From the UKAuthors Collection
Noblesse Oblige
By e-griff · Originally published 19 March 2012
belated entry for Prose Workshop Challenge (sorry)
Noblesse Oblige
Garland sat back in his armchair. As a junior minister in Carvallo’s government, he was entitled to a rather plush, if small, office in Whitehall and he was enjoying every moment of it so far.
The intercom buzzed. ‘Sir Ranulph Dixon, Mr Garland.’
‘Send him in.’ Garland got up, beaming, and walked across the room as the double doors opened.
‘Ranulph.’ He held out his hand.
‘Guy.’
Garland settled Dixon into a chair opposite his and rang for coffee. ‘Brandy?’ he asked.
‘Well …’ Dixon looked at his watch. ‘I have finished my business for the day, and if it’s the …’
‘forty-five …’ Garland smiled.
After they had sipped their small cups of Blue Mountain, Garland settled back with his brandy glass and raised it in a toast. ‘So, to what do I owe this pleasure? You asked to see me specially.’
Dixon leaned forward, placing his own glass on the low table that sat between them. His face was serious.
‘I’m sorry, Guy.’ He hesitated. ‘But I have something I must tell you .’
‘Tell me what? We have no secrets, surely? Go ahead.’ Garland waved his brandy glass in a sweeping gesture.
‘It’s about Lydia.’
Garland leaned forward. ‘Lady Lydia? Your niece?’
‘Yes, er, Lady Lydia.’
‘What about her?’ Garland’s eyes narrowed, and now he put his own glass down. This was an unexpected topic of conversation. Dixon’s lowered eyes and expression gave him the feeling that he would not like what he was about to hear.
‘Spit it out man.’
Dixon’s expression hardened. ‘Very well then,’ he said, ‘Not to put too fine a point on it, the lady intends to go to the media.’
‘What?’
‘She says she needs the money.’ Dixon’s expression remained innocent. ‘Well, I can’t help but recall your apparent fondness for each other during the weekend you stayed with us when your wife was abroad. And there are these …’
Photographs? What was the man up to? Garland felt less warmth toward him now – there was something more. Then he realised the implications. Damn! If this came out, he was finished. In today’s prudish climate, Carvallo could not dare to promote him, or even keep him on.
‘I’d be prepared to pay …’
‘On your income? With your expenses? Your wife does not come cheap.’
Penny certainly did not. She had been a great catch, career-wise, and status wise, cementing his presence in the ranks of the freeborn. But what right had this man …. Garland forced himself to hold back a reaction. ‘Could you not ... take care of her?’
For the first time, Garland detected the falseness of Dixon’s smile. He’d not noticed it before, or maybe Dixon had not wished to let the facade slip before. In either case, it seemed to morph into the predatory smile of a shark.
‘Well ….’ Dixon looked at his fingernails. ‘My own position is likely to be far less robust than it was, given the new Bill on taxation.’
This was it. Garland sucked the implications in and considered them. After a pause, he said carefully, ‘And is there any way of … improving … your position, as it were. Any way you can suggest?’
Dixon smiled again. ‘Section four, clause two-seven. Here is my suggestion.’ From an inside pocket, he withdrew a folded paper with some text on. He placed it on the table, and pushed it across towards Garland.
Garland did not pick the paper up. He knew what was on it. Wording that would presumably create the loophole that Dixon wished to trade on in his business.
‘But won’t it be obvious?’
‘No, it’s been very carefully worded by experts. If you handle it correctly with your civil servants, they will see it as an improvement. After all, you were a successful lawyer and are known to have a sharp legal mind. I also have back-up.’
‘What?’
Dixon laughed. ‘Experts who could make you believe black was white, who can be fished out of the woodwork should the matter ever come up for debate. But I am confident it won’t. Don’t forget my future rides on this, I’d not knowingly risk it.’
‘You’ve done this before?’
‘What a strange question.’ Dixon looked at him sharply. ‘I don’t think that concerns you.’
‘Then all this, your apparent friendship, the Lady Lydia, all part of a plan? Because I’m responsible for the Bill?’
Dixon smiled. This time a gentle smile, the one Garland knew. ‘I like you,’ he said. ‘I genuinely do. That was not play acting.’ The smile faded. ‘But business is business, as I’m sure you yourself know. I’ll bet you haven’t got where you are without doing something similar.’
Garland rose and went over to the intercom. ‘Mr Dixon is leaving now,’ he said. Scooping up the paper, he stood face to face with Dixon, who had risen from his chair. Very deliberately and slowly, he said, ‘I shall consider the matter.’
Dixon said nothing in reply, but as he passed through the double doors, escorted by the secretary, Garland heard the words ‘one week’ trail back to him.
*
Garland’s brain was whirling. He ordered that he should not be disturbed, and sat to consider the situation. Instinctively, he was disinclined to give in to Dixon’s demands because, like all blackmail, one surrender simply opened the door to the next. But Dixon seemed too big a fish to fight, a member one of the oldest freeborn families and probably very well protected.
He needed another mind, a trusted mind. Garland dialled a number and spoke softly into the telephone. ‘Duncan. I need your help. Now.’
*
‘Right. He’s an old-family freeborn, you’re a nouveau. What smells here?’
Garland looked at his brother, uncomprehending. ‘Dixon is a freeborn of the highest rank. He is honourable.’
Duncan laughed. ‘Honourable, like that Carvallo creature?’
Garland rose. ‘That’s enough! I didn’t bring you here to …’
‘What? Tell you the truth?’ Duncan held out a hand. ‘Sit down, let me explain.’
Garland acquiesced.
Duncan leaned forward. ‘Look. I know you better than anyone. You are the smartest lawyer around, you mince other people’s protestations with your logic. But you have a flaw.’
‘What?’
‘You’re a snob. You think the freeborn are perfect, cannot be deceitful, hurtful, that the world is like you imagined at school, becoming one of them, being granted freeborn status – making it! It was never like that at school – jealousy, envy, greed, control. How did you never notice that?’
‘I never did.’
‘You were lucky. I guess you had nothing to interest them, nothing to challenge, and your intellect frightened them – they wanted you onside.’
Garland rose. ‘What the hell is all this about? What does it have to do with my problem?’
‘It IS your problem. You walked into this, you are still walking blind into it.’ Duncan paused. ‘What makes you think any of this story is true?’
‘What?’ Garland sputtered the words.
Duncan leaned forward. ‘Here is an old-family freeborn, the most privileged class in our society, telling you this and that. Why would you believe the man?’
‘He went to my school, he is freeborn!’
‘By your own account, he is a blackmailer and a false friend. He has proved it. What would the Supreme Council say if you bared the truth?’
‘I could not tell, it is not honourable.’
‘But you asked me to help you explore the assumptions Dixon has made. By your own account, as a sharp observer of character and the parvenu, he has you bang to rights. He got you. He knew you would believe him. To be honest, I think he is pretty desperate.’
‘But he said it was a small inconvenience he’d like corrected …’
‘Of course he bloody did! I’m betting there’s far more to this than meets the eye. The new Bill traps several unwholesome practices. I’m betting he’s up to his neck and facing ruin. He would not go out on a limb like this if not.’
‘I didn’t …’
‘I know. You’re an innocent. But now, apply that brain logically – forget he’s old family freeborn, forget you are touting for elevation. Just analyse and decide. I can’t tell you what to do, only help, as you asked. ‘
Garland sat back, suddenly quiet. Thoughts were flashing through his mind, new ideas blossoming. He relaxed.
‘Duncan. Again, I owe you more than I can say. Give me a half hour and we’ll meet at the Dorchester Grill. Let’s relax.’
And, in response to Ducan’s puzzled expression: ‘Look, I got it, okay?’
*
‘You were right.’ Garland said. ‘It’s not true. Lynda is not a freeborn, she is only a plebite, not even a gentlewoman. He brought her in to hook me.’
‘So, in your world, that’s okay?’
‘Of course. It doesn’t count. Deceiving a freeborn woman would be disgrace though.’
‘But what about Penny?’
‘Why should she care? I have not made a freeborn associations, merely ...’
‘Had your way with a sweet child.’
Garland bridled. ‘ No! A procured, lower class female, purporting to be freeborn.’
‘Does that make your actions worthy? If you truly believed she was freeborn, you are as guilty as Dixon says you are.’
‘But she was not.’
‘And such is politics, brother, I now realise. Farewell.’
As Duncan left, Garland had a moment of regret. His brother was indeed a pure and honest soul. Still, despite his own naivety he was intent on improving his ideas. First, the crushing of Dixon, next, the slow crawl up the hierarchy to Carvallo and the top echelons of the freeborn.
He would make it.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Noblesse Oblige
I like the way you've intermingled some interesting ideas here, with the freeborn and the way that plays into the strict prudish climate of the government. I think the dialogue's very good too, and easy to follow. The tone is right.
You've got a typo - 'And to Ducan’s puzzled expression:'
Duncan seemed a bit wasted except as a foil for ideas, but I can't see what other role he could play. I suppose I wanted there to be something more, further. A final confrontation. But it's a subtle piece and maybe that wouldn't really work. I just feel a bit unsatisfied at the end; I'm not sure why. Hmmm. It is good, though. Maybe I'm just more in the mood for violence/shouting/kabooms.
Noblesse Oblige
There's some strong elements to this, as Blue say the dialogue flows naturally and both Dixon - nasty little toad that he is - and Garland are both entirely believable. There's something about the setting that feels like it's not contemporary, perhaps all the nobs and nobility, which fits the story well too. For me that's essential in fact, because I'm not sure people would make the distinction between adultery with a 'commoner' instead of aristocracy these days.
The problem I have is with all the talk of 'Freeborns'. It doesn't feel natural to me and pulled me out of the story a bit. This might well be how they refer to each other (being a 'commoner' one wouldn't know, what what), but for me changing that to something less particular would make it work better.
I'm with Blue in that Duncan seems to just act as a vector too. We know so little about him that it could almost be re-written so that he's deliberating on it himself. I'd perhaps lose Duncan and make it that way, or give him some more weight and identity.
Personally I'm ok with the subtlety of it all though, it suits the challenge well and politics is, after all, in the details.
Noblesse Oblige
Yes, you're right of course. I'd maybe flesh Duncan out a little bit more then? All, of course, merely my opinion so I may well be the minority.