From the UKAuthors Collection
Joy
By e-griff · Originally published 19 December 2011
FOR THE PROSE WORKSHOP CHALLENGE
a bit hurried, but I'll tweak it. Wanted to make the deadline ...
Joy
Joy
[img]http://i169.photobucket.com/albums/u215/JohnG38/lastseefather.jpg[/img]
My daughter had arrived at eleven. Bustling in, she spread some gaily-wrapped presents on the table, and went off into her mother’s kitchen to make me a cup of tea. I could hear her opening cupboards and clanging about.
The boys tumbled in, and with a few cursory politenesses, settled into the chairs with their eyes fixed on their games. We exchanged a few words, and every time Gerda came in she told them to ‘stop that and talk to Grandpa’. I tried to ask a few things, but mostly they looked at each other and raised their eyebrows, then replied as if I were some kind of foreign sub-normal. But always polite. They were nice lads.
When she’d finished fiddling about in the kitchen, Gerda started talking about presents. I had to open them all. She made the boys cheer and clap when I opened the packets, and we all had to wear paper hats and pull crackers. She found my Brass Band Carols CD and turned it up – a bit too loud, I thought.
‘Look, some nice new slippers! What’s this? Something from Father Christmas! Oh, it’s a new dressing gown. Isn’t it lovely boys?’
It went on. Socks from May, a mug saying ‘World’s Greatest Grandpa’ from the boys, until finally we got to the bottle. ‘And whisky from Don, he knows what you like.’ Gerda smiled.
Don knew what I liked alright, but it wasn’t this: Tesco value whisky. I ask you! Still, they say it’s the thought that counts.
*
‘Eat up, Dad.’
I looked at the tinfoil dish in front of me, with its pale slices of meat with some light brown gravy clinging to them, a ball of stuffing and some vegetables, and picked at it with my fork.
‘It’s good to have Christmas dinner with your family, isn’t it?’ Gerda paused a moment. ‘Well, sorry Don couldn’t be here. He had a commitment.’
Down at the pub, I guessed.
‘Harry, Jim, eat up.’ The boys had some kind of turkey snack. ‘They’ve got to keep some appetite for May’s. You know what she’s like.’
I knew what May was like alright. Hated the bloody woman from the day we met. ‘How nice that Gerda is now part of our family, she fits in so well,’ she had said. Well, Don never fitted with our family, and he didn’t try – always on the fly, never could stop, off on some ‘commitment’.
They asked us to Christmas a few times at first, but it never was that comfortable. Later the excuses came, and when Helga died, that was it. ‘May feels you’d be uncomfortable on your own, that’s all. She sends her best wishes.’ And some socks. Bloody socks every bloody year.
‘What are you having?’ I asked.
Gerda looked shifty. ‘Oh, I’m okay, I’ve been so busy running around I have no time.’
‘Apart from that special breakfast Dad cooked up,’ Harry said. Gerda shushed him.
I ate my dinner, and the individual Christmas pudding. Gerda took the bottle and poured me out a whisky.
‘There, that’s lovely, Dad. A lovely Christmas dinner, presents, seeing the kids. It’s all warm, isn’t it Dad?’
There was something in her voice. This was our daughter. Our lovely daughter, the little angel Helga and I had raised. Now what?
‘Thanks, Gerda. That was wonderful. My best wishes to Don, the whisky’s great, and give my regards to May and thanks for the socks. What would I do without her?’ I smiled.
Gerda’s face relaxed. ‘C’mon boys – we have to be off to Grandma’s now. Say ‘bye to Grandpa.’
They did.
Before she left, our lovely daughter gave me a cuddle and a kiss on the cheek. ‘Look after yourself, Dad. It’s so nice to see you. Maybe see you on your birthday. But there’s always next year.’
This house is cold.
(very slightly tweaked 11.33 UK Mon)
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Joy
I like the last line, and the reflection on family politics. It's a bit short and sweet, but that works for me. You could weave in some description of the house/boys etc, but I don't know if it would really add much. I enjoyed it.
Joy
It's the little details that distinguish it. The observations about the food in particular tinge it with sadness, like the turkey snacks and individual puddings instead of one to share compared to the special breakfast.
As pootle says, it feels a bit short and I think that's because of the number of names involved. It's a complicated family in 670 words, especially around May and Gerda; I had to read it a couple of times to get the relationships properly. It definitely works as flash though and does reflect on the family politics well; all the rituals and trenches...
Joy
I like the general concept, but I think the fact that it had to be rushed shows a bit. There are quite a few names and family relationships to untangle. The very first paragraph threw me a bit. 'My daughter had arrived at eleven' For some reason I imagined an eleven-year-old daughter, possibly it's her eleventh birthday. Then she goes off to 'her mother's kitchen'. But if she's my daughter wouldn't her mother be my wife, or partner? Is this daughter also Gerda, or is that somebody else? Of course it all becomes clear as you read on, but I found that the effort of sorting out the family relationships detracted slightly from my enjoyment, and in the end wasn't all that important to the story. What mattered was the perfunctory nature of the visit, the shallowness of the family relationships, springing more from duty than love, and the chill of that last sentence.
I'm not sure about how to avoid this initial complexity. Maybe the narrator should simply tell us about his family – 'I had been waiting anxiously for my daughter to come down from Leeds with her two boys...' or whatever. You could even introduce a bit more pathos by making the relationships even more distant and awkward. Don hasn't just got him cheap whisky, he's forgotten that it isn't whisky he likes, it's something else. He's mixing him up with the other grandfather (or something). The boys don't want to talk, all they want to do is watch some action film on the TV. You could paint a darker picture without stretching plausibility in the smallest degree. I think the theme is a good one. Those are my only small reservations.
Joy
I stumbled a bit at the start- the use of 'politenesses' felt a bit odd, for instance, and as David mentions, there's a moment where the family relationships need disentangling and it distracts from the main theme.
As to the theme, this works well- the little things that are a bit off-kilter, such as the music being a touch too loud, the forced nature of it all, reflecting how the events are dictated by his daughter, keeping to her schedule.
Worth a bit more tweaking!