From the UKAuthors Collection
LABELLING and the SELF FULFILLING PROPHECY a layman's guide
By zenbuddhist · Originally published 6 November 2009
MISANTHROPES ...dontja just HATE them!
I bought this book the other day, another one of those books whose blurb declares that the contents are, ‘laugh out loud funny’, you know the drill, usually the most you manage is a sly, twisted grin which only succeeds in instilling a feeling of great unease in your fellow bus passengers, so much so, you can feel the glances of suspicion and fear burn into you like super hero death stares.
This one went even further, the highly improbable boast of, ‘your jaw will ache’, glared out at me, like a beacon, or rather a warning, or a challenge, whatever the particular ad hook employed, it worked, I dug my hand into my pocket and parted with three whole pounds. Not a fortune, granted, and I was cautiously optimistic that my sacrifice might just be nearly worth it, that such a confident blurb couldn’t be a TOTAL pile of shit, that my cynical suspicions might be, just for once, way wide of the mark. And nobody was more surprised than me when that, indeed, proved to be the case
I’m getting ahead of myself here, there’s background stuff that you need to be aware of, apologies. I had high tailed it to my dentist, late, running for a bus, something so alien to my metabolism that I thought it was going to punish me with nothing less than fighting back with such a ferocity that soon I would be lying on the pavement, dying a miserable, public death, gasping for oxygen through a face that resembled a bloated, blood blister. But the last time I was late the bastards charged me ten pounds, a ‘missed appointment’ they declared with aloof cruelty, which, as I pointed out, was technically incorrect, but my protestations of the variances involved between ‘missed’ and ‘late for’ appointments fell on cold, indifferent ears. And in today’s climate of non-existent, available, national health, dentistry practices, only a fool would labour the point.
You know it’s true.
Anyway, as it turned out all this rushing around like a blue-arsed flea was a waste of fucking time and energy, I’d got the time wrong, I was an hour early, I’d like to say it was the clock thing, you know going back an hour but it was probably just because I’m an idiot. Which I am, and that’s fine by me, as long as haemorrhaging money for no good reason isn’t a consequence.
So that’s why, having escaped being fleeced by the dentist mafia, I wandered into a shopping mall and purchased the aforementioned, reduced price book.
Actually it was a far better move than I could possibly have realised at the time. It turned out that I had split a filling so bad that my routine check up appointment transmogrified into an emergency root canal drilling torture ritual. And if that sounds like too much of a list to you, you can go sod yourself, because that’s exactly what it was. An experience so traumatic and horrible that I don’t want to talk about it anymore.
But to be fair the massive doses of Novocain that were pumped into my gums killed the worst of the pain, my face just felt as if it had gone on a tour of the Antarctic and had forgotten to come back. Which can leave the rest of you feeling more than a wee bit vulnerable. Which is never a good thing.
Okay this is where I fess up, I didn’t go in blind, by that I mean I’d come across the author before, at least, sort of. It was during a particular nasty and prolonged bout of insomnia, lying in bed, flicking through a motley selection of rubbish channels, as you do when you’re driven half crazy by lack of sleep, that I came across a t.v. critic spouting bile about a motley collection of rubbish programmes showing on said rubbish channels. This guy was GOOD a sort of mouthy, funny, scathing, cynic who seemed to hold a venomous worldview I recognised as close to my own. Not only that, he seemed to have a particular nasty brand of poison set aside for that twat Jeremy Kyle, and, also, like me, sported the damning face of a criminal. The programme was called ‘Screenwipe’, the book, ‘Dawn of the Dumb’ and the man in question none other than Mr Charlie Brooker himself.
Home, after the dentist ordeal, I settled into my favourite chair and began my journey into the world of a man whom, I suspected, would rather be flayed alive than seen flinching when declaring, ‘I don’t get people, what’s their appeal, precisely, they waddle round with their haircuts on, cluttering the pavement like gormless farting skittles. They’re awful.’
It proved to be a fruitful, laugh out loud journey, one in which, as time went on and the anaesthetic wore off, I felt my jaw beginning to ache.
In 1796 a German physician called Franz Joseph Gall developed an early psychological theory known as Phrenology which states that personality traits can be derived from skull shape and facial features. This became popular in the 19th century as a criterion for the identification of criminals. It is a very early theory and has since been dismissed as pseudo-science and quackery. Which, in all probability, can be confidently viewed as an accurate appraisal. However, the next time you’re scanning through the local paper and you come across the photo of the latest drug dealing, man of violence to be thrown in the slammer, you wont be surprised to recognise the all too familiar picture of a dangerous thug, a right evil looking cunt who looks like he’s about to jump out the paper and kill your whole fucking family!
Futhermore there is a link, a statistically proven correlation between conviction and aggressive appearance. So what’s going on? Did Gall have a valid point?
The answer is no, and the justification for this rejection lurks within a social psychological approach proposed by Howard Becker, which became prominent in the 1960’s and 70’s, known as ‘labelling’ theory. The theory hypothesises that the labels applied to individuals, especially those applied by the guardians of social control, police officers, social workers and judges for example, influence their behaviour, especially negative labels such as ‘crook’ and ‘thug’, this in turn creates a ‘self fulfilling prophecy’ i.e. an individual who is labelled because of his appearance has little option but to conform to the kind of behaviour associated with the judgement. Which means if you’re unfortunate enough to be in possession of a face that is generally deemed to be that of a crook, you’re called a crook often enough and, subsequently, treated as a crook, guess what? You’re going to turn out to be a scummy fucking criminal! You’ve got no choice.
Now it’s my guess that The Brooker Man may well refute the judgement that he resembles a crook but he has no qualms at all when, off his own bat, it comes to labelling himself as a misanthrope. ‘I’m a misanthrope’ he informs us [Dawn of the Dumb] on more than one occasion and I feel my warming to him ratchet up a couple of notches as I suspect that I might well be one too.
Although it occurs to me that it may be a relevant term, or a sliding scale, that some people are more misanthropic than others, with a cantankerous old bastard who lives alone up a mountain in a fortified compound at one end and, let’s say, a happy clappy, altruistic Earth Mother who’s first on the list for the adoption of a blind, legless orphan on the other. Not sure where I’d be but, as I don’t harbour a hatred of mankind universally, only those sectors of society labelled, Slebs and Dykes, I might loiter on the low end. But it’s not all about me so let’s slide back along the scale to The Brooker, he tells us [Dawn of the Dumb] that a ‘ crazy party animal’ set him off one time, with me it’s more likely to be someone not paying me back, and he retaliated by wandering round the party like a zombie endlessly repeating the word ‘despair’ in ever louder tones, until he was ejected. Which is probably true and quite an amusing little story but I think he neglected to tell us the whole truth. I suspect he took along a bottle of wine to that party, a dark red, almost black wine with an unhealthy sludge of sediment floating at the bottom – like that ‘Bull’s Blood’ you used to get – and a white label with only a single word MISANTHROPY written in that old fashioned style your granny still uses. Every time Brooker is accosted by a ‘crazy party animal’ he violently shakes the bottle and takes a long slug. There are so many ‘crazy party animals’ at this particular party that he finds himself staggering around in a drunken stupor shouting DESPAIR AND DEATH into the face of everyone he comes across until he is beaten up and thrown out on his arse.
I harbour a suspicion that Charlie’s misanthropic tendencies are not so transient and mellow than he would have us believe. He likes to give the impression, that he would be a fucking good laugh in a pub, one of these guys that humorously slags off everyone else but not in a cruel way, or at least not too cruel. But really, deep down he’s not joking, he’s not only deadly serious but holding back, and the joke’s on you.
So I’m sitting in my most comfortable chair chuckling away at Brooker’s scribblings and my own interpretation of events and the letter box clatters at the door, I ignore it, I don’t want to see anybody, but then I hear a flutter, I know what it is immediately, the noise a hand written note makes on the way down to your hallway floor is unmistakable and IMPOSSIBLE to ignore. Sure enough there it was, shining up at me from the carpet, a note demanding to be read in a neat, seductive female’s hand. It was from the lassie downstairs, she had split up with her girlfriend, a relationship of five years, seemingly, an upsetting experience, apparently, it had ended in violence, allegedly, theft had been the final act of treachery, undoubtedly and, oh yes, could I lend her some money, inevitably.
If you ask me she’s well rid, I have come across the villainess far more times than I feel comfortable with and I have never seen that lassie smile, not once. In fact she looks at me with unbridled hatred but I suspect I’m not being singled out, no, there’s a good chance she hates everybody she doesn’t want to suck cunt with, which would, of course, encompass the entire male population of the world. She’s a man hater, the female equivalent of a misogynist, whatever that happens to be, and I wouldn’t mind so much if she didn’t try her hardest to be one, a man that is. Honest, she looks like a bloke with tits. I’m straying into an offshoot of labelling theory here, one that should be more familiar to the layman – stereotyping, but I don’t care, that lassie is the epitome of the Butch Dyke, she swaggers round sporting a skinhead haircut, in football hooligan uniform and, if given half a chance, would gladly, with relish, squish my balls into a paste. I’m not making this up, I met her up the town one day where she ‘borrowed’ two pounds for her bus fare off me and even as she was slotting the money in her pocket she looked at me with the fury of a crazed meth addict who’d just had her fix stolen. It’s not my fault her girlfriend always gives me the, ‘I’m a dirty bitch and you can fuck me if you want’ look. Is it?
It certainly isn’t but that doesn’t mean I have to grin back, but I do, because you never get two of these ‘Butch Dyke’ creatures paired up together, no, they always go for the more ‘girlie’ brand of lesbian, you know the ones you tend to see actively engaged in porn films. The lassie downstairs is one of those ‘girlie’ types and she wouldn’t have asked me if she wasn’t desperate and, besides, I like flirts, especially the dirty bitch type of flirt who look like they might star…anyway you get the picture, I went downstairs and lent her twenty pounds, ‘’till Friday.’
So much for Dykes, a despicable bunch, yes, but small beer when compared to Slebs, at least the Dyke is probably aware of the hate fallout they attract. The Sleb is a unique brand of self-obsessed moron so far up their own arse they are completely oblivious just how odious they actually are.
I thought the worm was turning, they were dropping like flies, two Sleb supermongs Michael Jackson and Jade Goody, gone, no more; Jackson, an abhorrent pederast more than capable of washing what’s left of his face in the leaking body fluids of a too long dead Hollywood child star if he thought it would turn him into Elizabeth Taylor and Goody, an attention seeking harridan who would’ve gladly paid a surgeon a Heat magazine fee to sculpt her fat arse into that of a pre-pubescent boy’s to put herself in the running for some of that legendary maypole dick action. Of course I didn’t wish them dead, as such, misanthropes are not necessarily sadists, but seeing that Slebs would rather puncture their own eyeballs with red hot needles than voluntarily move out the media spotlight, I’ll take what I can get.
Slebs are more than fair game for the Brooker Man of course, he fires volley after volley of scathing grapeshot into their midst with the blood lust of a demented destroyer:-
‘Nicky Campbell (Satan) drips with menace while sorting out fly by night time share companies as though discussing the Third Reich.
Joe Pasquale is better known as, Oh My God Turn Over I Can’t Stand Him
David Dickenson with his sagging breasts, cow length eyelashes and oaky complexion resembles a retired Thai ladyboy.’
And on, and on, you should read it, it’s fun.
How could I have been so DUMB it was so glaringly obvious I couldn’t see the wood for the trees. Charlie Brooker has obviously donned the cloak of misanthropy for comedic effect and, I’d like to tell him, it’s a superficial ploy that only works initially, my laughing out loud has diminished to a twisted grin and, I’d like to shout in his face, my jaw only ached because I’d been to the dentist. I HATE him. He’s also the worst kind of Sleb, the ones that pretend they’re not, he probably meets up with Jeremy Kyle every Friday for a few glasses of wine before retiring to a room lined with mirrors so they can watch themselves suck each other’s cocks from every possible angle. But worse, much worse, it’s Friday and as the day draws to a close, as I sit here listening to what sounds like a party coming from the flat below there doesn’t appear to be any sign of that torn faced Dyke venturing up the stairs with MY FUCKING MONEY.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
LABELLING and the SELF FULFILLING PROPHECY a laymans guide
This has the feel of a standup routine about it – I'm not sure it works so well on the printed page, it cries out to be performed.
Some material, I felt, was just there to make me feel uncomfortable, and it did. I disliked the stuff about (highly stereotyped) lesbians. I was waiting for you to move on to other traditional target groups – blacks, the disabled, asylum seekers, the old – but you chose instead clelbrities ('slebs') who I suppose most of us would consider fair game. Maybe picking on recently dead 'slebs' though pushed the boundary just far enough to appear daring. But is abusing people, even creatively as you have done here, really funny? I suppose I just don't have the right sense of humour. I wasn't clear how much of this was supposed to be you and how much you were attributing to the well-known gay-bashing and 'proud to be sick' Guardian columnist and late night digital TV broadcaster Charlie Brooker. My honest feeling is that this is his territory and should be left to him. It's not for me. Sorry.
LABELLING and the SELF FULFILLING PROPHECY a laymans guide
STUART LEE...