From the UKAuthors Collection
The Whistler
By Harry · Originally published 11 June 2012
When is a Whistler not a Whistler?
The Whistler
Harry Buschman
I have a few questions to ask Mr. Livingston ... five, as a matter of fact. Each one, separate and distinct from the other. He can answer them one at a time, or all together ... doesn't matter to me how he might want to answer them. But he better answer them - otherwise he'll find himself doing time!
I had a dingy old painting hanging on my living room wall. It wasn't much to look at. It was in a dark corner. Nobody ever asked me why it was hanging there, or who painted it ... it was a family thing, handed down. Nobody ever really wanted it. My grandfather painted it the summer he worked in Marseilles, a rather dark scene of sailors walking the quay, old sailing ships tied up to the dock, seedy taverns, a woman in the shadows standing in a doorway. Dark blues and browns and a dull gray sky.
Mr. Livingston was over one evening and asked me if I'd like him to sell it for me in his Village gallery. He's supposed to be an authority on things like that. He said the technique reminded him of an early Whistler. He knew it wasn't a real Whistler and he said he'd never stoop so low that he'd sell it as a Whistler, but sometimes people can talk themselves into something -- with no help from anybody else. He said it wouldn't surprise him if he was offered a hundred bucks for it. Sixty for me forty for him. About a week later he mailed me a check for sixty dolars.
I pocketed the money. About a year later I went to a Whistler exhibition uptown at the Frick Gallery on Fifth Avenue and there was Grandpa's picture on the wall. A card under it said it was "graciously" loaned by someone named Mark Berlin, the owner.
Well, a hundred bucks is pretty damn cheap for a Whistler, but it's just about right for Grandpa's old painting ... and that set me to thinking. Mr. Berlin and I have a few questions to ask Mr. Livingston.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Whistler
Nice one Harry, very droll. The Livingstone fella could have named the loan person as Irvin Berlin to further enhance the illusion of authenticity.
Regards.
The Whistler
Haha, lovely, Harry, as usual. I've spent a few weeks in Marseilles, and it is exactly as described here, except worse :)
The Whistler
Well, you could get even by contacting the new owner with the truth, let him go round and punch Livingston's lights out, then offer him ten dollars for the thing - everybody loses but you! Then, what IF your grandpa was telling whoppers and it WAS a genuine Whistler? Was his mother on the quayside somewhere doing favours for sailors? Mmm...so many possibilities!
The Whistler
Thanks for the enthusiastic, (and erudite) comments on this piece. My only solution for its continuation is that it might have been painted by Whistler's mother. The old lady was very versatile I hear.