From the UKAuthors Collection
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
By ChairmanWow · Originally published 13 February 2012
Happiness is a difficult fish to catch...
The three-year-old little girl and her young father
sit on a small hill under a tree as the suburban park
slips into darkness. They both hold long twigs
as imaginary fishing poles and pretend to fish.
"Fish, fish, fish, who can catch a fish?" the young father
picks up two varicolored leaves from the ground.
"There's one for me and one for you."
She takes the leaf and puts it in her pile.
"Fish, fish, fish, who can catch a fish?" He picks up
three leaves. "There's one for me and two for you.
That's a fine how do you do."
"Ha-ha, I got the most!"
Fish, fish, fish, who can catch a fish?" The father
picks up one big leaf from an evergreen tropical
plant. "There's zero for me but one for you.
Boo-hoo-hoo."
"You got none. I got a big one!"
"But you know what?"
"What?"
"This one's a shark."
"What's a shark?"
"It's a big fish that likes to bite little girls!"
The father pinches her on the side then tickles her.
She squeals and then asks, "I wish Momma like to play Fish-fish."
"No, your Momma doesn't want to play Fish-Fish."
"Is Momma too sad to play?"
"Yeah, your Momma is very sad. Okay, let's play.
Fish, fish..."
"Is Momma going away?"
"Yes, your Momma is going away," the young father
says after a short pause.
"Okay, let's play," the little girl says.
"I think it's time to go in now."
"No, again, please!"
"Fish, fish, fish, who can catch a fish?" He doesn't
pick up any leaves.
"Are you going away, Papa?"
"No, no way. I love you too much. Who would I fish with?"
He hugs her and then picks her up.
"Do you get sad?" she whispers in his ear.
"I get sad but not like your Momma." He walks her
across the street to their dark house.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
This is so very poignant. Beautifully and sensitively written.
Tina
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
Yes, very emotive and rather sad. Lovely, Chairman.
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
Yes I think poignant is the word. Very moving actually.
Romany.
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
Hi again Ralph,
Yes, to be honest I think that this is not only too dark for children generally, but that the subject matter might be way over their heads. I know we often underestimate children but this poem is written from the pov of the adult - children do not have the life experience or maturity to identify with the father here, I don't think. It would have to be written from inside the child's head, and I don't believe this is. I assumed from the off that this was written for adults.
Sorry if you were hoping for a different response but this is just me after all. Others may feel differently.
Romany.
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
I agree with all above but I feel Romany is so right, Have you thought of trying to write it from the POV of a child? It could work very well, but finding a childs voice can be a challenge, I have managed it myself a few times, particularly in this piece of flash fiction Written from the POV of a Down's Syndrom child. http://www.ukauthors.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=22213
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
Sorry I thought that would give you an easier link to the right page, but if you highlight the url and copy and paste it into your browser I think it should take you there if not, go to my home page and go to the 5th page and look for the story called Shana. Just to give you an idea of capturing a cilds voice. Valx Sorry about the ramble (-;
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
Sorry I thought that would give you an easier link to the right page, but if you highlight the url and copy and paste it into your browser I think it should take you there if not, go to my home page and go to the 5th page and look for the story called Shana. Just to give you an idea of capturing a cilds voice. Valx Sorry about the ramble (-;
Fish, Fish, Fish, Who Can Catch a Fish?
The make-believe situation is well described. I am not so sure that a three-year old girl would be acutely aware of the undercurrent but I concur with the suggestion of reading the child's point of view.