From the UKAuthors Collection
The Violin
By Harry · Originally published 26 February 2010
You can hold your nose to keep from smelling something, You can turn your glance away if you don’t want to look at something ... but ears are different,
The Violin
Harry Buschman
Twelve year old Manny Bonanza played the violin and that made him different from the rest of us in Bed/Stuy. Not better, by any means ... but different. We called him “Gutbox.” He couldn’t play baseball in the street with us. He couldn’t roller skate – in fact he couldn’t do anything we did. He washed his hands every chance he got; in school he washed his hands between every class, before he went to the bathroom as well as after. For a little Italian boy in Bed/Stuy he was exceptionally clean. We always suspected he had a disease ... and playing the violin had something to do with it.
So “Gutbox” wasn’t one of us. I think he rubbed us the wrong way because none of us could do the one thing he could do well. It made him special and as far as we could see, scratching on a fiddle didn’t deserve being special. Being a baseball player – that deserved being special.
The Bonanza family lived in a red brick five decker tenement across the street from St. Theresa’s Roman Catholic church and In the hot summer afternoons with all the windows propped open, a passer-by couldn’t help hearing “Gutbox” practicing inside. The church organist and the ladies choir practiced for Sunday masses at the same time and the discord––the musical dichotomy between the two of them made you grind your back teeth.
It was a no-man’s-land of musical torture to walk past his house on a summer day, a test of endurance and even temper in the face of incompetence and incompatibility. The organist and the ladies’ choir fought a battle with each other for supremacy in the empty church and another battle as allies for victory over the noisy fiddler across the street. The ladies, (already overheated) were warming up for Sunday Masses, while “Gutbox” was practicing for his upcoming appearance with the Brooklyn Youth Orchestra at Loewe’s “Pitkin” movie theater in Queens.
To add a little more to the mix, “Schultz,” the German delicatessen’s well-fed Weimaraner attended these afternoon concerts and sang with them. After his lunch of bones and salami ends he would walk over and sit outside the Bonanza’s living room window next to an old poplar tree that somehow survived it’s urban environment. The lowest branches of the tree jutted out belligerently at the level of the Bonanza’s third floor living room window. It was all the shade the dog could find, “Schultz” sat beneath the branches and sang to the Lord and the fiddler ... and occasionally peed on the tree.
On one warm summer afternoon, the combined voices were too much for “Gutbox.” It was the week before his concert and he was intent on his fingering and bowing in the overture to Beethoven’s Coriolanus. The droning of the women’s voices, the belly rumble of the organ, and now ... the damn Weimaraner. It was all too much for “Gutbox” and in a fit of blind Latin petulance he threw his violin at the dog. At that precise moment, realizing what he had done, he reached out to catch the fiddle just as he threw it. In doing so he nearly fell out the window. Self-preservation prevailed and “Gutbox” grabbed the lower frame of the window, dislodging the wooden stick that held it open. The window slammed down on the five fingers of his left hand––the BIG hand in fiddle playing. Now the agonized cries of the unfortunate fiddler were added to the general hubbub.
The only element of good fortune was the fate of the fiddle. It was lodged in the branches of the ancient poplar tree. The dog, noting its presence above him, assumed it had been thrown at him as a rebuke to his singing in the street and after a final squirt on the poplar tree to let his presence be known to one and all, he walked unhurriedly back to the butcher shop.
While “Gutbox’s” mother tended to the damaged fingers of her violinist son, his father, Vinnie Bonanza hurried down the three flights of stairs to the street. He stood in his undershirt staring up at the violin lodged in the poplar tree. The female choir and the organist now reigned supreme and were blissfully unaware of the disaster across the street.
Vinnie scratched his navel ruminatively and considered the possibility of climbing the tree. However, twenty-five years in the ice and coal business had taught him to recognize and accept his physical limitations. The dizzy height of the lowest branches and the hardness of the concrete sidewalk were all taken into consideration and he looked about him for a young boy desperate enough to earn a quarter or two. His eyes lit up when he saw me.
“Hey kid! Lookin’ to earn a quarter?”
I had witnessed the whole thing and there was no way I was going to shinny up a poplar tree and back down again for a quarter. “No way to climb a tree like that, Mr. Bonanza,” I said. “No branches. Y’need to get yourself a long ladder.”
“There’s one on the side of my truck.”
“Too small. Y’need a lo-o-o-o-ng extension ladder like the ones the firemen use.”
Vinnie stood there tapping his foot. He was perplexed, out of his depth. He looked me up and down and said, “How about fifty cents?”
He was getting into serious money now. “Okay,” I said ... all the while figuring the angles.
Using all my creativity and putting my street smarts together, I squeezed out an idea that was simple yet brilliant, with a bit of Machiavelli thrown in for good measure. I held out my hand for the fifty cents and Mr. Bonanza dug down in the side pocket of his overalls and came up with an impressive handful of change, so much in fact that I had no pangs of conscience for my solution. He put the fifty cents in my hand and I walked down to the German deli and borrowed the extension gripper they use to pull canned goods from the top shelf.
I then walked back to Mr. Bonanza standing by the poplar tree. He stared at me and scratched his head as I walked by him and up the stairs to his front door and up the three flights to his apartment. I could hear him starting up the first flight as I knocked on the door of the Bonanza’s apartment. No one answered the door but I could hear “Gutbox” sobbing inside. As I knocked for the third time, Mr. Bonanza came laboring up the third flight of stairs. “Turn the knob, it’s open,” he gasped. His breathing was heavy and it was obvious he wasn’t used to climbing stairs any more than trees––icemen always used the dumbwaiter. “I know what’cha got in mind, y’little wise-ass... “Gotta hand it to ya though. You gotta head on you kid.”
I opened the door walked down the hall to the front living room. I could hear Mrs. Bonanza consoling Manny in the bathroom. She was telling him his fingers were not broken, just crushed a little ... and maybe they would heal up in time for the concert. Manny was sure all five of them would have to be amputated.
Mr. Bonanza followed me down the hall and told me He would take it from here, “That violin is priceless,” he said. “I paid 45 bucks for it in a pawn shop downtown and I ain’t gonna have no kid nudge it outta the tree and down into the street. You gotcha money ... now git.”
Well that was true. I already had the fifty cents, why not let Mr. Bonanza take it from here. “Don’t forget to bring the gripper back to the deli Mr. Bonanza,” I reminded him.
I turned around and walked back down the hall. Manny was still making a fuss in the bathroom and I was fifty cents richer. I walked down the three flights, light as a feather and with my mind full of ideas of what fifty cents might buy.
I forced myself to glance up at the Bonanza’s living room window when I got out in the street. I could see Mr. Bonanza reaching out for the violin with the gripper ... he seemed to be having trouble with it and I quickened my pace a little. I had my money and I didn’t want any more of the Bonanza family.
I learned something.
You can hold your nose to keep from smelling something, You can turn your glance away if you don’t want to look at something ... but ears are different, they pick up sounds whether you want to hear them or not. I suddenly heard an explosive ... “Jesus, Mary and Joseph,” and I knew something had gone wrong with Mr. Bonanza and the violin. I tried to quicken my step, but I couldn’t help myself. I just had to sneak a look back.
One leg in the window, the other one on a branch of the poplar tree and with his arm holding the gripper stretched out as far as it would go, trying desperately to reach the violin – all to the accompaniment of the organ and ladies chorus of St. Theresa’s Roman Catholic Church. It was an unforgettable sight.
I wish I could tell you he was successful, but the scene was too much for me. I turned the corner and never looked back. For weeks after that I avoided the street between the Bonanza’s and St. Theresa’s Roman Catholic Church. I heard later that Manny was in the violin section the night of the Brooklyn Youth Orchestra concert, so I guess everything worked out all right.
©Harry Buschman 2008
(1630)
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Violin
Ah, what a wonderful picture you paint - full of vitality. I suppose the moral is...if you've got a musically gifted kid, point him or her towards something that he CAN'T chuck out of the window, like a grand piano. Or a sousaphone. Or, you could buy him an accordion and pray that he chucks it out of the window ASAP - but that would be wasteful. I love the idea of the musical battles across the street and there just had to be a singing dog to add to the fun. As usual, you left me with a big smile!
The Violin
Roy got it absolutely correct Harry the images were superb and very amusing. As usual I enjoyed every word written by your very creative pen, metaphorically speaking. Val x