From the UKAuthors Collection

The New Coat

By shadow · Originally published 14 February 2011

Sometimes, life could be very unfair.

All writers need to have had an unhappy childhood, to provide material for later bestsellers. In particular, an abusive mother is more or less essential. Unfortunately, most people’s experience does not fit the ‘misery memoir’ genre, but there is no need to despair. It’s all in the interpretation. On the surface, I was a normal, contented child. My parents did their best; they never beat me or locked me in cupboards or anything. They were more subtle than that. They simply did not treat my opinions and requests with the respect they deserved.

Take, for example, the episode of the New Coat. When I was small we lived in a semi in Crumpsall, north Manchester. The other half was occupied by a family with three grown-up daughters. ‘Auntie’ Winnie was the youngest. She was well-named, as she had a very high-pitched laugh, you could hear her right through the party wall. She was also considered to be an expert dressmaker, and one day she offered to make me a coat.

I was five or six at the time, and I was thrilled. A coat made specially for me! We went next door and, while my mother and Auntie Winnie discussed the details, I was given a pattern book to pore over, and told to pick one I liked. I turned the pages, marvelling. There were hundreds of coats, all shapes, sizes and colours. Then, I saw – It.

It was bright red, in a rather militaristic style; double breasted, with a belt and epaulets and dark green braid in a curly pattern on the front. There was a hat to go with it, a high crowned peaked cap, the sort of thing drum majorettes wear, but I was not bothered about the hat. I had fallen in love with the coat. I was particularly fascinated by its buttons. They were leather toggles, fastened with loops and I had never seen buttons like them before. It was, in short, the most desirable coat you could imagine.

I took the book over to Auntie Winnie. ‘Can I have that one?’ I asked.

And she said – yes!

The next few weeks seemed to go on for ever. I can remember asking, at no doubt maddeningly frequent intervals, how it was getting on. I was particularly anxious about the buttons. They were so unusual; would Auntie Winnie be able to buy the right ones? Each time I was reassured – the coat would be ready soon, I must be patient.

At last the day came, and my mother and I went next door to see it. It was laid out in the front bedroom, and I can still feel the anticipation as I climbed the stairs, went into the room – and stopped, confused.

‘Where’s my coat?’

There was a coat on the bed, but it was not my coat. It was blue, not red. It had no belt, or epaulets, or braid, and worst of all, no special buttons. It did have a matching hat, with a feather, but what use was that? I never asked for a hat.

I burst into tears and ran out of the room. I can remember standing on the turn of the stairs, bawling my anger and grief. The frustrating thing was that I had no words to tell them why I was so upset. All I could manage was, ‘It’s a horrible coat! I hate it.’

Eventually I was taken home. Once I had calmed down enough to listen, it was explained to me how naughty I was, and ungrateful, and how rude I had been to poor Auntie Winnie, who had made me such a beautiful coat (‘It’s not beautiful,’ I muttered). Also that the coat was made, now, so I would wear it whether I liked or not (‘No I won’t!)’.

It was the deceitfulness I could not forgive. If Auntie Winnie had said from the beginning that I could not have the coat I liked, I would have accepted it. But to go on, for weeks, pretending I was going to get what I had chosen while all the time making an entirely different one – I could not understand it. I thought she liked me. Worst of all, the whole thing had somehow become my fault. I was the one who had to go round and apologise. Why wasn’t anyone apologising to me?

It all blew over eventually. We became friends again. I wore the blue coat. It was, apart from being the wrong colour, wrong style and only having ordinary buttons, a very nice coat. Looking back, I think now it was a misunderstanding. Maybe when Auntie Winnie said ‘Yes’ she meant ‘Yes, that’s a nice coat’ not ‘yes, you can have it’. Or she just said ‘Yes’ to keep me quiet, and thought I would have forgotten by the time the coat was made. And when I asked about the buttons, perhaps she wasn’t listening. Grown-ups often did not listen, even when you were saying something important.

No-one ever admitted to being at fault, but then grown-ups never did. I think, though, Auntie Winnie did have some idea of the enormity of what she had done. The next year she got married, and asked me to be one of her bridesmaids. Again I went next door to look through the pattern books. This time I did not go for the most elaborate design, the one with the wide skirt covered in deep flounces. I chose something simpler, which I thought Auntie Winnie could manage. And this time, I got what I had chosen, down to the last frill.

So you see, even my uneventful childhood was not without its traumatic moments. I got over it, as one does. But even now, after sixty years, I still feel a pang of grief over the loss of my beautiful red coat, with its leather buttons.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

RoyBateman

The New Coat

Really fascinating...yes, these childhood incidents never leave you, do they? In this case, it really is difficult to see why on earth you didn't get what you wanted - it's clearly puzzled you ever since, and I can't see sense in it either! I reckon that kides, even more than adults, have a highly-developed sense of right and wrong, and anything that deviates from their expectations comes as a real shock: as it did here. It's almost as if the aduklts were being deliberately obstructive, though I can't see any logical reason for such a thing...and nor can you, even to this day. Yes, it does seem trivial compared with the abuse - real or imagined - that so many (ghost) writers have made a fortune out of, and God alone knows why there's a market for it, but the memory lingers...

geordietaf

The New Coat

Nicely written. Adults often make the mistake of thinking they can just bluff their kids into wanting what they, the parents, want for them. It never really works.

EleanorP

The New Coat

It *was* abusive in one sense - your trust was damaged. But I know what you mean. I guess some of us were more resilient because we were loved well enough, and others who 'write' these memoirs were less so and therefore more damaged, or else they know that sexual abuse and neglect pay higher fees!

I have written something very nearly the same as yours for a memoir competition last year. Funny how clothing was such an issue 60 years ago. Maybe post-war mentality came into it. Good piece and well written.

Ionicus

The New Coat

Philip Larkin had his finger on the pulse when he said that children are messed up by their parents. One would think that when children become parents themselves they would act differently but they seem to turn into their mother and father clones. Mind you, kids can transform incidents into Greek tragedies.

You can console yourself that that perceived slight has provided you with material that shows your skill as a writer.

Luigi x

Bradene

The New Coat

I can totally relate to this story, I had a loving childhood but as you say there were often moments of great injustices, or so it seemed. I quickly learned not to ask, because I would never get. I realise now that money was tight, but at the time no one bothered to tell me, and I had always to content myself with my sisters hand-me-downs. Loved your story, you told it so well, I felt your anguish. Valx

woodbine

The New Coat

It sounds to me like a story of trust betrayed. My grandfather took me to the park and offered me a brown bottle to smell. Being full of ammonia smelling salts it nearly knocked me off my feet. He in fact did me a favour. I learned that you can't trust all adults which is a valuable lesson.

Nicely written.

John X

stormwolf

The New Coat

I can relate to the sense of outrage and disappointment. A tomboy all my childhood, my mother suddenly decided to buy me a tweed cape with matching baker boy style hat! The ugliest thing I had ever seen and her anger and indignation about how much it cost was lost on a child who could not understand a mother who was SO far out in understanding her daughter.

Even now, I remember it and shudder. Someone passed me just the other day wearing one something like it.

But she looked the sort of girl it was intended for.

lol

Alison x

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…