From the UKAuthors Collection
Majority verdict
By Ionicus · Originally published 29 August 2003
A dissenting voice.
'I will accept a majority verdict', the judge said with a sigh after the jury had failed for the umpteenth time to reach a consensus.
He had made copious notes during the trial and listened attentively to all the depositions and although the defence lawyers had made feeble attempts to undermine the evidence by objecting to every little point - 'M'lud, I must protest at the line of questioning of my esteemed colleague....', et cetera, et cetera, - he had concluded that the prosecution had proved their point without any doubt .
He had been in similar situations during his time on the bench, when an awkward individual had disrupted the smooth process of the law, and understood human fickleness, but surely this lot could not fail to see that this was an open and shut case .
One only had to look at the accused in the dock, with his sinister appearance and sinister looks, to realise that he was as guilty as hell .
So he did not understand why the jury was having such difficulty in arriving at a decision.
He had rehearsed in his mind his summing up and one statement that he was least likely to make was:
'You will leave this Court without a stain on your character.'
Once the foreman of the jury pronounced the inevitable 'Guilty' verdict, he would proceed to deliver his favourite homily:
'You are an evil man and a danger to society and it is the duty of this Court to protect the law abiding citizens of this community from the likes of you. You will therefore....'
He harked back to the good old days when he would have donned a black cap before spelling out the man's ultimate fate.
But the world had become so politically correct that not only had the death penalty been abolished, but he had to be very circumspect whenever he expressed an opinion.
Of course he had spotted the troublemaker among the jurors; it was that redhead with fuzzy hair. She was the nig...
He stopped in mid-thought and racked his brain for a more acceptable word.
She was the 'subversive' in the woodpile; that's it, that what she was.
He had noticed a look of disbelief on her face as she frowned and listened to the witnesses. He guessed that she was the dissenting voice which had prevented a unanimous verdict.
The heated arguments about the culpability, or otherwise, of the accused were still raging inside the room where the jurors had been cooped up for what seemed an eternity.
The foreman, still wanting a hundred per cent agreement even though the judge had indicated that he would consider a majority decision, was trying to convince the vociferous objector.
Yet she was not going to be easilty deflected from her stance.
'But don't you see', she was saying, 'it's all circumstantial. Take his alibi for instance; he could not prove that he was in Sheffield when his wife was murdered, but neither could the Police establish that he was anywhere near the scene of the crime. Also there were no fingerprints, no weapon. So where is the proof?'
'Yes, but what about the insurance policy on his wife's life taken out only a week before her death?', rebutted the foreman, 'Isn't that a strong motive?'
'It would be if it could be demonstrated that it was him who actually made the application, but according to the insurance agent it was a woman who arranged everything over the phone and the premium was paid with a banker's draft, so nobody can trace who made the payment. It could have been his wife for all we know.'
'I know he is innocent, it's not just a woman's instinct.' She added defiantly in a desperate attempt to sway the other members who had been watching the skirmish between the two with bored indifference, anxious to bring the proceedings to a close.
'I believe we have exhausted all the alternatives', the foreman stated with finality, 'let's have one last vote.'
A hush had enveloped the entire Court, everybody waiting with bated breath for the forthcoming deliberation.
As he heard the single word that determined his fate, the defendant stared vacantly, into space with an uncomprehending look.
The ginger-haired juror's eyes were fixed on the man in the dock as if trying to communicate her thoughts telepathically to him.
'I am sorry, my love, I tried my utmost to save you but did not succeed. I was too much of a coward to tell them the whole truth, which would have exonerated you. That I was the perpetrator of the crime; that you were in the dark about my actions and that you really were in Sheffield, were I had sent you on a fool's errand to get you out the way. And the insurance policy was also my doing, to give you some financial security once that dominating bitch was out of the way.
But you were a coward too, afraid of leaving the woman who made your life a misery. You left me no choice, so you must share my guilt.'
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Majority verdict
Nice twist in the tail! An enjoyable read and well paced.
I was slightly alarmed at the judge 's prejudices, would he really think the man guilty just by looking at him? I'm sure a lot jurors would, but isn't the judge supposed to be more impartial? I'm also slightly unsure about a guilty verdict based entirely on circumstantial evidence - wouldn't a jury nowadays look for some proof to connect him with the crime?
But really, I know very little about what people are pleased to call British justice. Given the number of recent cock-ups, especially the Lawrence and Taylor murder trials, nothing would really suprise me.
Re: Majority verdict
I liked this, and the twist. However, I was slightly puzzled as to how the juror could be the wife. How could she be called to a jury and identify herself - didn't the husband recognise her? Or did I miss something --- Pretty puzzling.....:-(
Re: Majority verdict
hi, the quality of the writing was there without a doubt but a few too many holes for me. purely from years of working in the black pit of insurance i know that its impossible to take out a life policy on someone without proving who you are and why you want it - you have to stand to lose out financially in order to take it out. but that really is so incredibly sad that i let that knowledge spoil my enjoyment! many apologies for my patheticness!
but the woman on the jury, that one was a step too far for me.
but i loved the opening and the telepathic end. good ways to break up the usual story beginnings and endings.
Re: Majority verdict
I think the murderer, and the juror, was his lover, John, not his wife.
I enjoyed this one too, I thought the plot was good and the twist (for once!) worked quite well. My only criticism would be in the mode of telling, where the point of view seemed to shift first from the judge to the foereman of the jury, then to the red-haired woman and then in the final bit in italics it went right inside her head, so to speak. I think it might work better if it was all presented from her perspective. She could still hold back the critical piece of information until the end. Very nice work though.
Re: Majority verdict
I apologise! Doh! *hits head with fist* yes it is clear - I had just jumped to a pe-conceived notion which was my own imagining. Go and have a nice cup of tea, I think!! :-)
Re: Majority verdict
Hi, bluepootle. I confess I am completely ignorant of insurance matters. I just imagined that given a strong motivation a criminal might be able to circumvent obstacles which an upright citizen like me might find insurmountable. I seem to have read of insurance scams, but I bow to your superior knowledge.
Re: Majority verdict
What can I say? I'm speechless. For once Sirat gives his approval (even though qualified).
Are we beginning to see the caring Sirat that britgrrl
talks about?
Only joking, mate. Any comment is always appreciated.
Re: Majority verdict
I know John. I get confused at times, after reading so many entries.
Re: Majority verdict
I don't know Bee. I assume that everybody is predjudiced to some extent, so why not a judge.
Re: Majority verdict
sorry, it was a crap point anyway. must be having a bad day.
Re: Majority verdict
Hey! calmo! (as my cod italian amici says) when you're good, you're good. Sometimes, you are not perfect *preens* comme moi! *sneers at plebs* ou M.Anonyme. *mysterious look*
Re: Majority verdict
Enjoyed this story.
Re: Majority verdict
Quite right, e-griff. Just to let you know I am always 'molto calmo'. I understand that many times words are spoken in jest and I like to respond in kind. There is a tongue-in-cheek element in my replies, no malice intented.
As for perfection, we are all perfect. Ask my mother.
Re: Majority verdict
Many thanks, richa.
Re: Majority verdict
Sorry Ionicus - couldn't get past the lover on the jury bit.
I liked the fact the juror/lover was apparently correct in giving the "not guilty" against the prejudiced views of the judge (and those of the jurors) - but was incorrect in doing so for personal reasons - that was a good twist or inversion - but, just too implausible for me I'm afraid!
Re: Majority verdict
Fair comment. I was expecting some dissenting voices. This is a good thing because it generates lively debates.
Personally I don't find it improbable that somebody might act for purely self-interest, whatever the circumstances; then perhaps I am a cynic.
Re: Majority verdict
No, no. You made a valid point. It made me realise that one has to research very thouroughly before writing on a subject of which one has a scant knowledge.
Re: Majority verdict
I agree with Geeza's comment. The plot holes, which have been mentioned and discussed elsewhere, prevented me from really enjoying this. Not bad though, just flawed.
Re: Majority verdict
I am sorry that you didn't enjoy this little tale but thanks anyway for taking the time to read it.