From the UKAuthors Collection
Long Shorts
By Harry · Originally published 8 April 2011
A reader's look at short stories.
Long Shorts
by Harry Buschman
Most short stories are too long. To be honest, I've never read a short story that was too short, but I sure as hell have read many that were too long. Get in, tell your story in your clearest and best voice and get out. Let your reader wish it were longer. That's the secret of a good short story. When short story writers begin to wax eloquent, my interest wanes.
Short stories take a lot out of a writer. There has to be a brilliant flash of inspiration for every one of them – new characters – a new initiative – a new look at life, and a willingness to be brief. That kind of writing will drain a writer dry in no time. Writers have a limited number of flashes per charge, and when the battery runs low there is an irresistible urge to conserve it, and their short stories get longer – they hate to let them go.
It's a lot like music. Consider the long winded composers who write block-buster after block-buster – they go on forever, or at least it seems they do. They don’t need batteries, they are self-winding. But the short story composers like Chopin, Mozart and Mendelssohn died young. They told their story and got out. We won’t forget them.
Another thing about short stories, they require input from the reader. You can skip a chapter or two of Stephen King and find the bogey man is still hiding in the closet when you get nack to it. There's no skipping allowed in a short story, you've got to read every word, travel on foot every inch of the way. Those are the rules.
The writer of short stories strikes a spark, shows a time and place, imagines a situation and populates it with believable people. Then it's the reader's turn to supply his own element of creativity. It is his job to kindle his own spark and add the experience of his own life's living to keep that fire going. So far as short stories are concerned, I believe brevity is the soul of both wit and communication. But if the reader, sitting alone in the shadow of his plasma TV has nothing to offer he will get nothing in return.
Read Genesis. It's a great short story. It leaves much to the reader's imagination . . . the time and the place are somewhat obscure and the characters are not always noble or fully developed. Would we tell the writer to go back and do it over? Some of us would.
Harry Buschman
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Long Shorts
Some good advice in this, Harry.
Long Shorts
I'm in two minds about it. I know exactly what you mean, but at the same time I can't remember a single piece of 'flash fiction' that has made a deep impression or stayed with me for any length of time. The point I think is not to waste words, to be succinct and vivid, but ultra-short stories seldom in my opinion achieve very much. Stories need to be the 'right' length for what they set out to do, never longer, but shorter won't do the job either.
Long Shorts
Hmm, I'm with sirat on this. Two of the best short story writers working today, Lorrie Moore and Alice Munro, are not exactly known for their brevity - but they're both brilliant and extremely readable. And one the the greatest stories ever written, Saul Bellow's 'Silver Dish' is thirty pages long. (Who wants that to be shorter?) It is sometimes difficult to read long stories on a screen, but that's not to say there's anything wrong with the stories themselves. As sirat says, a story has to be the 'right' length, it's as simple as that.
Long Shorts
I agree ... for what it's worth. It's only one man's opinion anyway. I somehow think there is greater danger in padding out a story to a length greater than its content merit, than there is in trimming off its fat. That 6-word epic of Hemingway (baby shoes for sale, never worn.) stay with me longer than Joyce's "Ulysses."
Long Shorts
I've seen that 'shortest short story in the world' in various forms attributed to just about everybody who has ever written short stories. Surely 'never worn' is much too long-winded and should be edited down to 'unworn' or 'unused'? The neatest version I've seen is: 'For sale. New-born baby clothes. Unused." I think it works so well because it's all subtext – all show, no tell. I use it as an example regularly when I do a short story workshop.