From the UKAuthors Collection
Snowfall
By Elfstone · Originally published 3 December 2010
This won the weekly Challenge on Wednesday (I was very chuffed!) so I thought it might be worth giving it an airing here.
Snowfall
The old woman trudges slowly
across a seeming field
of untouched snow,
the soundless evening
creeping on to icy dusk.
Crunch -
crunch;
the breaking crystals
drill through frozen silence.
Her breath steams,
her wheezing numbed by
the weight of frigid air.
A muffling layer of white
leeches out the warmth of her.
Crunch -
crunch,
by familiar landmarks,
eery, distorted lumps,
thickened beyond knowing.
The old woman struggles on,
dragging her bags wearily through
a soft floating of pretty flakes.
Unforgiving, insidious,
these tiny bits of death
suggest perhaps that
Hell is not so fiery after all.
© Elfstone 30/11/10
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Snowfall
A popular win and well deserved. Very nibworthy too. Well done Love Valx
Snowfall
First quality, Elf, duly rewarded.
Luigi x
Snowfall
Really good Elf you captured the cold harshness of it...pretty as a picture but lethal in many ways...Leila
Snowfall
hi Sir Elf of Stone - an icy tale indeed which I enjoyed and well worth a nibblet but I have a few minor suggestions which I hope you won't mind considering: "across a seeming field" was odd grammar - how about seamless instead that reflects the white smothering blanket.
Sorry but, "crunch crunch" was a little like an onomatopaiec breakfast cereal advert - it's too obvious and you're missing a great chance for a double-alliterative reinforcement which removes the weird 'drill' verb and adds tempo: i.e.
the crunch of brittle crystals
breaking cleaves the frozen silence. (for example)
Her breath steams,
wheezing lungs numbed
by the touch of frigid air
as the muffle-white parasite
leeches the heat from her bones. (is a suggestion where the biting chill is reinforced as a living enemy and composite adjectives add interest)
Crunch -
crunch,
by familiar landmarks,
eery, distorted lumps,
thickened beyond knowing. (is there any chance of removing that 'crunch crunch' Frosties and developing this stanza? ie when you pass familiar landmarks they are shrouded, disorienting, ghost-like - more than merely eerie for example.
The old woman struggles on,
dragging her bags wearily through
a soft floating of pretty flakes. (by this time 'a soft floating of pretty flakes' won't register with an exhausted elderly woman - cloying or some darker adjective is needed. Two elderly people have just frozen to death in their gardens - pretty flakes doesn't cut it.)
Unforgiving, insidious,
these tiny bits of death
suggest perhaps that
Hell is not so fiery after all. (A fine closer but perhaps the perhaps is not needed - cold cuts like a knife so maybe 'scythes' will do i.e. ).
those tiny crystal scythes
suggests that Hell cuts flesh
through fire and ice... (ie try something composite rather than the obvious last line.)
HOPE THIS HELPS! Cheers. mitch :-)
Hope you don't mind this detailed crit!
Snowfall
Heh! You're not kidding - it really morphs the poem and makes for an intersting new slant. Thanks for the detailed defence of your original which made for a decent debate on poetical form - and a big thanks for for not taking offence too. Greatly appreciated! I recently tried out www.poetrycritical.net but it is a total bear-pit - worth a visit but you have to wade through reams of abuse and drivel toget some decent crit!
PS Would you return the favour and do a ruthless crit on Towers in the Mist for me? I need a fresh perspective on it as it stutters badly. Thanks!
Snowfall
lovely nice pome, Elf, as I thought when I first read it - you wee bastard! :-)
Snowfall
Are you really a sir, Elf? I see Mitch keeps referring to you as such. I dunno why, I always assumed you were a Ms. I must stop assuming. It can only cause me hardship. I currently have a garage full of Rubik's Pyramids because I assumed they were gonna be the next big thing. Doh! Nice work, very nice.
s
u
n
k
e
n
Snowfall
For me, i had the feeling you were writing about a homeless person, trying to cope by herself, struggling through Life, even Death could not be so scary, just welcomed. I never read others comments, i just say what i get out of the poem. Your words you used in the poem is really elf magic, i felt, oh i felt, it was so sad but than again not,hard to describe, it came from your heart and it moved me to tears, thank you Sir Elf, with love, hulda