From the UKAuthors Collection

The Sound of a Butterfly's Wing ...

By e-griff · Originally published 6 April 2009

a brief (and puzzling) encounter

Butterfly's Wing

I walked up to the farmhouse. It had been a long, hot, walk. Maybe it was foolish of me to be trekking on foot across this landscape. People round here were pretty suspicious, especially of lone wanderers. But it was the only way I could spot the small traces of the plants I was seeking,

A small, wiry, ginger-whiskered man stepped out from behind the barn. His face bore a smile, but the gun on his arm and the dog at his heel made me wary.

‘Howdy,’ he said. He caught my glance. ‘Just huntin’ varmints – don’t worry, you’re welcome here. Come and set down for a while and drink some lemonade. ‘

Noticing how I sidestepped the dog, he added, ‘Jack wouldn’t hurt you. Sweeter than apple pie, he is.’

‘Thanks,’ I said. I followed him to the porch and we settled down on the long bench together.

‘Martha!’ He hollered. ‘We got a guest! Any lemonade?’

‘Sure. Just a minute!’ came a woman’s voice from inside.

The farmer had laid his gun on the seat beside him, the dog lay quietly at his feet.

‘So, what are you up to round here?’

‘Looking for plants, I’m a botanist.’

‘Oh is that all? I expect some of my neighbours think you’re up to no good.’

‘Yes, well …’

Just then a woman bustled out, carrying a glass of lemonade, which she offered to me. I took it gratefully and we exchanged a few pleasantries.

‘It’s excellent!’ I said. ‘Thankyou.’

‘Not at all, you’re welcome.’

‘Any for me?’ The farmer spoke somewhat hesitantly, I thought.

‘You can get your own, Zeb Tolger.’ The woman swept off into the house.

I sipped the lemonade.

‘Tell me this,’ the farmer said. ‘You’re an educated man. You ever hear of people’s spirits bein’ swapped?’

‘Spirits?’

‘Well, people, their characters. Somehow replaced. It’s hard to describe.’

‘Why do you ask? Have you anyone in mind?’

The farmer turned his face slightly away from me. ‘Well, take Jack here.’ He pointed down at the dog, the I followed his gaze to the view in front of us, the dry hills, the scrubby plants. ‘You ever hear a sound like a butterfly’s wing on the air?’

I was taken aback. ‘What do you mean?’

The farmer looked down. ‘It’s the only way I can describe it, sorry. It’s just a sound.’

‘Then sorry, no I haven’t. Why?’

‘Caus' I have. I heard it before Jack changed.’

‘Changed?’ I was beginning to wonder if the man was completely stable. He seemed agitated now.

‘Jack changed!’ he blurted out. ‘He growled at me. He never growled in his life, ‘cept at a varmint. Never at me. He was different. He tried to bite me. Had to shut him in the barn.’

‘He might have had something wrong, an infected ear, something making him bad tempered.’

‘No, he wasn’t Jack. He was a different dog. Completely different. He didn’t do the things Jack did, he didn’t remember things.’

‘Remember?’ I couldn’t help but let out a small laugh. ‘A dog? Are you serious?’

‘Very. Two days later, he came back. I heard that sound, and he was back. The real Jack. Like he is now.’

I’d finished my lemonade. I looked round and carefully placed the empty glass on the broad porch rail.

‘You don’t believe me.’

‘It’s hard to understand. He’s just a dog. How do you know?’ I was trying to humour the man and wondering how to make a smart retreat without offending him.

The farmer cast his eyes down, and, surprisingly, blushed. ‘Okay, I’ll tell you. It’s about Martha …’

‘Your wife?’

‘Yes. You’ve seen her, the way she behaves with me.’

‘Well …’

‘She’s sharp with me – always has been. But she’s a good woman at heart, I wouldn’t have no other.’

‘I’m sure.’

‘Well. Same thing happened.’

‘What?’ I was puzzled as to any connection with the dog’s strange change of character.

‘I heard the sound ...'

‘The sound of a butterfly’s wing on the air?’ I wondered what that might sound like.

He coloured slightly. ‘That’s the only way I can describe it.’ He paused. ‘See, Martha’s never been the kind of attentive woman, you know?’

I wasn’t sure I wanted to know, but he continued.

‘She changed. She was laughing, singing … and …’

‘Attentive?’ I tried to save his embarrassment.

‘Exactly. Shameless. The boys down town would say “hot” I guess.’ A faint smile flitted across his face, his eyes glazed as if at some memory.

‘And …’ I interrupted his reverie.

‘Oh, well … Two days later, she was back. Martha.’

‘Martha?’

‘Well, the other one made me call her “Kitty”.’

‘The other one?’

‘That’s the only way I can describe it.’

‘Like Jack, you mean?’

‘Yes. You understand?’

His eyes seemed to plead with me. I guessed he was desperate for someone to believe him, and he couldn’t exactly tell his wife.

‘Not quite,’ I said. ‘I mean, I understand what you are saying, but how is such a thing possible?’

‘Ah. It’s them.’

‘Who?’ I was wondering about his state of mind again.

‘They're experimenting on us, swapping our spirits, our souls.’

Now I was worried. What did he think was going on? Some alien conspiracy?

‘They steal our souls, replace them with someone else’s, investigate them and put them back two days later.’

‘Why?’

'Because they want to learn about our superior species.'

'Surely it's they who are superior? – if they can abduct our souls and later return them to our bodies.'

'Naw, see, we have souls – they are investigating our souls – they are what makes us superior.'

'Don’t they have souls?'

He laughed scornfully . 'Course not – how can creatures who abduct people’s spirits have souls? Stands to reason …'

I couldn’t answer that, and didn’t really want to.

‘Don’t you believe me?’

‘I don’t know. It is hard to believe.’ I looked around for some excuse to change the subject.

Then I heard a sound – a sound like a butterfly’s wing on the air.

I turned back to the farmer. His face was subtly changed. His eyes, which before had been open and friendly, were narrowed, wary.

‘Just who are you, stranger? What are you doin on my land? I don’t hold with trespassers …’

The gun came up.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

macaby

The Sound of a Butterflys Wing ...

I could imagine this being played on stage.I know this kind of story has been done before,( was it the Bodysnatchers?) but I thought the dialogue between the two characters works really good.Enjoyable story, well presented.IM(humble)O. I also wonder what that butterfly wing would sound like, a sound most of us have never heard or have we? That's something to set the readers mind off wondering.

mac

bluepootle

The Sound of a Butterflys Wing ...

Yes, I liked the idea, and the hook of the butterfly wings, which gave it a surreal, delicate edge. I think its very well done up until the final quarter. The end is too abrupt and obvious - can you make the farmer's alteration more subtle, or maybe make the narrator the one who changes and pull out to third person, something a bit more experimental? Could be fun.

Seebaruk

The Sound of a Butterflys Wing ...

Hey e-griff, def an interesting idea, so looks like the test passed :) I like stories with a supernatural/other-worldly theme, so this one stuck with me. I love the way it's mostly dialogue driven too. Got to agree with BluePootle in that it ends rather abruptly, but wouldn't want to suggest how better to do it - I never even know how to end my own damn stories.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…