From the UKAuthors Collection
Goodnight Sister
By Harry · Originally published 13 August 2010
A contest entry for a work to be written in exactly 500 words, including name and title, the prompt being a photograph of a "pin."
Goodnight Sister
Harry Buschman
Her name was Madge, but on the street everyone knew her as “sister.” Bag ladies never use their real name. She pushed a Walmart cart she found in a parking lot on Third Avenue and in it was everything she owned.
Except one thing, and that was a pin her grandmother gave her when she was little. “If things ever get tough,” her grandmother said, “If the time comes, remember you’ve got this to fall back on ... it’s worth a fortune, Madge.”
It was on her mind at the moment. She took one hand off the handle of the shopping cart and felt three layers down to her underwear to make sure it was still there. It was.
They told her in the emergency room last week that she’d be dead in less than a year if she didn’t get out of New York. She’d be lucky if she made it through the winter they said. She knew that. Long before they ever told her ... she knew that. She had very little breath left now and pushing the cart uphill or down was becoming too much for her.
When you’re pushing a shopping cart on the street it’s not easy to stop off at a jeweler and sell a priceless pin ... not when you’re wearing a pair of men’s jeans, three sweaters and a pale lavender hat over a head of hair that hasn’t been combed in more than a year.
And Abe, the pawnbroker wouldn’t even look at it ... “What do I know from jewelry? Do I look like an Abe Tiffany? You got a violin? A catcher’s mitt with Yogi Berra’s signature? We can do business. Otherwise bug off sister, Abe Silver wasn’t born yesterday.”
Her last chance was Father McKenzie. He would understand, and to make him listen she would tell him the story, the whole story before her breath failed her completely ... in the confessional where everything you say must be the truth. “She was a gentle lady, Father ... the wife of Richard Simmons ... he owned the Boston and Maine Railroad ... the only railroad line in New England ... they had a summer house at on Cape Cod ... they had no children ... I used to spend summers there.”
She went on breathlessly. “She gave me this ... isn’t it lovely? ... my grandfather gave it to her ... on their fiftieth wedding anniversary.”
Father McKenzie glanced at the pin and looked back again at Madge through the little window in the confessional booth. She had slumped back in her seat. Her eyes were closed. He entered her side of the booth and felt for a pulse. He could barely detect one, if indeed there was any pulse at all, Reaching under his cassock he pulled out his cell phone and dialed 911. He took the pin and put it with the other useless items in her shopping cart. He made a mental note to have the sexton wheel it out to the trash in the morning.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Goodnight Sister
Hi Harry - very sad and moving with the end being the pin - her one hope being wheeled out in the trash. I wonder though if a genuine priest used to dealing with the homeless would ditch the trolley when they know that person's entire world was inside it? Did the priest know it was a costume jewellry pin or did he assume it was trash was left ncicel ambiguous though. A good piece. Mitch
Goodnight Sister
Hi Harry. I was a councillor for many years and dealt with homeless issues on a regular basis. Many trolleys were indeed full of tat but not all - some carried their last belongings from evictions from their houses for marriage break-ups or multiple debts so labelling all homeless trolley-pushers as delusional is well wide of the mark and unfair. At one hostel in cardiff, a troley-pusher would wander in and play Rachmaninov on the old upright. He was a concert pianist and i was told the trolley was full of old musical scores... there but for the grace of God go you and I! Cheerz. Mitch
Goodnight Sister
Very reminiscent of O Henry, but if he had written it you can be sure the discarded pin would indeed have been of great value.
Difficult to know what to do with this kind of plot. The core of the story I think is the difference between fantasy and reality --- it really depends on what you want to say about that. You have chosen to retain the mystery --- my instinct would be to settle it one way or other so that we know whether we're dealing with a tragedy or a sad comedy --- but I think the option you've taken is perfectly valid.
Good thought-provoking story.
Goodnight Sister
Short this may be, but there are still so many ways it could have gone, and still could...we can have no way of knowing what the true value of the pin was, if indeed it had any "value" beyond what the old girl believed. And that, in the end, was all that mattered. Sad, yes, but thought-provoking too. You didn't need more than 500 words, Harry!
Goodnight Sister
It's not that the pin is worthless so much as the Priest considers it to have no value. That's the only way I saw that the story could be complete in 500 words. That's shallow of me, isn't it ... my lack of depth keeps me in shallow water.
Goodnight Sister
Glad to see this got a nib, Harry. I read it this morning over a lightly toasted scone. That's not important tho. Ok, I'm procrastinating. I have it down to a fine art. Procrastinating I mean, not eating scones. Though having said that...
I shall just say well done on the muchly deserved nib and get out of your hair. nice work, fella.
s
u
n
k
e
n
i fought back a shiver