From the UKAuthors Collection
Escort Duty
By sirat · Originally published 4 May 2012
This is my story for the Workshop Challenges/Writing Exercises forum 4th of May challenge: a story where the main character is (or are) a nobody in a court.
Martin had developed a thick skin where the death threats and shouted obscenities were concerned, but having someone spit in his face was a different matter. It was an impressive shot, from the top tier of the raised benches across the wide aisle that separated the public from the barristers and court officials. He increased his pace, forcing his two escorts to do the same. As soon as the heavy mahogany doors closed behind them the party stopped and the older of the two uniformed men fished a packet of paper handkerchiefs from his pocket and handed one to Martin.
“Sorry about that, Mr Ellis. It happens sometimes.” He wiped the wetness from his cheek and screwed-up the tissue. The escort took it from him and flicked it into a nearby waste bin. “They always wait until the hearing’s over for the day. Then they can’t be excluded, or charged with contempt.”
Martin’s shoulders slumped. “Oh well. Thank god it is over.” He started walking again, towards the short flight of stone steps leading down to the corridor of holding cells, his faithful escorts keeping pace at either side.
“We may have to wait a little while for the prison van,” the older man said in a tone that managed to convey euphemism.
“Just like every other day of this trial.”
“I’m afraid so, Mr Ellis. The problem is, we have to segregate you from the other remand prisoners. You have to have a van of your own.”
“How flattering to be a celebrity.”
“Rules, Mr Ellis. Not my doing. Yours is categorised as a high profile trial. You saw yourself the way some members of the public treated you. We have to do everything possible to ensure that nothing untoward happens while we’re transferring you to and from Pentonville. Fellow prisoners are not always nice to one another.”
“You don’t say?”
They had reached the end cell, which contained three soft chairs and a coffee table littered with old magazines. Martin sat down. The older escort did the same, while the younger man took a seat in the corridor, out of sight.
“As you know, Mr Ellis, the rules require that I stay with you. But Bob out there will be happy to get you a cup of tea and a biscuit, or escort you to the toilet if you want to go. You might want to wash your face, after that little performance up there.”
“I’m fine for the moment thanks. I just want to unwind. And can we drop all this ‘Mr Ellis’ stuff? It’s Martin. You know it is. Presumably you have a name too?”
“I’m sorry, Mr Ellis. We… aren’t encouraged to get on first-name terms with the prisoners.”
Martin sighed. “You’re quite a man for the rules, aren’t you?”
He shrugged. “I’ve been in this job a long time now. I’m very close to retirement. I respect rules – they make for a simpler life. When there’s a rule, you don’t have to make a decision. They don’t pay me enough to make decisions, Mr Ellis. It’s not part of the job description. I believe in the simple life. I’m here to carry out the decisions of others. My father used to say that too.”
“So what’s your job all about, really? To stop me if I try to do a runner?”
“Not so much that as making sure you don’t communicate with anybody involved in the trial. Witnesses or jurors, for example. It doesn’t apply so much in your case of course, because you’re segregated.”
“You make it sound like I have leprosy.” For a moment neither of them spoke. “God, that woman prosecutor is a nasty piece of work. If I listen to her much longer I’ll start thinking I’m guilty myself. She’s a proper little hell-hound, isn’t she?”
“I… wouldn’t know, Mr Ellis.”
“Yes you would. Of course you would know. You’ve listened to this kind of thing every day for god knows how long. Before this trial I’d never stood in a courtroom in my entire life. Not even as a witness or a juror – nothing. Is it really going as badly as I think it is? Are they building the gallows in the prison yard?”
The escort looked him in the eye, seemed to consider whether or not he should reply. “Not a very funny joke, if I may say so. The last woman hanged in England had the same surname as you. Did you know that?”
“Yes, I certainly did. Ruth Ellis. Believe it or not, I’m distantly related to her.”
“That’s the one. Before my time of course.” He lowered his voice to a husky whisper. “I know I shouldn’t do this, but if you really want my opinion of this trial, I’ll give it to you.”
“Please. I would be very grateful.”
“Well, as far as I can see, they haven’t anything but circumstantial evidence. They can prove that you were in Mrs Wesley’s flat on the night of the murder, but you don’t deny that. In fact you reported the murder, which you needn’t have done. Her husband was there earlier on the same evening. He doesn’t deny that. Both of you had a key for the flat. Either of you could have done it. Of the two, I would have thought the wronged husband had the greater motive. But motive and opportunity aren’t enough. You’ve got to have something that actually links one or other of you to the crime. Some kind of forensic evidence that one of you delivered the fatal blow. And so far, they haven’t produced that evidence, have they?”
Martin considered this. He found himself whispering too. “Well, they must have something, mustn’t they? Otherwise why am I here and not Desmond Wesley?”
“That’s a very good question. How much do you know about Mr Wesley?”
“Only what Linda – Mrs Wesley – told me. We didn’t talk about him much. It wasn’t that kind of… affair. She wasn’t looking for a shoulder to cry on. Neither was I. We just… liked each other. We got on. We enjoyed each other’s company. There was never any question of divorce, or leaving our partners. It was just… a secret, beautiful little bit of both our lives.
“So what is it – this thing that I should know about Desmond Wesley?”
The attendant lowered his voice even more. “I don’t have the least idea. But it smells fishy. You’ve got a lawyer. Ask him to do a bit of scratching around. He should be doing it anyway, it’s part of his job. I think there must be some reason why the police passed him over and went for you instead, and that reason hasn’t come out yet.”
“Is anybody listening to us here? Secret cameras? Hidden microphones?”
The old man smiled. “You’ve been watching too many James Bond films, Mr Ellis. But Bob’s sitting outside that door. We’re not supposed to talk about the case. But now that I’ve got so close to retirement, I suppose I’ve become a little bit indiscreet. It's been hard, holding it back all these years. Because you’re right. I do get a feel for things that are going on around here. I do get a chance to… well, to spot patterns that the ordinary public miss. And very often, where there’s a rich and powerful man involved, and an ordinary man like you, it’s the ordinary Joe that ends up in the dock. I think it’s a bit more than coincidence.” He looked Martin straight in the eye. “Get your lawyer to do his job, Mr Ellis. That’s all I’m saying.”
“Thank you. I will. You’re a very intelligent man. Why didn’t you become a lawyer yourself?”
“Oh, I know my place, Mr Ellis. Crime and punishment has been the family business for us for many generations, but down at the coalface, not in the courtroom, where all the double-dealing goes on. In fact my father did meet Miss Ellis as it happens, but he didn’t know her for very long. Pierrepoint was his name. Albert Pierrepoint, public executioner.”
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Escort Duty
I found this to be an absorbing conversation, well written with the personality of the escort coming through very well.
I was interested in the case, so I wanted to know what happened there - what evidence did they have after all? I suppose that's a danger with using a court setting - the case can become as interesting as the characters! The only way I can think round it is to use what you've already got as a meat in the sandwich of the story, and bookend it with the defendant later on in life, perhaps, reminiscing about the trial. That would also free you up from having to do the exposition early on, all the 'as you know, you need a separate car' etc type dialogue that I feel comes across as a bit clunky.
But what you've got here is good, and it definitely held my attention.
Escort Duty
I'm with Blue here, it's solid and engaging. It does have that feel of being an extract from something larger, but that fits with the walking away from the courtroom as well. Personally I don't mind if short stories leave things open and just give a quick glimpse so that side of it's fine with me. It can work better to leave things unsaid and pithier than to fill in every crack with shorter pieces.
One thing I didn't get is the 'tone that managed to convey euphemism'. Am I missing a subtlety here?
The characters are definitely the strength of this though, in particular the guard. He's a perceptive and sensitive type, which means his family history could be counter-pointed to this in something longer. Sure, Martin gets all the drama, but he's not as distinctive. As Mr Ellis points out, the guards see everything, including unprecedented access to defendants, over the course of years. If you're filing things away, that's what I'd keep.
Escort Duty
Although obviously highly competently written technically, I found this rather stolid and uninspiring. As a reader, I felt I was being targetted by a lecturer, telling me a story, never letting me in to guess or bring my own interpretation. The tone was neutral and impersonal, as befits a 3rd person narrator, but I didn't get any of the emotions, hopes, fears or feelings of the main character. It seemed just a flat recital of some events which lead to a (rather lame IMO) 'punch line'. I'm sorry if this sounds cruel. You DO write in this style frequently, but usually we get motivation, characters and plot coming out. This seemed to me to be just flat and one-dimensional. Things like 'As you know, Mr ...' surprised me with their obviousness (ie simply a crude device to tell the reader something (sitting round a corner)) . And even 'Pentonville' - why? who cares? really unecessary overdone additions in my book.
Maybe I missed the core message. I'll come back later and re-read and re-comment if so. Sorry bout that :-)
Escort Duty
I really enjoyed this and it held my attention to the end. A wonderful crop of entries all round I thought.
One teeny tiny thing jarred (and it is a very minor thing) is screwed-up the tissue (more than likely because I associate screwed-up with being mentally stressed) and though that perhaps 'screwed into a ball' might be better?
Excellent as always, though, a winner for me.
Escort Duty
David, I don't think your comment on my supposed motivation (struggling) is worthy of you. I read, I react, I note my reaction, I pass it on to the author honestly and try to explain it. It’s my genuine opinion. Others may not share it, you may not agree, but what else should I do? I will say that the standard I apply to workshop submission is higher than normal, but that's what I assume we are in it for.
On your specific defences:
1. If you omit Pentonville, the story is unchanged. It brings nothing to the story. It’s a small detail in itself, I agree, but I chose it as an example.
2. Why on earth should you have to explain to the reader why he is segregated? All that is grey filling. Okay if a reader says ‘hey! I never knew that, great!’ – but I don’t expect they will. It strikes me as not just ’telling’ but ‘teaching’. It doesn’t advance the story or add colour or interest in any way. So, he sits away from the others, has to wait for a separate van – who cares/who cares why? The story is about the dialogue between the old officer and the prisoner, IMO it should focus on that. They can just be sitting there – no explanation needed (maybe just ‘waiting for the van’).
So, no, I didn’t ‘struggle’ to find problems. You simply presented them to me. But let’s be clear, I don’t think there’s anything ‘wrong’ with the story –no bloopers, no discrepancies. But if, in workshop, you present this, I think my comments are quite reasonable and I stand by them. And if I, in turn, am permitted to ascribe motivation to you, comparing this to much of your other (good) work, I gain the strong impression that you wrote it on ‘autopilot’ (which, yes, yes, I have been guilty of myself). :-)