From the UKAuthors Collection
Never Too Old to Remember
By Harry · Originally published 20 January 2012
Some things are hard to forget.
Never Too Old to Remember
Harry Buschman
I looked up to see the special features editor staring at me from across the room. It was unnerving and I knew he was looking for something, anything to spark up the paper on this long, late Indian summer weekend.
“We need something special for Armistice Day. It’s coming up Friday you know. Something like ... heart-warming, you know ... inspiring ... you get what I mean. If we could only get that old bastard Whitney to open up we’d have some great copy.” He smiled at me ... almost lasciviously. “He was in the big one you know. Number one.”
That’s the last thing the special features editor said to me just as he handed me the address. “Take it easy on the old bird, it’s a little hard to get through to him, he’s 104.”
Mr. Whitney was sitting at his living room window. It faced the busy city street, and at this time of day it was crowded with people walking briskly in the bright November sunshine.
Mr. Whitney no longer ate at meal times. He was fed. He slept and relieved himself whenever his family felt it was time he should. He was apprehensive at the approach of night. He could not see well in the dark, and even though he couldn’t hear well, the noises he remembered from his youth kept him awake most of the night. He didn’t need his eyes and ears any longer but the memory of what he’d been through kept him from sleeping.
A great grandson slept in the bedroom with him. Not for protection or emergencies, but because the younger man’s youthful physical presence was a stimulus to the old man’s failing heart. If he were not there his family felt the old man’s heart might cease to function.
His 104th birthday last week was noted by his family but not celebrated. No mention of his advanced age was discussed in the house. Nothing was said about the future or the past––time was never mentioned. The present was limited to the brief span of a moment or two, it was as though a moment was all there was left. He was one of the few living men that had fought in the first World War, wounded in the Battle of the Somme only three weeks before the armistice.
I looked at him sitting at his living room window, staring out with half closed eyes and I wondered why they chose to put him there. He didn't seem aware of what or who was passing by. It was hard to think of him as a living human being. Asleep? Perhaps, but more likely dead or in some kind of unresponsive, catatonic state which rendered him unaware of anything outside himself. I wondered why a man would tolerate such a poor quality of life ... could it be better than the hereafter ... or maybe he was too far gone to make a decision of his own one way or the other.
A woman leaning on a cane stood next to him. I was told she was his his unmarried daughter Samantha. A woman in her eighties. She wiped his mouth with a silk handkerchief from time to time, and when she did so, the old man would seem to waken––his eyes would flutter a bit and he'd try to turn his head to look at her. "There, there," she'd say, then he'd drift away again to wherever he had been a moment before.
I told his elderly daughter I came from the paper to interview her father for Sunday's magazine section. "They were obviously not aware of his delicate health," I said. "Perhaps I should tell them it's out of the question ..."
"He's perfectly capable of answering any question you might have," the old lady looked sternly at me. "He remembers everything––but you have to bend your head over and listen carefully, young man. His breath is short and you may not understand him."
"Does he really remember the events of World War I?"
"Of course he does. Ask him. You do remember the old days, don't you, father?"
"Do you remember the beginning of the first world war Mr. Whitney?"
As far as I could tell there was no reaction to our questions so I asked it again slowly and distinctly, moving my lips as though I were talking to a deaf man. His daughter lost patience with me ... "He's already answered your silly question young man. Aren't you paying attention? Why did they send you? Goodness, you're really not cut out for this kind of work, are you?"
"I didn't hear him ... I don’t think he heard me ... maybe I should ask him again.”
She answered abruptly, "The war began with the assassination of Archduke Francis Ferdinand, the heir to the Habsburg throne ... everybody knows that."
"Yes, I knew that."
"Then why did you ask him? For Heaven’s sake. he can’t waste his time sitting here answering a question you know the answer to.” She turned to him and wiped the corners of his mouth again, “can you dear?" ... and again he looked up as though he had been awakened from a deep sleep.
I looked at my notes again and noticed there was one question the editor told me to be sure and get an answer to. It was about the details of the battle in which Mr. Whitney was wounded just three weeks before the armistice.
"May I ask one more question?"
"If you must," she answered coldly. "But be brief, he needs his rest, poor dear."
I brought my face close to his and mouthed the words slowly and distinctly, “Do you remember the battle of the Somme, Mr. Whitney?”
The old woman thumped the floor loudly with her cane. "That's enough," she cried. "How would you expect the poor man to answer a stupid question like that?
Out of the corner of my eye I saw the old man's eyes flutter and he turned his head towards his daughter. He stiffened violently in his chair. His legs shot out before him violently, jointless from hip to ankle. His daughter held his shoulders back in his chair, otherwise it appeared likely he may get to his feet. It would be unthinkable to see the old man stand.
All the while his lips moved spasmodically and he began mumbling in an incoherent and violent manner. It was apparent ... to me at least ... that if left alone a moment he might actually say something.
Perhaps there was something in that question ––something that triggered him. Was it possible there was anything he could add to the mountain of literature already written about the first world war and its final battles and its effect on the lives of the survivors of that long dead generation?
The old woman glared at me as though I had somehow been the cause of it all. “You ... you ...” she tried to think of something dreadful to call me and then both of us noticed the old man had raised his arm and pointed at me with an accusing finger.
It was the first time I heard his voice and I dare say his daughter hadn’t heard it for a long time either. I expected it to be papery and thin but it was surprisingly robust coming from a man his age. His eyes grew wide and seemed to stare at something that was happening far off and long ago, and while his daughter restrained him he said quite clearly ... “Mouquet Farm finally fell to the 11th Division, and we went on to Courcelette. It had rained during the night and the weather was warm for late October, there was the smell of the dead and the scent of phosgene and cordite in the air.”
He shook himself free of his daughter’s restraint and stared at me ... his eyes were in focus now, “I was with the British then. A corporal. The first day we gained a total of two miles and left a trail of 420,000 dead men in the mud behind us. You know what that figures out to be young man ... no of course you don’t. Well tell this to your newspaper ... for every inch we gained we left a dead man.”
I took his words down in Gregg, and I reminded him that the Somme offensive had been a great victory ... “It brought the war to a close Mr. Whitney ... the Germans surrendered shortly after.”
“The men behind us ... the men in the mud ... ask them about the victory, not me!” He was looking into space again. Something behind me. Something I couldn’t see. His daughter wiped his mouth again while looking at me anxiously.
“What have you done to him? He never talks ... look at the poor soul! There will be no further questions, do you understand?”
I had no further questions. The answer he gave to the one I asked shocked me into silence. It was an experience that must have festered in him a lifetime. “I’ll let myself out, Ma’am,” I muttered as I backed away from the old man. “I’m really very sorry to have been so much trouble,” I added, “but the paper ... you see ... they were hoping for something uplifting ... patriotic, you know. Something for Armistice Day. It’s this Friday you know.”
She didn’t answer me. Her attention was focussed on her father. She wiped the corners of his mouth with her handkerchief and smoothed a few filaments of gray hair that had become mussed during his outburst.
“How’ja make out with old man Whitney?”
I read him my notes ... “It’s nothing we can use, boss ... he remembers what it was like all right, but it’s not the kind of thing people want to read on Armistice Day.”
He leaned back in his chair and clasped his hands behind his head. “We’ll have to make something up I guess. Stubborn old bastard, I’d think he’d be anxious to see his name in the paper.”
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Never Too Old to Remember
I think I'm beginning to work out what it is I enjoy so much about your pieces. It's not just the characters, rounded and genuine as they are; it's the combinations of them that let you lift out the details. The way Mr Whitney, his daughter and the reporter act in relation to each-other tells three stories simultaneously, all of them worth telling on their own. And you make it look so effortless!
Never Too Old to Remember
Multi-dimension and smooth as usual, Harry - wonderful stuff. I can't believe how prolific you are!
Never Too Old to Remember
I'm glad you liked the little study of the relationships of three generations ... thank you both very much.
Never Too Old to Remember
Accomplished as ever Harry you draw the reader in and never a wasted word, the best of story telling...Leila