From the UKAuthors Collection
The Brief
By e-griff · Originally published 25 May 2012
Story for the Prose Workshop Challenge - at last! completed one on time :-)
this has been edited slightly (on 26th May) following the comments below - specifically to try and diminish the hints that seemed to give away the ending. Of course it may still do so.
The Brief
The first step was difficult. Could he leave the safety of the comforting enclosure and move out into the open air under the threatening sky above? He had convinced himself it would be worth it, but the reality was challenging. He lifted his foot over the raised threshold and set it on the wet surface beyond the door. The enclosure at the top of the stairs was bare: plain walls, the smell of damp and neglect. He’d come up here on his own -- come up here from the brightly lit, colourful hall below. Luckily no one had seen him. Gradually the noise had receded as he climbed, reaching this final stair with the battered wooden door at the top. It had creaked open part way, and he’d had to lean on it heavily before it crashed open, banging loudly on the wall outside.
The outside was endless. On his left flank, a sloping wall of grey slate. On the right, stone balustrades encrusted with blackened moss and the pollution of the city. At first he could not raise his eyes above the parapet. With a great effort, he boldly took a look.
Shock! He was high up. There was nothing to enclose him. Beyond the parapet was empty space, stretching away. Buildings, a whole cityscape lay before him. He pressed back against the door, squeezing his eyes shut. He felt sick. For the umpteenth time that morning he questioned his actions, his motivation.
But he hadn’t come this far for nothing. Opening his eyes again, he raised them to look along the line of the parapet and the path he must tread, unprotected, unenclosed.
It was there! Just as he had suspected. Still there, untouched by man or beast. Untouched by the elements, or so it seemed. His grandfather had planned well.
It took him all his mental strength to move away from the comforting wall with its sheltering door, its inviting, dark protection. As he moved out, a gust of wind caught him. He had read about wind, knew what it was, but the physical presence surprised and frightened him. As the pressure built up on one side of him and the strong current of air pushed him towards the parapet, he fell sideways onto the slate, his fingers slipping in the damp shiny surface. It would blow him over that chasm, it was so strong. For a while, he lay on the sloping slate, sobbing, wondering if he could get back to the welcoming door and the sanctuary beyond. But he remembered Grainger’s words.
‘Your grandfather wanted you to be ready in case things changed, he wanted you to rise above the others. He remembered a time when all people walked in the open air. He thought that if the climate changed once more, they would again.’
He gasped. All people? He knew there were people who worked outside, maintaining the fabric of the city. He knew there were some in the country, outside the protective farming domes, who still lived a traditional life. But they were specially selected and trained. City people could never do that. How could he?
‘Your grandfather promised a reward if you can accomplish this task. Something to change your life.’
His grandfather had been a rich man, whose riches were tied up in a trust that Grainger administered. He’d never been given any details of the fortune.
*
He decided to crawl. The fierce wind buffeting the roof was threatening. It howled now and made bumping noises, very deep and worrying. Lowering himself to his hands and knees, regardless of the wet patches on his trousers and the rough, dirty surface of the walkway, he began to make his way slowly forward, his eyes on the briefcase.
*
‘You’re an idiot!’ Mareille’s voice came shrilly from the kitchen. ‘The Old Man never gave you anything and never will even now he’s dead. He was always scornful of you, mocking you.’
‘Grainger said I’d get a reward ...’
‘What? That if you go up in the open air on a roof and endanger your life you’ll get a case full of money?’
‘Well, he said a “reward”. I’m going to do it Marielle.’
Marielle came into the lounge and looked him in the eye. ‘You are too,’ she said. ‘Then you’re a bigger fool than I thought.’
The next day, he had gone to Grainger’s office for instructions. It had seemed simple. But the reality ...
*
He was about halfway when a massive gust caught him and filled his jacket, throwing him towards the parapet. The stonework here was different, the gaps between the pillars wider, and he was terrified. He flung his arms around a pillar and clung to it, sobbing piteously, afraid to go forward, afraid to go back. He wondered if Grainger had someone on standby, someone watching out for him, to rescue him. But no help came.
He was soaked through now, cramp aching his stiff arms which would not release their grip. In the end he had to. He slumped down, back against the pillar, wondering what to do.
*
He was cold, wet and now hungry. He glanced at his watch. An hour since he’d started. He looked down the walkway. The case still sat there.
He thought that the wind must have dropped. Its fierce noises were now gentle soughing amidst the pillars and stone decoration of the roof. He felt small tugs at his sleeves, but nothing more. Resolutely, he moved onto all fours and gingerly resumed his task.
*
He was three-quarters of the way. He could see the case clearly, the black leather, the gold clasps. The combination lock.
*
‘Nine, nine, nine,’ Grainger said. ‘Your grandfather had a sense of humour.’ He smiled.
‘And the reward?’
‘Within the case.’
*
Why couldn’t the Old Man have just left it to him? Why all this fuss? This performance? Looking up, he saw he was close now, very close. He wondered if there would be a cheque or a banker’s draft in there – or plain money? No, probably not big enough. But it was a large case, larger than a standard case – what they used to call a ‘Pilot’s Case’ for some reason. What if it were gold? That would be a lot of money. But he couldn’t lift it. Panic gripped him. What if he couldn’t lift it? He’d have to come back, with a trolley or something – he’d have to do this all over again. The thought sickened him.
Carefully, he approached the case. It was wet. He wiped the rain off as best he could and studied the top. The code wheels were set at random. One by one, he aligned them: nine (click) nine (click) nine (click), and tried the first clasp. It flew open, startling him. His heart pumping in his chest, he set the other code wheels and pressed the other clip, then folded back the top half of the lid and peered in. Nothing!
He raged. He felt totally let down, betrayed. What kind of fool had he been? He forgot his fear so much that he stood up, heedless of the wind, and kicked the case over.
The case tipped on its side, and the other half of the lid flipped open. An envelope fell forward and a gust of wind caught it, lifting it up towards the parapet.
That was it. Damn! It was there. What a fool he was. Carelessly, he sprang forward and grabbed the envelope, then found himself hanging over the parapet, looking down. He nearly let go of the envelope. He nearly fainted. He was sick. He staggered back, primal fear flooding his body, falling backwards, his head colliding with the edge of the slates, stunning him.
He came round a short while later, still clutching the envelope. It took him some moments to realise where he was, and for the fear to come back. Then curiosity overcame him. He tore at the envelope, and extracted a piece of paper.
It was a handwritten note. Congratulations, boy. I knew you could do it. You’ll not be afraid of the outside again after this, will you? That is your reward. You have something many do not – and in the future you may well need it. Grandad.
He was angry; blazing anger filled him. How dare he! How dare he do all this for some pathetic game!
Heedless, he stood and began to run back along the walkway, clutching the note, to go and confront Grainger.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Brief
This would probably qualify as science fiction, and because of that I found myself applying slightly different criteria when reading and assessing it. Character and motivation in this kind of story seem less important than plot and setting. The ending, and whether it can be predicted, also seems important. 'Show' and 'tell' still matter though, and I did worry about Grainger's remembered words filling-in so much of the background. I think it might have been more elegant to let us work out what was happening for ourselves to a greater extent. It wasn't all that complicated. Another example – why not let the protagonist see the farm domes in the distance and start thinking about the way outdoor life was lived rather than the narrtator telling us directly: 'He knew there were people who worked outside...' etc.
As to the setting, it hovered a bit between the present and the fairly-near future. It was a society that still used cheques (we've almost stopped that even now), where gold was still valued, and where the numbers 999 presumably still meant something (again, that's almost gone too). Envelopes, and ordinary paper money still seemed to exist also. For these reasons I wasn't entiurely transported into the protagonist's world, but I know I'm being a bit picky here.
On the bigger point, I'm afraid I did see what was coming fairly accurately, but I thought the tension was well maintained and the story was involving. My only real criticism is that I thought a lot of the background we could have worked out for ourselves without being told.
The Brief
I enjoyed the story and I thought you circumvented some element of the guesswork of the reader by having the envelope fly up out of the case rather than cutting immediately to it being empty. It did occur to me that it would be empty at about the half-way point, so the envelope caught my attention once more.
I liked the way you interspersed the action with dialogue to fill in the back story. It was well-spaced, but I do wonder if you missed a trick there by not using those dialogues as a window into life in the city. Some description of it, the artificial, enclosed nature of it, would make his terror on the roof seem much more real to us.
I quite like your Shock! moment. Such a powerful word But I felt you undermined it a bit by then describing the character as 'shocked' again a few paras on. If you're going to use such a strong word in that manner, I think you have to stick to your guns and use it just the once.
The Brief
First off - good to have you back in the challenge. It gives me longer to come up with an idea for my turn for one thing. ;op
With this though, I'm with David in that I saw the end coming which took some of the spin off it for me. That said though, I didn't have a problem with the 999, cheques et al. It may be a broken future but there's no obligation for it to be our future.
That said I think you missed some of the potential to develop the world with more subtlety. We get a lot about the physical challenge of getting to the suitcase but little of the wonderment at exactly what is outside, and as a result why people don't go out there anymore. His confusion at how wind felt worked on this front, because it makes you wonder and deduce.
An example of what I mean is this line, 'He was three-quarters of the way. He could see the case clearly, the black leather, the gold clasps. The combination lock.' Blue's right in that it helps with the pacing but it doesn't do a lot else, whereas with some observations on the landscape you can hint at a lot. (It's actually something I think Blue did really well this time as well, incidentally.) I assume they're living in buildings and underground by the way, or has he spent his entire life to date in the church?
Personal favourite bit are the (click)s though - there are some good sensory moments in this, which help you get up on the roof with him.
The Brief
It was probably the great reward and 'something that will change your life', yes. That and Grainger talking about his grandfather wanting him to 'rise above' (I like the play there btw). That said, I've read a fair amount of sci-fi in my time and it's a classic theme - an individual leaving the ruins of the old and confronting the new wilderness - so it may just be that I'm picking up on that.
I think the fear did come across strongly - I get vertigo myself so I was entirely on board with that. I get it going up spiral staircases, inside or outside, for instance, so I actually put his reactions down to the shock more than a phobia. That's just me though! I suppose I was left wondering about the world more than the narrator. Like what kind of world he knows and how'd they'd react to someone venturing outside. Is it forbidden for instance, or just not considered good sense? The more I think about it, it feels like an introduction instead of a complete story, it's leading up to things that aren't resolved within it. Not necessarily a bad thing, but what happens when he talks to Grainger...?