From the UKAuthors Collection
Laughing All the Way
By Harry · Originally published 14 May 2010
A serious look at comedy.
Laughing All the Way
by Harry Buschman
The rougher and grittier life gets the harder we look for laughter. There is a bug in us that makes us want to laugh when there really isn’t any reason to.
I had lunch with my daughter in Montreal some time ago. Next to us sat a husband his wife and their daughter. It was summer and everyone was eating outside. Summers are so short and precious in Montreal the only people inside the place were the cooks. The husband's flimsy plastic chair collapsed and he went over backwards taking the tablecloth and all three lunches with him. His wife and daughter were convulsed with laughter even though he could well have sustained serious injury.
That is the essence of comedy...
In church one Sunday I passed the plate and dropped it scattering coins all over the hardwood floor. Hilarious, utterly hilarious .... even the priest had to laugh.
Laughter has to hurt someone. From the Keystone Kops to Woody Allen – the joke's got to be "ON" somebody. We revel in their agony. Did you ever get your pants pulled down in first grade? The joke was "ON" you.
There are limits. If the husband in Montreal had broken his back, if I had a heart attack when I dropped the church basket, the initial laughter would have petered out and replaced with an embarrassed silence and shamefaced regret. But still .... back in the tickling part of our brain we would confess to ourselves (if to no one else) that it was really pretty funny while it lasted. Let's make no mistake about it, we prefer to see something terrible happen to somebody else .... ask the men who survived the landing at Omaha Beach.
We love stereotypes too, "Two Irishmen walk into a bar" .... "Two Priests and a Rabbi are playing golf." You're all primed to laugh at somebody, and it really doesn't matter whether it's the Priest or the Rabbi. Chances are you're not a Rabbi or a Priest, and if there's any Irish blood in you the mash has been watered down by living abroad. Tell the joke to a Masai warrior and he won't get the point, but you do. You're the result of more than a hundred generations of poking fun of your ethnic neighbors and being poked back in return.
The Jewish stand-up comic far from home in the Catskills is out of his element .... deep in Indian country. He ignores that and he laughs at himself and his Jewish audience. He only plays there in the summer, when winter comes you'll find him in Las Vegas or Atlantic City if they'll have him. The audience goes home to Levittown where they’ll watch the black comedian in the sitcom .... backin' and fillin', doin' hand jive, and dancing in his baggy clothes as he plays to an convulsed canned audience. Laughing, not so much at what the comedian is, but what the stereotype is. Is that really funny? Isn't the funny man selling out? It seems to me humor loses a lot of its bite when someone makes a living getting you to laugh at his heritage.
There's the humor of Lennie Bruce, horrible biting humor you can't remember without seeing Lennie sprawled on the floor of his bathroom with a needle in his arm. There's George Carlin shining the comic torch of honesty in your eyes, and Mort Sahl hitting you over the head with a rolled up newspaper. There's Woody Allen reveling in the angst we all share with him, and showing us as Shakespeare did, how comedy and tragedy go hand in hand.
In the backfield are the Dangerfields, the Rickles, the Masons, the Joan Rivers and the Phyllis Dillers all dissolving in the acid of their own gall as they stand up for a living. Loonies, like Jonathan Winters, Robin Williams and Red Skelton are like the running backs on the special teams who make a living out of insanity. Being funny is a serious business and I submit that none of the people mentioned above are or were happy people. I also suggest that none of them, living or dead had a sense of humor.
I have a sense of humor and I'm sure you do too. That's because neither you nor I have to be funny for a living. All the fun goes out of humor when it has to pay the rent. Watch Olivier in "The Entertainer" and feel the acid flow .... watch it melt a family down.
The clown always wears a sad face and so does the stand-up comedian. There are no happy stand-up comedians. They are sad souls, laughing hollow laughter and standing in for us at life's whipping post. We feel their pain – and what a joy it is to see someone else suffering the same slings and arrows we do if only for a little while. Pain is the essence of comedy. The more acute it is, the more we enjoy it. It's not our pain, some clown, some comedian is suffering for us.
I look back at Oedipus and I think to myself – "what a cosmic joke!" A man marrying his mother .... fathering her children after being mothered by her! How would Woody Allen handle that? Look at Hamlet! The first stand-up comedian of the modern stage, trading one-liners with a grave digger .... ready with a monologue at the drop of a hat. It took four hundred years for George Carlin to think of doing it again.
With my heart in my mouth I watched Lennie Bruce offend everyone black and white at a cocktail party, ("Jesus, that Jackie Robinson could tap dance! .... oh, yeah, Bill .... sorry.") and because I couldn't understand the headlines I let Mort Sahl carry the ball for me. They kept me laughing, I could not have survived without them. There was Tom Lehrer poisoning pigeons in the park and doing the Vatican rag for me. All of them for me.
They were, and some still are, the great ones, the tragi-comedians of our adult years. They're not mean spirited like Rickles. They're not rapid-fire punsters like Youngman was. They didn't flagellate themselves like Dangerfield did, or limit their audience to the borscht belt like Jackie Mason. They don't dress up for trick or treat like Milton Berle, or flirt with the edge of insanity like Robin Williams and Jonathan Winters. Life is funny enough ... "play it the way it lays." Sahl still comes on stage with a newspaper under his arm "There's a new highway built in Los Angeles, built to replace the one lost in the earthquake .... it cost $4000 per inch." He doesn't need jokes – it's funny enough as it is. Carlin listened to people; to the flight attendant who asked him if he was "terminating at La Guardia?"
Black comedians make us laugh nervously. We look both ways, as if we were crossing the street before we feel safe enough to laugh. They didn't come any better than Richard Pryor, but white people laughed nervously at him, looking left and right, while black people really didn’t laugh at him at all.
Comediennes are different. They are predatory, husband devouring females who ignore the problems both sexes share. It's hard for someone .... any man with a sense of humor to spend more than a few minutes with Joan Rivers and Phyllis Diller without feeling profoundly bored. Their emptiness and our guilt soon shows through.
The stand up comedian is a rare bird. You won't find him in books or the movies. He can't exist for long in a situation comedy on radio or television. He's at his best in a barroom, a small and noisy barroom where he can get up close to you .... look you straight in the eye, point his finger at you and make you feel ashamed of yourself. He will offend you, scandalize you and shock you to the point where you will shake your head and have to admit that laughing at life is the real victory. In a world where nature eventually annihilates all of us, laughing may be the only victory.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Laughing All the Way
Exactly...life's too short as it is without allowing ourselves the essential outlet of humour. It's a very complex thing, too - there must be some reason why virtually every social/racial group laughs at another (usually smaller) one. Clearly, we have a need to laugh and thereby denigrate - can we separate the two? There's sometimes no logic in it - it's always seemed to me that the best tellers of Jewish jokes are themselves Jewish, though this is far more a US than UK thing. Not many British comics or comic actors are/were Jewish. The ability to laugh at oneself like this is something I really admire, and hope that it's something I have myself. (This self-deprecation is looked upon, here, as being very British - I wonder how it's seen abroad? Certainly, a Frenchman would be far less likely to find it amusing if you made fun of his country, whereas to us it's normal. No, compulsory...)
And, how exactly do we amuse ourselves without annoying others? As you so rightly say, somebody has to suffer. My favourite comedies have always been "Life of Brian" which certainly didn't amuse the religious amongst us, and I'm sure it would have been worse over there. Then there's my second choice, "Blazing Saddles" and there CAN'T be anybody who doesn't get roundly insulted in that! Nevertheless, it still cracks me up. Especially the toll booth in the middle of nowhere...what a comedy idea that was. And the roll-up "Welcome to our New Sheriff" notice. Oh, dear, I'd better go - great article, Harry - it's always good to get a new perspective!