From the UKAuthors Collection
For all those years
By Yutka · Originally published 22 October 2010
In search for her I walked right through her ghost
feeling the cold around the kitchen table, where
for all those years she read the bible, talked at length
of paradise, god on a throne, how angels sing in heaven
an endless drone of praise. There are no ways
that I can hold a spirit that will move
as fast as thought or hear its sounds protruding into darkness
from spheres beyond. I found her dying with her spirit gone
but still her flesh was holding on and on..
She’d lost her voice. It dimmed like candle light
I listened to her prayers in the night, although they never came
yet still were sounding in my ear the same, as when
she spoke them at her kitchen table before each meal.
Bless oh Lord our daily bread, bless oh Lord our flesh,
our mind, our doing, our waking, our sleep. What else to bless?
May be the silence, now, her soundless room,
the place where her chair stood, the empty bed.
Do bless it all, oh Lord, she has forsaken you
and lives now with the dead.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
For all those years
This caught my eye Yutka. It says a lot and says it well, but if I may be so bold, I think the way you have laid it out on the page is not doing it justice. Food for thought perhaps? Elfstone
For all those years
Hi There
I thought this was inded excellent. I understand Elf's feelings about the layout..the one line going into another makes it sort of lack oomph but the oomph for me comes in the almost dispassionate recount of things which actually have great meaning in them (if that makes sense)
The voice behind the poem is almost monotone while what it is saying is very profound
I found her dying with her spirit gone
but still her flesh was holding on and on..
She’d lost her voice. It dimmed like candle light
I listened to her prayers in the night, although they never came
yet still were sounding in my ear the same, as when
I loved it Alison x
For all those years
Wow! This is a good piece of work. Moving, full of meaning, without overplaying its hand and drifting into blatant heart-appeal. As another commenter says 'dispassionate' - but it's not of course, under the shell.
I don't score pieces. If I did, I'd give it a ten. It works really well.
I think the layout complements it, I liked the rhythm the line breaks produced, and also the quite subtle internal rhyming that went with it.
A stunner.
(the only thing I'd change is to remove the comma after 'spirit' )
For all those years
you wrote: There are no ways that I can hold a spirit, that will move as fast as thought or hear the sounds protruding into darkness from spheres beyond
I'm assuming you meant 'that will .... thought' as a sub-clause, in which case, that sub-clause should be bracketed by two commas eg: There are no ways that I can hold a spirit, that will move as fast as thought, or hear the sounds protruding into darkness from spheres beyond
or (my first take and the source of my comment) : There are no ways that I can hold a spirit that will move as fast as thought or hear the sounds protruding into darkness from spheres beyond.
This leaves out the bounding commas, as today comma use is reduced.
The first I think is more correct, but I would say 'that can move' or 'which can move' and 'There is no way' - but that's just my take on it.
best, John G
For all those years
Hi again Yutka,
I maybe did not make myself clear enough but I agree with Griff..the layout made the poem and this is indeed unusual, for poems to be laid out in this way often lack oomph....but here it was totally in keeping x
For all those years
Yutka, you asked for a suggestion - here's one. It comes with my usual caveat that it is, in the end, *your* poem and it must be as you want it, but hoping that this will be helpful. Elf.
In search for her
I walked right through her ghost
feeling the cold around the kitchen table,
where for all those years
she read the bible,
talked at length of paradise,
god on a throne and
angels singing in heaven
an endless drone of praise.
There are no ways
that I can hold a spirit
which moves as fast as thought
or hear sounds protruding into darkness
from spheres beyond.
I found her dying with her spirit gone
but still her flesh was holding on and on..
She’d lost her voice:
It dimmed like candle light.
I listened to her prayers in the night,
although they never came
yet still were sounding in my ear the same,
as when she spoke them
at her kitchen table before each meal.
Bless oh Lord our daily bread,
bless oh Lord our flesh,
our mind, our doing, our waking, our sleep.
What else to bless?
May be the silence, now,
her soundless room,
the place where her chair stood,
the empty bed.
Do bless it all, oh Lord,
she has forsaken you
and lives now with the dead.
For all those years
I liked all the soft internal rhymes in this - is this what all the debate about the layout is? A carefully built ense of pathos.
David
For all those years
I had no problems whatsoever with structure or layout - it read very naturally to me. As for the ending, excellent (as indeed it all is.) I very much appreciated her forsaking God and not the other way around - very effective.
Romany x
For all those years
Oh, yes, you are right (above) ... same happens when I write my own poetry, I change something, then notice I've introduced a problem... I should take more care :-)
JohnG