From the UKAuthors Collection
Et in Arcadia Ego
By franciman · Originally published 8 August 2011
For the Prose Workshop Challenge
"Please take a seat Father Saunier. Can we get you something? Tea perhaps, some wine?"
The travelworn Priest slumped into the chair, shaking his head in refusal. On the other side of the wide mahogany desk, the speaker sat at his ease. Cardinal Jacques Doueze, the Papal Nuncio, leaned his scarlet clad elbows on the desk, interlacing the fingers of both hands in front of his face.
"Perhaps Father Remigius might find you a bed for the night? You look exhausted Father. We could meet tomorrow?"
"Please your Eminence, it must be now. I have to....It is too heavy Eminence," he said, resting his head in his open palms.
"Okay my son, let it be now. But Father Remigius here will tell you I have a very busy schedule. We must be....expeditious, No? He gazed out of the large window, watching Paris take itself seriously in the April sunshine. He returned to contemplation of the young priest when it became obvious that Saunier seemed reluctant to speak.
"Father?" he said softly, receiving no response. The priest stared fixedly at the floor. "Father Saunier, the Archbishop of Toulouse asked me to see you, at your request, on a matter of pressing importance."
"I must speak with you alone, Eminence," said the priest in a hoarse whisper. "For the safety of my immortal soul. Yours also, I fear."
"Father Remigius please," said the Cardinal, with a flick of his wrist. The secretary glanced quickly at the taciturn priest then left softly and silently. "Now Father, what is this grave matter you wish to tell me, eh?"
"How would we fare without the knowledge that the Lord rose from the Dead, Your Eminence? What are we without the Resurrection? The Cardinal could hear the edge of hysteria in the question.
"Your crisis of conscience is hardly important enough to take up my time Father. You should speak to your own superior if you have lost your faith my son," said the Prelate in a softer tone.
"With the greatest respect Eminence it's not my faith, but our faith. My question is really for the Holy Father himself." Realising this last had been shouted, the priest put forward his hands in supplication. Slowly he drew both palms together in the attitude of prayer. "Believe me Eminence, I don't want to know what I know. I want to return to the simple faith of my childhood. Until recently I used to be able to do this with ease. Such simple steps are forbidden me now," he said ending in a whisper.
The Cardinal leaned forward over the broad desk. "Father Saunier, you are an ordained priest of Christ. Of course you are forbidden to return to a childhood faith; we all are." Jacques Doueze shook his head in exasperated fashion. "We aren't here to serve mankind Saunier, we are here to serve Holy Mother Church," he said, banging his fist on the desk in emphasis. "Now tell me what you bring to my attention, and not the whining of a child. Do not anger me further."
In that instant the priest seemed to shed a heavy burden. He stooped to the black bag at his feet and brought out a tube of hammered metal. The tube seemed blue in the light, as the priest removed a cap from one end and lifted out a rolled parchment. He walked across the intervening space to place the scroll on the desk.
"And what exactly is this Father?" said the Cardinal gesturing with his beringed right hand.
"We are rebuilding the Eastern wall of my church at Rennes-le-Chateau, Eminence. We found this and others in a lidded recess within the old foundations."
"Others? What others? You mean there are more tubes, more scrolls?" he said peering from beneath furrowed brows.
"Yes, Eminenence. A further six tubes, all from the same recess."
"You have them here?"
"No. I felt it prudent to leave them somewhere safe, Eminence."
"Safe? From whom? From me?" he said angrily. "Do not play games with me Father. Where are they?"
"Please Eminence," he said pinning the scroll with one hand and rolling it open with the other, "Please read the scroll." Saunier walked to the tall window looking out over the Rue Rivoli. Silence crept softly into the large high-ceilinged room and the priest became aware of the Cardinal's measured breathing. The crackle of the scroll re-rolling caught Saunier's attention. The Cardinal looked pale. He took a cigarette from an ornate box on the desk.
"Cigarette Father?" he said in a voice turned old and chilled, at the same time ringing a small bell. When Father Remigius entered the room both churchmen were obscured in a thin blue veil of smoke.
"Father Remigius will find you a bed on the premises and I will speak with you later. Would you be so kind as to bring me a magnifying glass Father, and a comprehensive Latin dictionary?" he said to his Secretary. "And I wish to remain undisturbed until further notice."
The Cardinal sat on long after the two priests had left. He slumped in the chair, his elbow on the desk supporting his head. With a physical effort he roused himself and reached for the telephone.
"Can you put me through to Cardinal Montefalcone please? It's Cardinal Doueze, the Papal Nuncio." The Cardinal lit another cigarette, aware as he did so that it was the third such in less than twenty minutes.
"Lorenzo, it's Jacques here. It has finally happened, as we have long discussed. Et in Arcadia Ego."
One week later to the day, Father Saunier was again travelling by train. The late morning train from Paris to Toulouse. In his overnight bag was a small box of fine Belgian chocolates for Marie Denaudan, his young housekeeper. Also in there was a promisory note to draw on the bank for a budget of Five Hundred Thousand Francs to rejuvenate his ailing Parish. In the same misssive was a guarantee of a further Five Million Francs to be drawn against the Vatican Bank. The priest thoughtfully handled the crucifix hanging from his neck. A well dressed, elderly woman sat opposite, watching him with some interest.
Saunier suddenly pulled the crucifix from his neck. He carefully studied the brutalised Christ lying in the palm of his hand, before tossing it through the open window.
"You have lost your faith, Little Father?" said the old lady her voice full of concern, of compassion.
"No Madame," he said, a beautific smile on his face, "I have simply lost my chains."
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Et in Arcadia Ego
I like this. It made me speed off to Wikipedia to fill in the gaps; I'm not sure whether that means it's a good story or not! It doesn't answer any questions but it does make me interested to find my own answers. Perhaps that's the most a story about religion can hope to accomplish??
I love the line about Paris taking itself seriously. I would have liked to have written that one.
I always want to put more commas into your work, but maybe that's just me...
I enjoyed it, and learned something too.
Et in Arcadia Ego
This one needs thinking about. You want us to do a bit of work, don't you.
'Et in arcadia ego' (I was in Arcadia also) is the title of two paintings by Nicolas Poussin depicting shepherds around the opening to an underground tomb. I assume we're to conclude that the scrolls contain evidence that the Resurrection was faked. Is there some significance in the fact that they have been discovered in a French church, that Poussin was French and that the Papal Nuncio is also, unusually, French (he would normally be Italian)?
Then we have the priest who made the discovery joyfully abandoning his faith (his 'chains') and (if I have interpreted it correctly) running away with his housekeeper and five-and-a-half million francs of Church money. The Vatican will of course be able to cover it all up, they're very good at that, and they aren't going to let the discovery threaten their position of power, so really the only one whose life is affected is the priest, Saunier.
I like the basic story but I felt I had to work a bit too hard to know what was going on, and I may still have got it wrong. Almost too little 'tell' in this one for me.
Et in Arcadia Ego
I knew what was going on quite early. But I didn't know what he was going to do. I think it could do with a stretch in the middle to ad a bit of a tangle -- not that I'd have an idea how to do that.
Et in Arcadia Ego
first on the side comments - surely you mean 'Christ was mortal' not that he wasn't crucified. - ie he wasn't resurrected (as David has said).
I think it's a good story, effectively told, but rather dramatic and thin on detail/underpinning, a bit black and white rather than teasing, thought provoking. Nothing to wonder about, go off an a tangent with.
So what if someone found a document saying Jesus was mortal and wasn't resurrected? Who wrote it? My guess is people wouldn't believe it anyway, it would be discredited. Cheaper than paying a priest loadsa money and surer than assuming he won't be back for more with the other five he's stashed, or he won't tell (unless they put a hit man on him). Maybe they put him on special duties at the Vatican and never let him out ..
So, why is he free of his chains? They appear to be moral chains - what? free of the guilt that some ancestor killed the son of God (but he rose up again as God planned, so was that really wrong? why should it involve guilt? Like Judas, it was all part of God's plan).
so what is he now then, Jewish or Muslim? Not that much difference, except for the uniform ! :-)
Et in Arcadia Ego
I understand. But (and you may be expecting this) truth is truth and a story is a story. Being true doesn't make it an engaging story. It has to stand on its own. This is drama, not documentary.
Actually, reading my comment, it does seem to be overly biased towards complaint. As I said at the beginning - good story, effectively told - wouldn't want my other comments to obscure that essential observation. :-)
Et in Arcadia Ego
I enjoyed the mystery/intrigue even though I didn't know the background. Don't know whether sirat's interpretation re the priest running away with the housekeeper is right - I suspect that's his fantasy, but I agree with bluepootle's comment about the commas - you do often miss them out. I thought it was a good story, and now, knowing the background, I'm going to read it again.
Et in Arcadia Ego
I'm obviously at a disadvantage because I'm not familiar with the factual background of this submission. I've got so say that this piece came across as a little over-written and it consequently deflected me from the body of the story.
If I may point out a few intrusive examples:
'wide mahogany desk'
'leaned his scarlet clad elbows on the desk'
'The Cardinal leaned forward over the broad desk'
'Jacques Doueze shook his head in exasperated fashion.'
'said the Cardinal gesturing with his beringed right hand.'
'He took a cigarette from an ornate box on the desk.'
'he said peering from beneath furrowed brows'
'With a physical effort he roused himself'
I think many short stories could be much improved by deleting superfluous details.
I notice that the Papal Nuncio is also referred to as Cardinal, Jacques Doueze, and Eminence. Maybe one title would be sufficient for a story of this length. There are a few random capitalisations that need weeding too.
Anyway, despite me being ignorant of the circumstances, your story was intriguing and I'll be off to Google more information.
Regards,
Steve
Et in Arcadia Ego
In the Prose workshop thread, my comment onthis being 'unabiguous' was challenged. so I came to read it again.
The story IS unambigous, clear. See, I read it as a story, not some historical account - I didn't lurch to google or anything - what does that matter, alll those details? - I'm not a professor of religion, not interested. It is the story that matters. I just read it for what it was on the paper, no more.
Et in Arcadia Ego
I really don't know how you can say the story is 'unambiguous'. I thought it was intentionally ambiguous – loaded with mysteries and unexplained goings-on. What is in the scroll Father Saunier has discovered? Is it something the Papal Nuncio already knows about? Why does Saunier not want to tell the Nuncio where he has hidden the other six scrolls? What does the Nuncio mean when he says that Saunier, and all of them, are 'forbidden to return to a childhood faith'? Is it because Saunier has lost his faith that he throws the crucifix away in the train? Is he stealing the Church's money, or has he been paid off in some way for keeping quiet? Why is he buying chocolates for his young housekeeper? Is he planning something with her? What does he mean when he says that he has simply lost his chains?
I suppose if you know all the history, and know also that the writer has stuck to the accepted historical interpretation, then a lot of the ambiguity and mystery disappears, but to say that the story is 'unambiguous' to the average reader seems to me ridiculous.
Et in Arcadia Ego
thanks, David. I'm happy to be ridiculous, then :-)
I meant what I said, thankyou. You may have tied yourself in knots looking for non-existent 'clues' , I didn't. Blokey took chocs for his housekeeper cos he'd bin to the big city (it also indicated he no longer had the scroll, he'd left it there). Aliya's contribution was judged good by most of us because it didn't explain everything. That is good writing. Similarly here, this is not 'ambiguous' - it is 'mysterious'. It's perfectly valid to mention things that are not explained, it enriches a story, IMO. The main plot was clear. I have enough of a vague idea of my own about the 'childhood faith' - that was enough of a resonance for me. and yes, you wonder about the remaining five. One of the things I thought was their return was conditional on the successful cashing of the big amount, but no, I don't know :-) . Also you wonder if he will apply the money to his community or himself.
It would be quite boring to be told all those things. As I said, this is a story, not a historical account. The fact it leaves you wondering, thinking about it is therefore good, IMO
No, I know sod all about the 'truth' behind it - and don't care. :-)