From the UKAuthors Collection
Red Roses
By e-griff · Originally published 12 September 2011
For David's Prose Workshop Challenge
Red Roses
We have a nice shop. Poppa lets me help sometimes. Jose is too small, but he sits and laughs when he sees me carrying boxes or something. We have everything. People say 'Mr Rodriguez, you have everything in this shop,' and wave their hands around.
It is true. There is even a refrigerator with food, there are tins, cleaning things, mops, buckets, toys, sweets, fruit and flowers. Poppa puts big red roses in the window. 'To cheer people up as they pass,' he says. But when Momma comes in he says, 'For you, Maria, your roses,' and they get all lovey-dovey. The shop is small but full. The shelves are so high Poppa has steps to reach things down for folk, but the big tall men who come in can get them themselves. Some people here are pretty big around as well; they have trouble getting past each other when they are looking for stuff. I laugh, but Poppa has told me it is rude to laugh at people, so I hide it.
People seem to like me. They ruffle my hair, which I don't always like, and say, 'Isn't he cute. Look at those big, dark eyes. He'll be a heartbreaker.' I don't know why I should be a heartbreaker. Sometimes I don't like the people. Poppa has told me to just smile, it's good for custom. I asked what that was and he said, 'People will come to the shop and more people will buy things.' I'd like to help my poppa. I don't think he's selling enough things, I don't believe he is getting enough 'custom'.
Some men came a few weeks ago. They did not buy anything. I hid behind the shelves because their voices were loud and not nice. They asked for money and Poppa said he did not have it. They said it was 'due'. I don't know if they were from the government, I don't think government people would shout like that – they have to be polite I am told.
I think most people are nice, but some aren't. They call us names. Poppa says not to take notice but it is hard, especially some boys at school. They call us 'dago', 'spic', 'wetback'.
Where we live there are lots like us, and also lots of the others, but they are all pretty nice. They don't seem to mind us when they come in the shop and chat to Poppa or Momma. They say my momma is a 'beauty'. She has long, dark hair and looks nice. Poppa is just ordinary. I see some men looking at my momma in a funny way. I think they are liking her, but maybe not in a nice way.
When the men came, they talked to Momma in a nasty way. Poppa shouted back at them and they got angry. He told my Momma to go in the back, and she did. One man pushed him, but Poppa was behind the counter so the man couldn't reach far. One of the big, tall men came in and said, 'What's going on?' and they went away. But said they would be back.
I remember my birthday. I wanted some trainers like other boys had, but Poppa couldn't afford them. I got some nice ones, but they weren't the right ones and the nasty boys made fun of me. But they were all my poppa could afford, and he did his best.
Momma looks after us well. We have nice food. Some of my friends of the others who drop round say their mommas don't make food like mine; they like it. That makes me proud of her. I'm sure lucky to have a Momma like her – a beauty and a good cook. She can dance, too. When we have our festival, she puts on her dancing dress and it whirls around her. She really looks beautiful, and wears a red rose in her hair. Poppa always looks proud, his chest sticking out, smiling all the time. Perhaps that's why he keeps the red roses for her.
Tonight there was a big noise, a big crashing noise. Me and Jose were asleep. It was late. The shop stays open very late and Esteban or Rafael come in to take care of it while Poppa and Momma sleep. But Poppa cannot afford to pay them too much, so he stays as late as possible and gets up early. Sometimes Momma gets up early to let him sleep and he complains.
Jose did not wake up. I crept to the door and opened it a bit. I could hear the shouting – it sounded like those men again, those nasty men. This time they were shouting more. I heard Momma shouting too, and Poppa, and the men. It was horrible. I was afraid. Then there was a big bang, and Momma screamed and screamed, then it went quiet.
After a while, I crept downstairs. There was no-one in the shop. The lights outside were off, which they never were at night, and the shutter was down on the door - I'd never seen that except when grandpa died or when Poppa counted the money for the bank. I went to look for Momma, towards the back room. The door was closed, but I could hear Momma making funny noises, and the men laughing. I didn't like it. I wasn't brave enough to go in – they are big men. I don't know what Momma was doing. I was afraid. I thought I should go back and look after Jose.
On the way back, I saw Poppa's shoes sticking out from behind the counter. He was lying down; the men must have knocked him out like people do on TV. But I knew he would wake up soon like they all do and everything would be alright again.
Then I saw the roses, the red roses all over the floor, crushed and dirty. The spilt water from the vase had gone all red. From the roses, I thought.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Red Roses
Wow! Great story. You've certainly taken things a few steps further than Kesang's song. I think you've made great use of the 'roses' motif. In fact the ending might be even more powerful if you left out the last sentence, or reversed the order of the last two.
The only thing that jarred slightly was the change of tense after the section division. I can see why it's there but I think it might be worth living with the slight awkwardness of retaining the past tense in order to avoid breaking the 'narrational spell'. The final sentence, the one I dislike, almost introduces a second change of tense, which is, I think, another reason to get rid of it.
Overall, a great story that I can see ending-up in a future anthology.
Red Roses
Yes, I like the awkwardness of the paragraph changes, very convincing in voice and just so horrible and sad. I felt a lump in the throat. It's obvious where it's going, unfortunately, but short enough for that not to matter, I think.
I like the use of the roses. Really you need to end with that image and do something about the tense change after the asterisk - do you really need the break? Just change the whole thing to present tense, perhaps. That would seem more childlike, in a way.
I've just read David's comment and realised he's said the same thing. That's unusual!
Red Roses
John, this story really rocks. I agree about the tense changes, though that in itself doesn't change the power and the message in the story.
Maybe the spilt roses seeming like the colour of blood to the child, should be the last line?
Great work'
Cheers,
Jim
Red Roses
I'm no proper short story critique but this held me from the first words. I could see it wasn't going to be a happy ending but had to stay with it. The roses and the red water; brilliant.
Daff
Red Roses
Have rewritten the tense at the end as demanded by several critics :-)
Red Roses
Hi John,
Something niggled at me after I read and critiqued this the first time, and I had to return to it.
I can somehow believe in the rape or sexual abuse of Momma if these men are after protection money. A singular lesson for papa, if a little overdone. However, it is not really feasible that they would murder Pappa (remember MC heard the gunshot) then rape or molest Momma.
The problem is that I thought this was a great story, but now look at it in the light of probability and it does not tick the believability box. Sorry.
Red Roses
Hi John,
I imagine killing him was a fairly stiff example! However, it is the feasibility of these men remaining, after an audible gunshot, to spend time molesting the dead man's wife, at the scene of the murder. These were men who had previously been warned off by a customer. Hardly the actions of men who think they are so above the law, C'mon, how much consensus do you need?
Cheers,
Jim
Red Roses
Good stuff, really enjoyed. You could ditch the last sentence (after the asterisk), would make much more impact imo.
Red Roses
ok, straw poll of my regualr poetry readers says 'cut it' - so I have (don't tell wifey!)
Red Roses
So having missed the previous versions this reads very well. It balances the comedic innocence with the horrible truth well, defining by mis-understanding. It is obvious where it's going, but only after 4th para. So it carries as a touching misunderstanding of the world by a child long enough for you to buy into the coming pathos.
Also, Jim's right in that killing off Poppa doesn't entirely make sense so the more ambiguous crashing noise works for me. Just enough ambiguity is the story-teller's friend, right?
George