From the UKAuthors Collection

Advice I Tend To Ignore

By Ionicus · Originally published 22 October 2010

Water off a duck's back. (My weekly attempt to get a Golden Egg - see the Prose and Poetry challenge)

Do this, do that, do more,
don’t use adverbs unless…,
the tips come thick and fast;
advice I tend to ignore
although, I must confess,
I took it in the past.

I discovered then
that many disagree
if I get just one tribute.
I’ll be happy when
my divorce decree
becomes absolute.

I felt great frustration
and a certain pique
utterly lacking charm.
So a trial separation
from the critical clique
won’t do me any harm.

I used to write in code,
my poetry was a sham
but now it’s the real McCoy.
I compose serious odes
but know that I still am
a frivolous old boy.

© Luigi Pagano 2010

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

stormwolf

Advice I Tend To Ignore

hehehe well done you frivolous old boy, you!

Alison x

Bradene

Advice I Tend To Ignore

I liked this one of yours Luigi, in fact I like all that you write, so Rock on. Valx

franciman

Advice I Tend To Ignore

I really like this.

My one observation is that this might only strike a chord with kindred spirits.

How did you get your decree?

Jim

e-griff

Advice I Tend To Ignore

There are many sites which are essentially 'social', nice, with only 'positive' remarks . There are violently critical sites which are horrible. UKA is a moderate, honest, critiquing site in my experience, and to simply refuse advice here, just as an instance, would seem like sticking one's head in the sand. (But you can chose to only receive 'social' comments here if you are really that way inclined).

As Gordon Ramsay said about cooking recently: You don't learn anything from positives (me: but aren't they lovely? :-) ) Listen to the negatives - that's how you will learn to get better!

he was talking about a restaurant where the front of house manager (the two chefs' mother) was not passing on 'negative' remarks from the diners (ie 'my food was cold' 'the fish wasn't cooked') , but telling them everything was fine, etc. Is that what someone would want, as a chef? Is that something a serious writer, trying to improve their skills, would want?

I can't imagine any real 'authors' who could be deterred from writing by a harsh crit. If there are any such, that's something in them, a lack of interest or will (or maybe honest self-evaluation aided by the crit, which helps them to go onto something they really ARE good at). It's a bit like saying ' he was deterred from becoming a formula 1 driver because someone criticised his driving.' Do you think Lewis Hamilton only wanted 'positive'? Not on your nelly. I think the first question he asked every race was 'What did I do wrong there, Dad? How can I do better? '

Ahah... Well, there is a whole discussion around this on the forums under 'Discussion on Crit' (lower down the forum list). Might help some to think round the interesting subject you have raised and allow people to make their own decisions. :-)

Capricorn

Advice I Tend To Ignore

Haha!! - - I think we've all felt like this from time to time, Luigi. I visited a very aggressive poetry site once and was told my poem belonged at the deep end of the midden!!!

I think the secret of critique is to offer it in a polite manner. I've had many a very harsh critique given in such a nice way, that I couldn't possibly take offence ... and this is more encouraging.

I've been a moderator on an American poetry site for some years and we have a saying when we give critique - take or toss. In other words, if these suggestions are just what you are looking for then take it , if you don't feel the comments offered fit your purpose - then toss them aside.

A critique is after all just one person's opinion and if 5 people critiqued your poem they might all see different things in it to comment on. At the end of the day, the poem belongs to the writer and it is up to him/her to decide what changes they want to make.

However, there's always someone who thinks they know it all!

Keep writing

Eira

sunken

Advice I Tend To Ignore

Another Luigi classic, in my sunky opinion. Nice work fella. Frequenting this site is made all the more pleasurable for your presence. Your poems often provide light relief. I for one am often in need of relief. Ahem. I hope this has helped. Luigi? Hello?

s

u

n

k

e

n

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…