From the UKAuthors Collection
Rising
By e-griff · Originally published 9 July 2010
winner of theis week's (well-attended) weekly challenge.
even I think it's 'not bad'
the keyword was 'Rose' ...
Rising
Great rivulets of ocean foam cascade
As this return to airy world is made
From far beneath, in water’s silken deep
Atlantis now is waking from a sleep
The Kingdom of the Lost is lost no more
As ancient lands rise from the ocean floor
And tumbled stone and buildings all around
Progress through fathoms to the light and sound
Oh, what a sight to see this risen land!
Stone columns soar aloft on either hand
But where the noble people walked of yore
No creature’s seen upon this new-found shore
In boats, in flurried caravans of sail
The people hurry to their holy grail
A place of magic, mystery and wealth
Each one is seeking something for himself
But sensing in their minds the guile and greed
Old magic rallies to the country’s need
And in a trice all movement stops and then ...
Atlantis rose. And now it sinks again.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Rising
It was inspired - u b*****d - give us mortals a chance ...
Rising
Owes more than a little to my own humble pennings, I dare opine. But then, it's probably hopeful for the hoi-polloi such as yourselves to dream ...
a fair attempt, I grant, given the level of your talent.
Hereward
Rising
Reminds me a little of Kublai Kahn John - A brillaint idea and well executed.
My critiques:-
1) Why the partial punctuation?
2) This verse:-
"In boats, in flurried caravans of sail
The people hurry to their holy grail
A place of magic, mystery and wealth
Each one is seeking something for himself "
Seems a a little garbled. The sense, I think, is that all the looters rush out in their boats to loot Atlantis. But to call A place a holy grail seems to be a broken image to me.
How about :-
'The people rush to find a holy grail
Among the magic, mystery and wealth'
In the last verse who is doing the sensing? Old Magic I presume but the personification seems rather strained to me.
Again I think it could do with some more work - e.g.
'But sensing in their minds the guile and greed
Old gods rally to the country’s need'
Also saying 'in a trice all movement stops and then ...
Atlantis rose ' is not the correct chronological order, especially as you have been describing the slow process of Atlantis emerging from the deeps in previous stanzas. You mean the rising process suddenly stops and THEN the island seeks again. So:-
'And in a trice all movement stops and then ...
Risen Atlantis slowly sinks again. '
I hope these comments help - in any case, repolished or not, the piece is worthy of its Great Read Recommendation.
David
Rising
I loved the poem on first quick read. Agree about punctuation but have seen worse examples. At least here I understood and mantally added commas.
Read it again and still love it.
Rising
A traditional poem very skilfully penned.
Rising
Perhaps it's because of its rhyming structure that this flows so well - it seems to suit the subject matter very well, and brings it to life in a highly visual way. Good to see it getting that nib. I reckon there were shades of Arnold's "Dover Beach" in this, and that's no bad thing.
Rising
I'm reminded, as I read this, of seeing a village that had been flooded to form a reservoir resurfaced due to a water shortage. It was quite a sight.
I think you've captured the strangeness of it and the curiosity with which it was regarded very well.
I can't see anything wrong with this at all. Very well done.