From the UKAuthors Collection
A Gift of Wisdom
By sirat · Originally published 15 July 2011
This is my entry in the current Prose Workshop Challenge. It was set by Bluepootle and if you want to see what it was all about you'll need to go HERE.
“I don’t believe it! It’s happened again. That sweet old couple across the street.” Morris put down his book and hurried to the window.
“Did you see them this time?”
She shook her head. “I wasn’t quick enough. But I’m pretty sure they were in a car. I just saw it vanish around the corner at the bottom of the road.”
“Thugs who put bricks through windows – in a car? Doesn’t make sense, does it?”
“Let’s go over. Ask them if there’s anything we can do to help.” She took Morris’ hand and led the way, before he could think of an excuse not to go.
ooOOoo
After a lengthy rattling of locks and bolts the door was opened by the old man that everyone called the Colonel, dressed in a rather severe dark grey suit and a spotless white shirt with a crimson silk tie. He smiled and wished them good night.
“We’re the Cunninghams from across the street,” Morris began, “This is completely intolerable. I’ve never known anything like it. People don’t behave like that in this neighbourhood. I can’t tell you how angry it makes me, the way you and your wife are being victimised. I hope neither of you was hurt.”
“No, Mr Cunningham, we’re fine. But it’s very kind of you to offer your sympathy. And your good lady, of course. How are you, Mrs Cunningham?” He looked at her affectionately. He was far from young but she couldn’t help thinking that he looked quite dashing. His accent was unusual, she thought. Latin American, perhaps.
“Please call me Louise, Colonel. And my husband’s name is Morris. I’m afraid I wasn’t quick enough to see them, but I’m pretty sure they were in a car. It looked grey, but of course you can’t really tell at night, under those orange street lights. Have you called the police?”
“Good heavens, no. What would be the point? Person or persons unknown in a car that might be grey? I don’t think there’s very much they would be able to do. But do come in, Morris and Louise. Have a drink with us.”
“Can we call a glazier for you then? Some kind of emergency boarding-up service?”
“Oh, we can manage. The downstairs windows have bars anyway, as you can see. Nobody will be able to get in between now and tomorrow morning. We’ll sort it out. Come in, please. It’s cold out here.”
They followed him inside and through to the spacious rear lounge, adorned with large exotic pot plants arranged around a baby grand piano, where his elegant wife was sitting at a wooden dining table bearing a cut glass vase of large white lilies. She wore an old fashioned blue evening dress that clung to her slim figure. Her silver necklace ended in a cluster of sapphires that toned-in with the dress. She reached up to greet them, squeezing each of their hands as her husband introduced them. He used the newcomer’s full names, but referred to the seated lady simply as “my wife”. They sat down while he made his way to the drinks cabinet and started placing bottles and glasses on a silver tray.
“You’ve been here for a few months now, haven’t you?” Louise said with a hint of embarrassment in her voice. “We should have come over to say hello before…”
“That’s perfectly all right, my dear. People don’t in this country, do they?”
“Were you about to go out, Mrs…?” Morris enquired.
“My name is Chalina, dear, but in English it is simply ‘Rose’. Please call me Rose. No, we were not going out. We normally dress for our evening meal. It’s a rather ridiculous habit that we’ve acquired, something left over from happier days.”
“Oh, but I think that’s beautiful,” Louise assured her. “Wonderful.”
“Do you my dear? And what do you charming young people do?”
“Morris is an architect – in a firm, with two other partners. I teach Yoga and Tai Chi. Just three times a week – night classes at Chester Tech. I can’t work full time yet, one of our daughters is still quite young.”
“Architecture is a wonderful profession,” the Colonel put in. “You have a vision and you make it a reality. I can identify with that.”
Morris smiled. “Well, usually it’s a vision of a loft conversion, or a granny-flat extension.”
Rose ignored the interruption. “Ah yes, I have seen your two girls. Charming. Quite charming.”
“Not when the older one comes in drunk and crashes out in the front room. Sorry, I shouldn’t have said that. Yes, they’re not bad girls really. Do you have children… Rose?”
It was uncomfortable to address the old lady by her first name, so commanding was her presence.
“No, I’m afraid we never did. We were a military family, always moving around. Then later Clemente went into politics. Life was very hectic, state functions and official engagements all the time. We never had time for children. We regret it now, but one can only do so much in this life. Decisions have to be made. It’s never possible to do all that one would wish.”
“Where was it that your husband had his political career?” Morris asked.
“A small Central American republic. I doubt if you would have heard of it.”
“It’s very hot there, isn’t it?” Louise wanted to hear more.
“The hot season is very hot, and the wet season is very wet. It’s a part of the world where the weather does not do things by half measures.”
“You must miss it?”
“Yes, some aspects. The sunsets, the sounds of the rainforest – the beauty of our garden, with the ornamental lakes and the magnificent plants and shrubs, flowering all the year round… but in many ways it was not an easy life. It was a turbulent place, where all my husband’s efforts were needed to keep order. A family in our position could never relax. There were many factions, hungry for power. Always… unrest. Trouble of one kind or another.”
The Colonel joined them with his tray and started to arrange the glasses on the white lace placemats.
“I see.” Morris toyed with a glass. “Did you rise high in the political ranks, Colonel?”
“Yes,” was his cryptic reply.
He showed them the ornate label of the bottle he was holding, a deep green background with the Spanish writing in blood red across a forest scene outlined in white: palm trees, enormous blossoms among twisted vines, and a little group of racoon-like animals holding their tails high in the air. “This is a liqueur from my country. It’s called Sapiencia. In my language ‘sapiencia’ means ‘wisdom’. You will please try it? It is made from cashew nuts, sorrel and ginger. My wife and I are very fond of it.” He poured each of them a generous measure of the green liquid and raised his own glass. “To peace and stability in our troubled country,” he said with a smile.
“To peace and stability everywhere,” said Morris.
They touched glasses and tasted the content. “It’s delicious,” Louise smiled. “Absolutely heavenly.”
“When you go home you shall take some bottles with you.”
“Oh, but we couldn’t…”
“I insist. The good things in life pass away quickly, dear Louise. You must enjoy them while you can. Share them with others, savour them. Hold them in your heart for the times when they shall no longer be there.”
“My husband can be a little morbid,” Rose apologised.
“Do you think you’ll ever go back?” Morris asked.
“No. That won’t be possible. We are dependent now on the hospitality of our former friends, like the people of the United Kingdom. Your former prime minister, Mrs Thatcher, was a great friend to my family.”
“Really? You knew Maggie Thatcher? Golly!” Louise was highly impressed.
“You too, perhaps? You call her by a familiar name.”
“Oh, no.” Louise was embarrassed. “Everyone in England called her that. It was a mark of… affection.”
“What a lucky lady she was, to enjoy the love of her people. One can not always retain that love when firm action is needed to quell insurrection. Sometimes unpopularity is the price one must pay for political effectiveness. The surgeon must be willing to yield the knife before the gangrene spreads, don’t you agree?”
“Oh yes.” Louise was a little puzzled. “I should think so.”
“But let us not dwell on unhappy things. Do you like classical music?”
“Why yes. I’m not an expert, but I have some favourites…”
“My wife was a concert pianist before we married. Do you have a favourite piano piece?”
Louise thought quickly. Did she actually know the names of any classical pieces for the piano? “I remember I once heard a Chopin nocturne that I loved…”
“Opus nine, number two?” Rose seemed delighted. “It’s one of my favourite pieces! How wonderful. And such a graceful and peaceful composition. May I play it for you?”
“That would be… fantastic. I’ve never had anyone play just for me before.”
“Oh, not just for you. For myself also. And for Morris and Clemente, of course.”
She walked to the baby grand and made herself comfortable on the stool. They turned their chairs to face the instrument, and she began to play. As Louise had fully expected, Rose’s performance was sensitive and flawless. She drifted into a peaceful haze as the music embraced her. This, she thought to herself, is the high watermark of human civilization. Calm and heavenly music, played by a mature and gifted lady, in beautiful surroundings, to her life partner and their honoured guests. Surely nothing could ever surpass this?
As the piece came to an end, and everyone applauded, and certainly not just out of politeness in her own case, Louise noticed that she could hear the sound of car engines outside – more than one. They stopped, one after the other, and silence returned. “I think there’s something going on outside…” she began, but Rose was not interested.
“Let me play you another of the nocturnes. This one isn’t so well known, but I think it’s very beautiful. It predates Opus 9, although it was published posthumously. It is usually referred to as Opus 20.” She started to play again, an equally beautiful and restful, but less familiar melody, and Louise’s anxiety seeped away.
As this piece ended Louise was certain that she could hear the beating of helicopter rotors high overhead, growing in loudness. Then the loud squawk of some kind of crude megaphone, the voice too distorted for her to make out the words.
The Colonel excused himself and stood up. He went to the drinks cabinet and returned with a black carrier bag containing bottles that rattled as he walked. “You’ll have to be careful how you carry these,” he explained, “I don’t think I have time to wrap them for you. Perhaps you should leave now, I believe there are some other people anxious to talk to me, and I wouldn’t want to place you in any danger.”
Louise took the bag and rose to her feet in numb incomprehension. “I hope you’ll forgive me if I ask you to find your own way out. Thank you so much for the visit. It was an enormous pleasure to meet you.” She turned to leave. “One more word before you go, Louise.” She looked back and their eyes met. “Never do wrong because you think a greater good will result. Never make that mistake. It is a pathway with no turnings, and only one ending.”
The loudspeaker barked again. The helicopter now seemed directly overhead. The Colonel started to return to his seat. He had to raise his voice slightly to speak to his wife. “Will you play Opus 19, my dear? You know it’s my favourite of Chopin’s works.”
As Louise and Morris made their way to the front door Rose, began to play the slow dreamy introduction that seemed to speak of a world of utter peacefulness, beyond time itself.
They opened the front door with difficulty, releasing the large steel bolt and unhooking the chain to do so. Outside, six bright sets of vehicle headlights shone straight into their eyes, obliterating everything from view except the helicopter with its red and green navigation lights, which was hovering just a little above rooftop level across the street, silhouetted against the moonlit sky, and causing a wind that threatened to propel the two of them back into the hallway. Yet the sound of Rose’s delicate piano-playing penetrated and remained perfectly audible beneath the churn of the mighty rotor blades.
The voice from the megaphone, when it came, was clearer now, the words perfectly distinct. “Put the bag down. Keep your hands where we can see them. Walk forward slowly.” They did as they were told, shading their eyes from the blinding headlights. As they reached the line of vehicles, arms reached out and pulled them to a taped-off piece of roadway behind the police cars. Uniformed police officers, one male and one female, frisked the two of them for weapons. Only then did any of them speak.
“Okay, what were you doing in there?”
“Visiting. Having a drink. They’re our neighbours.”
“Are they both in there?”
“Yes. Of course.”
“Anybody else?”
“No, I don’t think so.”
“Are they armed?”
Louise swallowed hard. “I don’t think so.” She paused. “If the helicopter wasn’t there you’d be able to hear Rose playing the piano.”
The officer thought for a moment, then spoke into a small radio that he took from his belt. “Can the air support pull back a bit, please?” The helicopter ascended, turned, and moved off out of sight. The noise of its rotors diminished sharply. Louise could hear the piano again – peaceful, unhurried, the melody winding down towards the closing bars. The piece ended, and there was a moment’s pause. Then, two gunshots rent the air, separated by about a second.
Officers shouted orders and men wearing heavy body armour surged forwards towards the front door and crouched down, guns drawn, awaiting the order to go in. The bag that the Colonel had given them lay incongruously directly in front of the door. Everybody surely knew what had happened, but nobody made any comment. After a few seconds, the men stood up and in an unhurried line walked through the doorway. The sound of the helicopter grew dimmer and all but one set of vehicle headlights died. Freed from the glare, they could see hundreds of their neighbours now, held back behind the police tape in both directions along the road. An excited drone of conversation was starting up. A small group beyond the tape to their right were holding up hastily constructed banners bearing words like “Murderer” and questions such as “Where are my two brothers?” and “Why have you betrayed your people?”
Morris turned to the senior officer who had been asking the questions. “Was the Colonel… a very evil man?”
“Not for me to say, Sir. He had an appointment at The Hague, but I don’t think he’ll be keeping it. It’s between him and his maker now. What you might call, an appeal to a higher court. All I know is that they’re still finding more and more mass graves back where he comes from.”
Louise shuddered and took her husband’s hand. He put an arm around her shoulder and held her gently. For a few moments, nobody said anything.
“Can we have our bag back?” he asked the officer at last. “It was a gift.”
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A Gift of Wisdom
I don't know what the challenge might have been, Dave, but you've got yourself a mighty fine little piece here. It gets a little hectic toward the end and gives a somewhat bitter taste to the genteel social call ... but that's irony I suppose.
A Gift of Wisdom
Yes, a very enjoyable read! (even with the occasionally overwhelming flurry of adjectives).
A Gift of Wisdom
Sorry, I was trying to avoid my sometimes heavy-handed approach by not pointing out the actual culprits. Although I appreciate you were setting a scene, I thought the narrative sections were sometimes overdone with description, especially: '..through the SPACIOUS REAR lounge where his VERY ELEGANT wife was sitting at a POLISHED WOODEN DINING table . She wore an OLD-FASHIONED BLUE EVENING dress that clung to her IMPRESSIVELY THIN figure. Her SILVER necklace..' Twelve-plus adjectives/adverbs in two lines just seemed a bit much. But maybe it's me?
A Gift of Wisdom
Overall a good little story indeed.
My methodical mind said to me, however, that it didn't believe UK police routinely shoot people who are going to appear at the Hague and be tried, and who earlier comments may have indicated were under their protection. I've thought round it several times and it doesn't fit for me, slightly troublesome I have to say.
A much lesser worry (I'm a worrier) is that she indicates her daughter is too young to leave alone. Yet they appear to have left her (the older daughter's out boozing by all accounts :-) ) It's funny how daft things like this worry me ... sad, I guess.
A Gift of Wisdom
oh yes, I misread it - the shots come before they go in of course ... :-) silly me ..
A Gift of Wisdom
Maybe I ought to go back to school. My apologies if I'm wrong, but I always thought 'impressively' and 'very' were adverbs - aren't they?
A Gift of Wisdom
Brilliant build-up here. Very culturally interesting. I wasn't keen on Louise 'just noticing' the baby grand - would rather have it built in up-front in the description of the room (yes, I want more description rather than less!) but could just be me being picky. I think it's very strong.
A Gift of Wisdom
I thought this was a great read. The many strands were introduced in a seemless manner and it is only predictable to those who have the benefit of reading the inspiration poem as the theme. My one concern is that whilst descriptive adjectives are fine, qualifying ones are author intervention. You gave us the Colonel and his wife so well that you didn't need to touch up on the references. I hope you see what I mean?
A super story, interesting right to the end.
Cheers,
Jim
A Gift of Wisdom
David
I hesitate to say this, but as you are someone who, years ago, taught me to be above all honest in critique, this is what I think on my second visit to this piece.
I felt bad about misreading the gunshot thing, but also , I felt there was something about the story that was leaving me unexcited and uninvolved, merely reading each step in the plot and thinking ‘I wonder what’s gonna happen at the end?’. So I came back again and read it with more care, taking my time, and noticing more along the way – and I did ‘notice’!
It honestly did not register with me first time (as I’ve said about poetry -- I read to enjoy, not to analyse) but when I got the first warning tinkles on this one, second time round, I focused.
First, punctuation: punctuation around interrupted speech we have discussed before, and here it is wrong (Morris began). But sure, that’s a minor technicality; commas – just a few out of place not checked. As Louise and Morris made their way to the front door Rose, began to play ... ; What you might call, an appeal...
These could all be seen as trivial, careless, fixed by a swift edit – I agree.
This is the biggie:
I think the story would be radically improved if it was written from the POV of one character (probably Morris or Louise), and dump the omniscient narrator (the most boring and uninvolving for a reader it is reliably observed).
but there’s more: speech attribution and intrusion. Some of this can be blamed on omniscient narrator, but not all. eg ‘He looked at her affectionately’ you can’t! ‘Morris was clearly intrigued’ was he? how do we know this? Is it by what he asks, in which case why not let that stand for itself and not give a narrative commentary on it? (similar is “ ‘Yes,’ was his cryptic reply” ‘yes’ is pretty cryptic in context, why say it again? ‘Morris modified the toast’ (presented as a ‘said’ substitute --- never!) and we know he did, we just read his words – why repeat it – are we that dim?
Then we have ‘said’ substitutes such as ‘put in’, ‘apologised’ (a little like ‘I’m sorry,’ she apologised. redundancy or what?) at least you didn’t use adverbs (as in ‘she apologised apologetically’)
Intrusion? ‘Louise was highly impressed’ (er, she did say ‘Really’ and ‘Golly’ do we need to be told?)
‘Louise was hesitant’ ‘Rose was clearly delighted’ (in the middle of her saying something which SHOWS she is clearly delighted. – again redundancy/repetition – all mush to bog the reader down )
After a plethora of speech attribution with intrusion, we have some places where there is no attribution and we don’t know who is talking.
Frankly, this is not your best writing, but also I don’t think it’s at all typical of your writing generally. Maybe write it off to a bad hair day?
On the basis of this, I’m hiking myself up to 3rd place!!! ha ha :-)
*wanders off belatedly, dreaming*
very best, JohnG
A Gift of Wisdom
and who the hell is Lillian? :-)
A Gift of Wisdom
No, it is not from Louise's POV as written, as is totally apparent (and I have demonstrated above), and that shows how much this story has gone awry.
David, I am not stupid. The intention of the story is obvious (perhaps too much so).
My comments above are on the method of achieving your intention. No amount of obfuscation/defensiveness hides that (you don't understand/it hasn't worked for you ... bollocks!) It's about writing technique, pure and simple. You may not 'be bothered' about attribution - but for a reader it's a mess . When were you ever 'not bothered' about what readers thought? Surely that is the point of writing?
This is not your typical writing, which is why I feel free to be so critical. It is multiply flawed. Maybe you were busy with UKAway, I dunno. BTW I have my own problems with writing at the moment (frankly, I'm crap :-) ).
So maybe the David Gardiner that I know and admire will simply say, 'Yes, this is a duff piece, I shall do better.'
After all, we've all done it. i do it often *sobs* :-)
sincere best wishes, JohnG
A Gift of Wisdom
Far too modifier heavy for my taste, but the story-telling is smooth and convincing and I enjoyed the read. A thoughtful piece.
A Gift of Wisdom
neither am I :-) as in fact I said MY (recent) writing was 'crap', not yours. Unless you want to disagree? (ha!)
I based my comments on what I normally expect from David Gardiner, not the average writer. I did this especially (yes, okay, maybe a little exuberantly, but you're a big lad :-) ) because Jim and bikerman in particular have been struggling manfully and working very hard (and it shows!) to master some of the very things you've let slip a bit here.
You've a reputation to keep up, man! :-) very kindly, JohnG
A Gift of Wisdom
I can see e-Griff's confusion over what he sees as an omniscient narrator. For me the story is written in third person past tense with Louise as the POV character. I think e-Griff sees the narration of the piece to be possibly over-descriptive. Also, although Louise is the POV she seems to carry only an equal part in the story of the main four characters (not that this should not make her a suitable POV).
Rather can get bogged down in the craft of writing theory I'll just say how I believe the confusion could be removed.
Firstly, Sirat could introduce the POV earlier. It is introduced in the third paragraph (after the beginning lines, which I presume are not optional?):
“No, Mr Cunningham, we’re fine. But it’s very kind of you to offer your sympathy. And your good lady, of course. How are you, Mrs Cunningham?” He looked at her affectionately. He was far from young but she couldn’t help thinking that he looked quite dashing. His accent was unusual, she thought. Latin American, perhaps.
This is confusing. One would assume the narrator is pointing out that the Colonel is looking at Louise. But when we complete the paragraph we undergo a mental re-alignment in our new POV and wonder if perhaps it was Louise thinking he was looking at her affectionately. And we only find out her name after a string reading the Morris name (she comes in the fourth paragraph after the beginning lines).
To cut a long crit short, to solve the problem, I would say the POV should be established immediately in the first paragraph, or possibly the second (in which it seems as if Morris would be the likely candidate, unless we were going to get a strict omniscient narrator). Also do a bit more of Louise noticing the objects rather than the narration simply describing them.
A suggestion was made that the POV should be made as first person present/past tense? I don't think this would work with Louise's character as she is not particularly interesting. I think the POV in third person past tense is the correct one but that it was not introduced nor used well enough.
I hope that might explain e-Griff's problem with this piece.
I enjoyed the story.
My criticism would be the poor handling (in my opinion) of dialogue in relation to action. There are large sections of the story that feature Manhattan skyline syndrome (see: "Brenda Starr dialogue. Long sections of talk with no physical background or description of the characters. Such dialogue, detached from the story's setting, tends to echo hollowly, as if suspended in mid-air. Named for the American comic-strip in which dialogue balloons were often seen emerging from the Manhattan skyline.
http://artlung.com/smorgasborg/Sterling_SF_lexicon.shtml")
Then there was the opposite: Large sections of non-dialogue narration.
Sorry if I'm not putting this crit forward well, but I'm listening and watching the cricket!
So in summary, establish POV character early and maintain it throughout the piece. Also improve dialogue (including thoughts) mixed with actions.
I enjoyed the ending as I could feel the off-scene activity and wondered what would happen when Louise and Morris left the house with the bag. There were many possibilities.
Cheers,
Tom