From the UKAuthors Collection

The Curse of the Ninth

By Ionicus · Originally published 26 August 2011

Ex Prose/Poetry Challenge.

Even today there are endless debates
as to why Schubert didn’t finish the 8th .
Maybe he went drinking with his mates
or else he feared the curse of the ninth.

It is a superstition, believed to be true,
that nine or more symphonies are fatal.
Any composer will have cause to rue
transgressions of permitted quantities.

They cite von Beethoven as an example,
as he died after composing the Choral,
but contrasting arguments are ample:
many prolific musicians weren’t jinxed.

Could it be that our Franz was sloppy?
It is said he didn’t complete the 7th either.
Perhaps one day he got moody and stroppy
and scattered all the scores to the wind.

Alternatively he may have been dissatisfied
with the result of his musical creation
that was intended to be heard worldwide
and nipped the work-in-progress in the bud.

© Luigi Pagano 2011

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

RoyBateman

The Curse of the Ninth

Ah, yes, maybe it's a bit like the so-called curse of King Tut ("It's true, that is! You know, your poor Uncle Ernie fell down the coal-hole steps reading about that King Tuttifrutti's tomb in the Daily Express! AND he was never a well man afterwards, only lived to be 93, Gawd bless 'im.") in that only a few major composers actually got that far...Vaughan Williams, for one. Old Sibelius got grumpy after seven and packed up, Tchaikovsky managed only six. Then, Elgar only finished two and many of my favourite composers such as Puccini never even bothered with the form at all. And as for Haydn...as you say, there are many good counter-arguments! Interesting stuff, Luigi - we could do with more to make us think a bit, I reckon.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…