From the UKAuthors Collection
Elegy for a dead poet
By Yutka · Originally published 2 February 2009
...with a gift for to listen, repent and find peace...
Without digressions you went steadily
and grew old like a river reaching the sea.
As one who reaches the sea and the sand,
you let go the safety of the land.
You fought the storms battling with age.
Your spirit overcame. You turned a page.
Your words became salty and filled with shells,
drifting in light and drafted in spells.
Young in its fervour, brother of the waves,
your heart carried weight, wherever it braved.
Wherever it braved, you came into being
as when morning dawns and night is fleeing
in the slimmest of lights, and you suddenly know
a new day born and you feel aglow.
You reached old age undisturbed by chance
with time for reflection and eager for balance,
with a gift to listen, repent and find peace,
as the sea waves receive, hold on and release.
As the sea winds play with an errant dove
may the Great Spirit enfold you with love,
carry you, written in wind, salt and sea
to Elysium’s infinite harmony.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Elegy to a dead poet
I appreciate the idea behind this and much of the execution. In an apparently simple form like this, I think some very careful technique is needed to raise it to the highest level. On that score, although I have no enormous problems with the present version, I think it could be raised a notch or two with some delicate tinkering with the rhyme and metre. At present some of the rhymes seem rather obvious/simple and the metre has little added internal interest and some problems in the stresses .
to try and give examples, I found these lines better than the average in the poem:
Your words became salty and filled with shells,
drifting in light and drafted in spells.
nice rhythm throughout, shells and spells unexpected, interesting - you think about what 'shells' means, etc. the 'll' sound in filled and shells repeats nicely and adds interest,
and the drifting/drafted is also a nice touch. and here you have the unstressed start line 1 and stressed start line2, which creates the nice rhythm. This doesn't occur in some other verses, maybe it should, although variation can be good if required.
this, on the other hand, didn't have the same 'feel', IMO
Without digressions and steadily
you grew old like a river reaching the sea
this has some problems - in this first verse, where no rhythm has been established, it's not clear how to stress the line - to fit the later verses 'steadily' has to be said STEAD i LY to provide the two stressed beats to fit the accentual pattern of 4 per line. However, 'ly' is naturally unstressed (a 'feminine' ending) so pairing it with the strong masculine 'sea' ending doesn't fit the pattern of the rest. So when you hit the second verse, you are out of kilter. It felt wrong.
In the second line, the first stress comes at 'old' so you have two substantial unstressed beats before it - whereas most of the other lines begin with a stressed beat. This is too much -
(I'm not going into iambs etc, which is another way to describe it) But to be clear, for instance 'as when morning...' is acceptable, having only a minor unstressed syllable at the start.
Hmm ... I hope I haven't rambled on too much. Basically, I like the poem which is why I became interested in it.
very best, JohnG
Elegy to a dead poet
Hi Yutka.
I liked the idea behind this and liked the descriptions too of 'aging', very nicely done. My favourite lines are:
You fought the storms battling with age.
Your spirit overcame. You turned a page.
Your words became salty and filled with shells,
drifting in light and drafted in spells.
They give out beautiful imagery and meaning to them.
My only niggle with this is that some of the flow seems a little off in parts and the rhyme doesnt sound right in places, for instance with these lines:
You reached old age in the knowledge of silence
with time for reflection and the spirit of balance,
and also
carry you, written in sea, salt and wind
and in all that is forever entwined.
I'm not really sure though of what to suggest to you. Hope my comments help in some way and I've not offended you.
Lis'. xx
Elegy to a dead poet
I can't possibly compete with Griff's detailed review above, but I think the poem does need [and deserve] some careful work on it. It's very rhythmic in places and would be better, I think, if this could be extended. When one finds rhythmic verse in a poem, one tends to expect it all the way.
As I was reading I picked two lines that I thought stood out and I see griff picked the same two
Your words became salty and filled with shells,
drifting in light and drafted in spells.
That is absolutely beautiful.
So, having finished nit picking, I have a suggestion. Do you belong to the poetry society and, if so, to one of its stanzas [area groups]? I ask because each year they have a comp for members who are members of stanzas and PS. This year it is for an elegy.
Daff
PS anyone viewing here PLEASE VOTE FOR MY SPRING FEVER POEM. It needs votes in order to get near a judge. Odd system :-)
http://writelink.co.uk/springfever/entryDetail.php?id=9
Elegy for a dead poet
Yes, I certainly like it better.
I think it needs a full stop after
'as when morning dawns and night is fleeing' or the line before. As it is that line seems to be part of two sentences.
Good luck with the Guardian
Daff
Elegy for a dead poet
okay - I was going to give you some more comments after taking a closer look, but decided this instead: there are numerous problems with the metre in this, some of which are pretty obvious (1st verse and verse 8 particularly). If you'd like a run down, PM me, but I don't want to put it up publicly if you don't agree or if you are happy with this as it is.
very best, JohnG :-)