From the UKAuthors Collection

Highway to Alice (version 4)

By e-griff · Originally published 1 April 2011

coming home ... to what?

(first thing I've been able to write for months :-) )

This has been edited after comments from bikerman and Michel,and now the third version in response to comments from Aliya (bluepootle). I've not left the old versions. the phrases referred to in comments were weeded out in version 2. And I've now tickled it a bit and reordered the beginning - v4

Highway to Alice

I turned off Highway six onto the old town road. Five miles out of town, I pulled into the recreation area by the lake and took a stroll to get my head straight. I was sorely tempted to just turn around and head back to Cheyenne, but Pop had been convincing on the phone.

At the edge of the water, I got the ring out. It sparkled gold in the dying light. I made my decision, and flung it out into the lake, where it disappeared with a small plop.

I thought of Alice, and the trouble I'd caused. What would people say? Despite Pop's reassurances, I wasn't sure. Alice and I had grown up next door to each other. I regarded her as an older sister, but when she turned into a fine young woman, I began to have other feelings. I never took it too far, but I assumed she felt the same. She was always round our house, joking and chatting. My Pop used to say, 'Great girl that, Joe. You wanna snap her up before someone else does.' He was so right.

I took her on dates a few times. We saw so much of each other, it hardly seemed needed, but I treated her to some good dining and trips to the city shopping. We had a great time. I'd often find her waiting for me to get back from work. She'd leap up and hug me, grinning, then we'd all play a game of cards or something, and she'd stay to cook a meal for me.

What happened was bad. I was plain crazy with it when I found out she was set to marry. Sure, she told me in a kindly way, explained how it had happened, been a surprise. But I couldn't take it. Only that day I'd bought the ring and was set to talk to her so when she told me, it was difficult. I said nothing to her. Pop reckoned I should go away for a while, cool off and get a new life. Now he'd said it was time to come back.

I climbed back into the truck and fired up the motor. Pulling up to the highway, I swung left, heading for town.

*
The place looked the same. I had to go down Main Street. A few folks recognised me and waved. That was okay, but further on the Sheriff was getting out of the police cruiser and signed me to pull over. 'Okay Joe? Nice to see you back. Stayin'?'

'Just a day or so. Life's pretty good in Cheyenne.'

'I'll bet.' He winked. ' Plenty goin' on there, I guess. Got a steady girl?'

The question jarred me. But I responded in kind. 'Sure, nice girl called Maybelle.' She was.

'Good for you, boy. Everything settled now? Here I mean? No more ...'

'Sure, Sheriff. No problems. Talked to Pop last night and he persuaded me it was time to come home for a visit.'

'Okay, son. Better get off now or you'll be late for dinner.' He waved a hand and stepped away, leaving me to pull out and take the next few junctions until I reached our street.

*
The screen door flew open. Pop stood there, looking healthy as hell and grinning like a fool. 'Joe! Joe!' he called, and grabbed me in a big hug and pulled me inside.

'How are ya, son? You look well.' It was like he couldn't stop.

'Fine, Pop, just fine. And how's ...'

A voice called out from the kitchen. 'I'm fine too, Joe,' said Alice.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Bikerman

Highway to Alice

I enjoyed this; it kept my interest right to the end - but then for me it fell flat. It needs something more. We already knew that Alice would be there, so there was no surprise in the ending, and no interest in it. I'm not saying that every story needs a punchy ending - I like stories that are left in the air, but this felt more like disappointment, especially as the story itself was interesting.

Bikerman

Highway to Alice

'Worse, she was marrying him' made it pretty obvious. I realise you COULD have meant someone else, off-stage, but there was no hint of anyone else being around, so it was obviously the father that she was marrying.

Michel

Highway to Alice

The minute you say, 'I'd often find her at the house chatting to Pop,' even without the rest of the sentence, we know (it's been foreshadowed by Pop's earlier words about her, but those words telegraph). This is reinforced by further references to Pop, making him overtly the central character. 'Your Pop eats real regular these days' hammers the situation home.

The story seems to depend on withheld information to hold interest, with little colour or humour and quite a bit of repetitive presentation of his feelings (he doesn't have an individual voice, and explains his feelings often and in flat summary, ie, my heart sank, I couldn't take it), so for the reader to experience a pay-off after the build up to a surprise ending, it needs to deliver.

I think it would be better to have more confidence in your reader, get more texture into the writing, and place less reliance on a twist for interest - in first person, too, it can easily come across as contrived when information is withheld.

Michel

Highway to Alice

Yes, that's what I meant. The difference between *foreshadowing*, where a twist is surreptitiously set up so that even the smartest reader can't see it coming but is satisfied by it, feeling it falls into place with what has gone before, and *telegraphing*, which works to announce what is coming.

Bikerman

Highway to Alice (version 3)

I don't know. Did the first version start like this? Sort of wish you'd left that version up for comparison. But anyway, I found 'the tiny thing in my hand' a bit coy (although, to be honest, before it sparkled, I thought it was his dick! Sorry). Why not just say 'the ring'?

But the main problem is still the ending. The problem with a surprise ending (I mean, when the whole story depends on it) is that once the reader knows what's going to happen, there's not much left. For me, it would be better, instead of the last two lines, something like this: ' I knew she was there; the old man reeked of her. It was no use. I wasn't ready for this. I broke free of his embrace and walked away.' (Okay, that could be improved, but maybe you can see what I mean?)

Bikerman

Highway to Alice (version 3)

Yes, I suppose it is because I've read it before and so know the ending. But what really matters (for me, anyway) is that you're not telling a joke - so it shouldn't all be in the punchline (or if it is, it needs to have a hell of a kick); I still think the ending just isn't strong enough.

Also, wouldn't he have thrown the ring away when he first found out, rather than six months later? (If you do keep it as it is, you need to adjust 'I'd even bought her a ring'.)

Michel

Highway to Alice (version 3)

The writing has a lot more texture than the earlier versions. I think the scene with the ring comes across as a little stagey, and I didn't like him thinking of her, as he grew up, as 'a fine girl', just as his father did. That also comes across as oddly patronising (fine figure of a girl, good all-rounder, sort of thing), as well as dated. He wouldn't need flowery language, but I thought he would think of her in an admiring way, and simply as beautiful.

You still tell quite a lot, where you don't need to, and it's rather stilted, I think (The question jarred me. But I responded in kind.) 'Sure, nice girl called Maybelle.' She was.

(Perhaps it could be, " 'Sure, nice girl called Maybelle.' Well, she was." where he would show a grudging dismissal of her with the thought that she was nice enough.)

Using the -ing can be slowing, and can come across as repetitive.

The screen door flew open. Pop stood there, looking healthy as hell and grinning like a fool. 'Joe! Joe!' he called, grabbing me in a big hug and pulling me in.

I think something like this would be more active:

The screen door flew open. Pop stood there, healthy as hell and grinning like a fool. 'Joe! Joe!' He grabbed me in a hug and pulled me in.

Redundancy: 'he called' comes across as something the writer is writing out while he's thinking, and lacks dramatic punch. If we see 'Joe! Joe!' we know he's speaking loudly, and we know who's talking.

'It was like he couldn't stop.' is the narrator's interpretation but doesn't come across in what we read - if he keeps prattling on, show that. Dialogue is interesting and engaging.

I think the vernacular is a bit jarring. The dropped 'g' from -ing, for example. Once the tone is established, probably less is more. One of the jarring aspects of the down-home dialogue is the narrator's frequent formality and wordiness. He doesn't seem, in his voice, to belong in that setting.

At the end, I think we've read a far more vivid story now, definitely less predictable, but I'm not sure the main character has engaged in a way that makes us feel for him. It doesn't help that we haven't seen Alice for ourselves or heard any dialogue from her, so haven't felt emotionally moved by her, and from the hokey sound of the place, and Pop, we might even think there's something wrong with Alice's perception, and he's well off out of it, so the twist doesn't have a lot of impact.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…