From the UKAuthors Collection

You are the Grit within my Shell

By e-griff · Originally published 10 May 2010

David (Sirat) recently opened a discussion on critiquing. He is the guy who gave me my first solid , honest crit when I first joined the site, and set me on the path of (at least some) competence. At the time I wondered if he was trying to sabotage my great work :-) With my first proper story, he ‘talked me down’ to one quarter length, shedding side-plots, then said ‘do you need this other character at all?’ A while ago, I wrote this for him. (bastard!)

You are the Grit within my Shell

I’m finished – It’s perfect! I’ve checked it all through.
I’m pasting it here now to e-mail to you.
I wait with excitement. You’re going to say:
‘It’s perfect!’ But no, I read this with dismay:-

The plot doesn’t add up, the character’s flawed,
That word wasn’t used then. I got slightly bored.
Could you make it shorter? Then lengthen the end.
Why not change his sex, or just give him a friend?

His motives are suspect. A man of his age
Wouldn’t have done that – It leaps off the page!
Take out a few players; you don’t need them all,
And in the third verse you say ‘rise’ – Why not ‘fall’?

What is the true mood of the man in the punt?
Is he really jealous? Or is it a front?
And it’s not convincing a woman that size
Could squeeze through a window in such a disguise.

You bastard! I’m doubting the worth of your case,
But if you insist, I’ll respond with good grace.
Then behind this mask I will weave clever schemes
To defend and reject this attack on my dreams.

I’ll explain the impossible, twisting the plot
And introduce mystery, likely as not.
I’ll pull any trick that I possibly can
To try to retain my original plan.

By God, I won’t change an iota for you!
I’ll work and I’ll strive just to force it all through.
Triumphant, I’ve finished, I don’t quite know how.
Then back comes your e-mail: That’s much better now!

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

admin

You are the Grit within my Shell

Hahaha, that's clever that is - I really like it (Bet David's chuffed, too)

:-)

zenbuddhist

You are the Grit within my Shell

'A while ago' aye right John I remember reading this when Moses was a boy...ahahahaah doesn't time fly Bono's 50 today!......makes me feel better about saturday when me myself will be joining him, jeezo FIFTY whats it like??...Z

:-)

Gee

You are the Grit within my Shell

You know, that's one of the things with criticism, taking it the right way. When you create something, be it a poem or a pie, it's hard to accept someone elses opinion and realise that it hasn't turned out perfectly, and harder still to go back over it until you get it right.

It made me giggle and I bet sirat really appreciated it.

sirat

You are the Grit within my Shell

I knew it had to happen. The first poem anybody has dedicated to me! I had hoped it would be a declaration of love from somebody like Sagari Chhabra, but I guess I'll just have to make do with this one from Griff.

Yes, we have given each other a mutual leg-up as the years have gone by. We are, as you might say, the Clegg and Cameron of prose critique on UKAuthors (by default, if not desert). I will leave you to decide which is which.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…