From the UKAuthors Collection

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

By e-griff · Originally published 27 July 2009

Watson gets him in a tizzy ...

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

Holmes tapped his pipe out carefully.

‘So it was Moriarty behind this?’

‘Yes, Watson.’

‘But what was his game, revealing himself like that?’

Holmes smiled gently and began to refill his pipe. Then he spoke. ‘That is what he wanted people to think.’

Watson’s face bore a blank expression.

‘You see, old fellow, Moriarty had prepared a clever double bluff. By posing as an evil villain, and later announcing it was a bluff, he could then eliminate from his search those people who had responded to his first announcement in an inappropriate way.’

‘But …’

‘I know what you are thinking, and you are right: what if people saw through his bluff and in return, falsely pretended to be the kind of people who would respond to his first announcement, thereby confounding his categorisation of them?’

‘Er …’

‘And again, what if the double bluff was a triple bluff?’

‘Or a quadruple bluff?’

Holmes looked sharply at his companion. ‘Exactly,’ he said. ‘So much is obvious.’

‘And?’

‘Well, by eliminating those who were too stupid in their response the follow the twists and turns of his brilliant criminal brain, he was thus able to select those of the right level to join his criminal gang.’

‘Unless of course …’

‘Exactly, Watson.’ Holmes’ tone was rather sharp. ‘Unless of course they themselves were bluffing to call his bluff. There are some sharp minds in our Police Force.’

‘But …’

‘Yes. Moriarty was so convinced of his own superior intelligence that he overlooked one thing.’

‘You mean …’

‘Me. Exactly, Watson. A mind that could out wit and outfox the wiliest fox in the criminal kingdom.’

‘And so …’

‘The master criminal, in the belief that his multiple bluff has worked, is now engaged in activities which wholly benefit the forces of law and order in our land.’

‘Unless …’

‘Ah Watson, you are right, annoyingly so I fear.’

‘Then …’

‘There is only one man I know who could …’

‘His name, Holmes, his name!’

‘Enough!’ Holmes sprang up and paced across the room. ‘Enough! I will not have Hereward Taft’s name spoken here.’

‘But you just …’

The door slammed.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

macaby

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

I am a fan of holmes, especially Basil Rathbone, I think he was the perfect Holmes. Your Holmes cetainly had me baffled, all those double, triple, quadruple bluffs. I had to do a bit of detective work myself, thank god for google, now I think I know who this Hereward Taft is :) Nice one.

mac

Andrea

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

I, too, am a fan of Mr Holmes. Basil was great...and who was that other chap? Jeremy Brett, that's it, liked him too.

Your chap's good as well, reminds me of someone...

Shouldn't out wit be outwit?

Andrea

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

Maybe so, Watson, but it should still be 'outwit'

shackleton

The Manners of Sherlock Holmes

Great fun, Mr. Griff. I originally got the wrong impression at the mention of Moriarty revealing himself... but it was just my mind. Enjoyed the read and the humour.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…