From the UKAuthors Collection

The Unknown Soldier

By sirat · Originally published 16 October 2009

My entry for the October challenge in the Prose Discussion/Workshop forum, based on pictures of war graves.

The Commonwealth War Graves Commission is charged with the duty of commemorating any officers and men from Great Britain and her Empire who so courageously and selflessly laid down their lives in the service of their country. There are an estimated 45,000 of "The Fallen" missing from the Commission's registers and memorials throughout the world.

Compounding this unfortunate situation, the records of those who the Commission do commemorate are marred by a very large number of errors in their name, rank, unit, date of death, age and next of kin. It is obvious that many errors have been in place since the Commission's founding, but in more recent years the matter has been further complicated by the defective OCR (Optical Character Recognition) computer scanning of its records, resulting in a corrupted electronic database.

The Campaign for War Grave Commemorations

Granny Brewster was still struggling to get out of the car, levering her weight forward with her stick firmly planted in the gravel as fulcrum. Barry had already pushed open the low metal gate and was charging recklessly down the main aisle between the stark white gravestones. At least there was nobody else about to see him do it.

‘Don’t run, darling!’ Celia called after him, ‘This isn’t a playground! If your mother was here she’d be very cross!’

We all knew it was a pointless gesture. Barry was going to be Barry whatever Celia or I might say to him. He got to the end of the long straight pathway and started to return at the same breakneck pace but weaving over and back across the pathway now, almost touching the end gravestone of each row, arms outstretched and with an accompaniment of fighter aircraft sound effects.

Granny Brewster joined us. ‘That boy has no respect, I don’t know what’s wrong with his parents.’ His father was my son and I felt I should defend him but what was the use? GB had made up her mind about Barry a long time ago. ‘Can you get the book out please?’ she requested, sitting down on the low wooden bench just inside the gate. I took it out of its small oven-like cupboard built into the gatepost and handed it to Celia, who unlike GB or me would be able to read it without glasses. She thumbed through the pages for a while before reporting back.

‘Only one Brewster,’ she announced, ‘but he was a captain in the 8th Devonshire Regiment.’

‘Well, that’s not him then, is it?’

‘No, Mum, I’m afraid it isn’t.’

‘How many people are there in this graveyard?’

She flicked to the last page. ‘Four-hundred-and thirteen, of which two-hundred and seventy-five have been identified. An estimated one hundred more in the ossuary.’

‘It’s not really a very big graveyard then, is it?’

‘I don’t know where it comes in the league table, Mum. It looks big enough to me.’

‘We’re wasting our time here. What was the other one that the Frenchman mentioned?’

I felt the time had come to intervene. ‘Emily, I think we’ve looked at enough graveyards for one day. We’re not going to find your father. We simply don’t have enough information. Why don’t we just go back to the hotel and have our dinner?’

‘I’m sorry to have to say it but I think you’re a very unfeeling person. Your father had a normal life and a normal death. He was there for you all along. You don’t know what it’s like never to have known your father. I’m not leaving this world until I’ve seen his grave and said my goodbyes. You two can go and have your dinner – leave me with a guide and I’ll get a taxi back.’

There was no dealing with her when she was in this mood. And it was her ninetieth birthday treat, so an element of diplomacy was needed. ‘It’s no wonder Barry’s getting restless,’ I said as a way of opening negotiations, ‘we’ve been out here since nine o’clock this morning. It’s too much for a five-year-old. It’s not good for him – all this obsession with graves and death. We need to do something that he likes as well, something normal and healthy. Here’s what I suggest. Let’s all stay an extra day. Tell them in the hotel when we get back. I’m sure Rita and Bob won’t mind. Then tomorrow we’ll drop Celia and Barry off in Lille and they can go to the zoo. I’ll come back with you and you can visit as many more cemeteries as you want to. All four-hundred and whatever if you like. Knock yourself out. How does that sound?’

She hesitated. ‘I still think your attitude is very unfeeling.’

‘But you’ll do it?’

‘I don’t have very much choice, do I? You just wait till you get to my age. You’ll see what it’s like.’

‘Thank you Emily. That’s a good decision.’

ooOoo

As we drove back GB sat with me in the front as usual while Celia tried to keep Barry entertained in the back, but he had passed his crankiness threshold. He was sleepy and hungry. I thought of stopping and buying him a hamburger or something to keep him quiet, but the villages were too small to have cafes. We would have to put up with Barry until we got back to the hotel. I found it hard to admit it to myself but he was the grandson that I liked least.

‘You know, Emily, I have thought about what you said. About what it must be like for you, never having known your Dad. I don’t know if you realise it, but you talk about him far more than people who did know their dads. I think you’ve got this totally made-up picture in your head about what he was like, haven’t you? I bet he wasn’t really like that at all.’

‘What do you mean by that?’

‘Well, he must have been an ordinary joe. The eighteen-year-old son of a wheelwright in a little Norfolk village. Not much money, not much education, no real prospects. All the trades connected with horses would have been failing in a big way back then. Have you really thought about how he would have felt, what his life was like, why he joined up?’

‘He joined up because he loved his king and his country and wanted to do his bit like the rest of them. Because he was a brave man and not a coward. What more reason did he need?’

‘He’d got a local girl pregnant, Emily. There was no way he could have supported a wife and a family. Be realistic. Take off the rose-tinted, eh?’ I didn’t really know why I was saying these things. There was just something about the attitude she had adopted towards this shadowy figure, this whole fantasy that she had built up about him, that irritated the hell out of me.

‘Are you saying he wasn’t brave?’

‘I’m saying he wasn’t free. He didn’t have any real options. He was a victim. Another sheep herded down the road to the slaughterhouse. There was nothing glorious about what Trevor did – or about what most of those poor foot soldiers did. They just got caught up in an obscene mass destruction of teenage boys, organised by their stupid elders. Thank god the world has stopped doing it. At least this part of the world. That’s all it was. A mass blood-letting. An unspeakable obscenity.’

‘Please don’t start, you two,’ Celia pleaded from the back. ‘It’s bad enough coping with one toddler.’

‘My mother told me exactly what my father was like. He was a very polite and quiet young man. He didn’t go out drinking or gambling or talk back to his elders or swear. He treated her extremely kindly. He was generous to a fault, even though he didn’t have very much. He was a perfect gentleman. She was the very first girl that…’ She left the sentence unfinished, no doubt remembering that Barry was listening. ‘My mother said that no woman ever had a better husband, or a kinder companion.’

‘I wonder if his mates would recognise him from that description… sorry Emily, I don’t know what I mean really. Just that he was a real person – a very sad and unfortunate person, but the same as all the rest of us. Good bits and bad bits. Not a plaster saint.’

‘You know nothing whatsoever about him.’

‘Leave it alone, you two,’ Celia pleaded from the back. She was right. I drove in silence from that point and the main voice we heard for the remainder of the journey was Barry’s, complaining that he didn’t want French dinner, he wanted proper English food. Celia assured him we would do our best to please. As we always did.

We had almost reached the hotel car park in Lille when I realised that GB was gasping for breath and her face was contorted in pain. Celia and I knew these symptoms all too well. They signalled the beginning of another nightmare for us all.

‘She’s having another attack, Celia.’ I said the words as calmly as I could. ‘You go in and call the ambulance. Take Barry with you. I’ll stay here.’
ooOoo

The hospital doctor had an East European accent and spoke perfect English. He ushered me into the anteroom where Celia and Barry were seated. ‘Perhaps the young boy would like to go to the candy machine and buy some chocolate,’ he suggested. ‘Nurse Coutet would be happy to accompany him.’ The nurse behind him beamed down at Barry and reached out to take his hand. Feeling ridiculous I had to admit that I was carrying no French money. The doctor dismissed my embarrassment and supplied a coin himself. Barry and the nurse left hand in hand. There was little doubt what this was leading up to. The doctor sat down by Celia’s side and his expression became serious.

‘Mrs Collins,’ he began, ‘there is no point in telling you lies. Your mother’s condition is very serious. I think you should prepare yourself for bad news.’

‘She isn’t…’

‘No, Mrs Collins. Not yet. She has a wonderful spirit – she refuses to give in. But I have to tell you that the prognosis is not good. She is an elderly woman and her heart was already damaged from the earlier episode. To be perfectly honest, I am surprised that this episode was not instantly fatal. I’m sorry, but I think you understand what I am saying, yes?’

‘Yes, of course.’ Celia was pale and words seemed to fail her. ‘I think I should take Barry to the hotel,’ she said very quietly. ‘This isn’t really the place for…’

‘I agree, Mrs Collins. Perhaps you would like to say goodbye to your mother before you leave?’

Celia looked more drained than I had ever seen her before. ‘I’m not sure that I can,’ she whispered.

‘Stay here for a moment,’ I suggested. ‘Let me go in first.’ She made no objection so I left her with the doctor.

Inside the Intensive Care cubicle GB lay alone on the narrow hospital bed, wired-up to an impressive array of electronic equipment. She looked amazingly small, like a child in its cot. A cannula had been inserted into the back of her hand from which a long transparent tube led to an inverted bag of saline solution on a metal stand. A small screen monitored the flickering attempts of her injured heart to maintain the flow of blood around her body. She looked utterly exhausted but her eyes were open and her face still bore that almost fanatical focus and stubbornness. I could tell exactly what she was thinking about, just from that expression.

I smiled at her and sat by the bedside. ‘Don’t try to talk,’ I instructed her. ‘Let me do the talking. There’s something that I want to read to you.’ I put on my glasses and produced a folded sheet of paper from my inside pocket. I unfolded it carefully on my knee. ‘I’ve just come from the hotel,’ I went on. ‘A letter was waiting there, special delivery, addressed to you.’ I looked at her face but her expression had not changed. ‘I hope you’ll forgive me – I’ve opened it. May I read you what it says?’ She nodded, almost imperceptibly. ‘It’s from your friend the Colonel, at the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. He says: Dear Mrs Brewster. I have wonderful news to impart. I hope it reaches you before you leave for England. The Colonel-in-Chief of your father’s regiment e-mailed me this morning in a state of great excitement, and I have to admit that I have been in a state of some excitement myself since reading what he had to say. The mystery of your father’s war record and place of burial has been solved. The reason for all of the difficulties was that when he signed-up the name recorded on his military papers was incorrect. That kind of thing happened relatively often during the Great War – many of the young men signing-up were illiterate and the papers were completed by the recruiting sergeant in response to verbal instructions from the recruit. All that the new recruit was required to do was sign his name, and sometimes even that was nothing more than a cross counter-signed by the recruiting officer. Your father’s name was incorrectly recorded as ‘Brewer’, not ‘Brewster’. Once this was realised, everything fell into place. It transpires that your father was posthumously awarded the highest military medal of that time, and indeed of the present time, the Victoria Cross. This was in recognition of his exceptional bravery in leaving the trench during enemy bombardment to retrieve three fallen comrades. Despite being wounded himself he retrieved the first two successfully, undoubtedly saving their lives. While attempting to rescue the third he was fatally wounded himself. Private Brewster was the only soldier in his regiment to be awarded the Victoria Cross, either in the Great War or any subsequent engagement right up to the present day. The Colonel-in-Chief requests that you inspect a parade of his men and tell the regiment what you know of your father, to be followed by a regimental dinner in your honour. When you return to England he will get in touch with you regarding these arrangements. Allow me to say…etc. etc.’ I stopped reading and looked at her face. She was smiling broadly. I couldn’t remember having seen her smile like that ever before. ‘You were right, Emily,’ I whispered. ‘You were right and I was wrong. Forgive me.’

Suddenly the room seemed to be full of people and a hubbub of voices speaking in French. Nurses and men in dark gowns were furiously attaching things to GB, and the doctor I had spoken to was guiding me gently back to the anteroom.

Celia, pale and trembling, was sitting there with Barry. Even he was subdued. Celia spoke to the doctor behind me. ‘She’s gone, hasn’t she?’ was all she said.

‘I’m sorry, Mrs Collins,’ he confirmed. ‘They’re doing everything possible but I don’t think there’s any real hope.’ He joined her again in the same chair as before. ‘It’s a funny thing, though,’ he added, looking her in the eye, ‘but I could have sworn she had a smile on her face. I don’t think I’ve ever seen that before.’

Celia suddenly noticed that I was holding a sheet of paper. ‘What’s that?’ she asked.

‘This?’ I handed it to her. ‘Nothing. Just a blank sheet of paper.’

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

The Unknown Soldier

It held my attention all the way through, but I think it's not entirely successful. It seems a little clunky, and the dialogue not quite right. I didn't get a strong sense of GB (I think because her dialogue seemed a bit too neat for me). I think that having Barry along is a great move, though, and that certainly works.

My main problem was that I saw where it was going as soon as he unfolded the sheet of paper. Maybe it's just me. And then the immediate death of GB felt very stagy, and the doctors rushing in... I think it just needs a lighter touch towards the end. Less dramatics. Lengthen the section in hospital, give the narrator more of a dilemma and let us know that he's decided to lie, instead of going down the 'twist in the tale' route? It could be very moving that way.

Just some thoughts. It'll be interesting to see what others thought of it and if I'm just being grumpy today.

bluepootle

The Unknown Soldier

Hmmm... I get what you're aiming for.... maybe just a change to her face, or her breathing, after he reads the 'letter'? Something that indicates that she's letting go? You've made it clear earlier that she will die. I think something more subtle might work.

chrissy

The Unknown Soldier

I found this story very completed if you know what I mean and I liked it. I've read it a couple of times since early this morning and it still feels whole and finished.

I'm not sure whether the old lady should actually, physically die at the end but for me that makes it complete and that she passes with her ideals, probably fantasies about her dad intact is a good ending.

I liked it a lot and it held my attention from start to finish.

Two v small typos 'God bits and bad bits' and '...regimental dinner in you honour'.

Regards.

Chrissy

RoyBateman

The Unknown Soldier

Considering that this was a rush job, I'm impressed with the quality of writing: very flowing and literate. Still, I'd expect that... I'm sure that a bit of sandpapering round the edges would produce a really touching tale, but it's difficult to know when to stop tinkering.

I was a bit concerned at the unfeeling tone of the way GB was talked to early on - I think that, especially if it was her (possibly last) treat, she'd have been a bit more indulged by her relatives. Most of us do that with old folks, at least putting our irritation into asides rather than direct comments. The switch to the caring persona seemed a bit Damascene to me.

The twist was, I think, signposted with the inaccuracies in the "letter", many of which, I'm sure, you know about. (The Colonel-in-Chief is purely ceremonial, usually a senior royal; no line regiment now exists in the same form as it did in 1914/18, so he/she would have changed anyway; I can't think of one that only has one 20th-Century VC; VCs are very carefully documented and have their own association - they don't go missing) So, that gave it away for me, though admittedly somebody making it all up on the hoof might well say these things. Overall, it's a compelling and touching story: considering it was rushed, it's very impressive. I'm amazed it has so few comments.

e-griff

The Unknown Soldier

I'm catching up ... :-)

This was, as I would expect from you, a well-written highly competent story that is well worth reading. But I agree with your own estimation that no, it isn't one of your best. The style overall seems stilted, focussing on actions and dialogue rather than including surroundings and mood, feelings. (the feelings are stated by the characters, not shown). The family relationships were a little confusing, and not explained all that well, so that distracted me - even after I had read it the first time, I had to go back to find out what relation Barry was, and it's still not crystal clear to me now.

I. like blue, saw the 'twist' coming straight away, and found the details of the dinner etc overdone, laid on too thick, so the end really didn't give me the kick it should. Some lack of originality, I'd have to say. But, as I said, still a good read.

best JohnG :-)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…