niggles and it's most probably me and not you :D
one other thing, though, where you've amended that final line you've dropped a syllable and it throws the stresses out - it still works, if read more carefully, but again serves as a distraction where your preceding v's were so spot-on.
your message hits a home-run, no doubt about it.
Old School Ties
lines 3 and 6 rhyme in the other v's... hmnnn
there are a couple of ways round this to consider:
you could drop your original title and use the first two lines as the new one, or - in the brief description box - 'On the posthumous promotion of Balding-Young minor to rank of Major in the Grenadier Guards'
leading on to:
He once was de-bagged here;
a really nice fag dear;
yet he never bragged, cheered or cried.
I read in the paper,
sent out here by mater
In the mess drinking claret, he died.
this would not only keep faith with your rhyming of L's 3/6 in the following V's, but also initiate the 2/2/3/2/2/3 beats per line in them.
edited again to say i don't know why the extra line-breaks are showing but you get the gist :)