From the UKAuthors Collection

Family Matters

By sirat · Originally published 26 January 2009

This is for the January challenge in the Prose Workshop forum. As soon as I read the phrase 'I threw the knife over the railings' I thought of a song. This was written in odd moments on my Eee PC while touring Southern India. It contains some fairly dark material.

Dear Mama

I reckin I owe you an explanatin and this here is it. The first thing I want to say is that you wernt never a bad Mama and Papa werent never a bad Papa. You was the best Mom and Dad any girl ever had an you tawt me wrong from rite an I knew full well what I done was wrong an I done it anyway. Me myself, I done it, nothin to do with you. I knew what I was doin an I went right ahead an done it.

Ive kept quiet nigh on two years an not said nothing becase of i was afraid of what Papa an you would say an what other folks would say. Along with evrey thing else I am a coward.

So heres the truth. Tell the truth an shame the devil you used to say when I was litlle an you was right.

I reckin you knew all along that Billy Joe an me had somthin goin on. Evreybody else round here knew so why wouldnt you know? You an Papa never thought much of Billly Joe. Papa said he never had a lick of sense and maybe that was true but he wasnt no retard. Billy Joe worked that farm his Pop gave him up on Chocktaw Ridge with just his own hands from he was 18 yeares old and always grew enough to get by even tho the land up there was nevre even near as good as what we got, an he could rede an rite an do his numbers as good as the next person only he was kind of soft an not much good at lookin out for himself. Werent no bad bone in Billy Joes body. He always treated me reel nice and respecful, even after hed slept with me few times. Sorry for talkin plain but I reckin this aint the time to mince words.

I know you remembir that time two summers back when Billy Joe jumped off the Tallahatchie Bridge. Folks thought hed gone a bit crazy. Well mabe he had but there was reasons why he'd gone crazy. Most times things happen for a reason. I don't need to remind you ether that ever since that day things has gone reel bad for this famly. Pappa got that virus and passed away an brotheer Ned married Becky Thompson and bought that no-good hardware store in Tupelo an their marriage is damn near on the rocks already. An the crops near failed two seasons in a row. An I know you been pinin since Papa passed away an lettin things get on top of you. Aint nothin whatsoever went right for this family ever since that day. Iv had no heart in anything myself ether. I aint hardly slept since then with nitemares and aint hardly et ether and just been feelin terrible all the time. All I want to do is wander round on Choctaw Ridge, maybe say a few prayers, pick a few flowers. A right pair the two of us was – its a wonder anything atall got done on the farm, last couple years.

Well now its time for me to do a bit of unburdenin an im reel sorry that i have to upset you like this but i reckin things cant get much worse anyhow an its likely better that this hole thing is out in the open, at least no secrets between you an me. Old Doc Ransom used to say there was a deal of folks secrets hed be carryin with him to the grave. Carryin secrets aint easy an Im not strong enouf to do it no more.

Dyou remembir a few months before Billy Joe died his sister Charlene had a big bust up with there dad an got thron out of the house because she was goin to have a baby? I'm sure you do. Folks talked about it a lot. Well Billy Joe an me was seein one another at the time an I was workin in Anarine at the Four Eyed Jack. So I agreed to do Charlene an Billy Joe a favor. Charlene wanted to let her mom know she was OK only she dint want ether of them to know where she was, so what happened was she holed up with her brother in the Chocktaw Ridge farm an pretendid to her Dad that she had found a rooming house an a job in Anarene. She rote her Mom some letters an I posted them in Anarene an the return address was the place one of the other girls lived in Anarene so I got the letters from Charlenes mom an passed them on to Charlene. Any time her Dad visited Billy Joe at Chocktaw Ridge she hid out in the barn or some place so that he wouldnt see her. It only happened a couple times. Evrey body thougt she was in Anarene but she was with Billy Joe all the time. She told her mom shed moved to Anarne cause it was a big town with morein 2 thousand people in it so nobody would know her ther. It was a pretty smart story. I told Billy Joe he ought get her a doctor or somethin cause a girl can't just give birth to a baby like a mare drops a foal – in fact even that can be pretty scary an risky. But Charlene dint want nobody else around, not even me reely i think. It took me a long time to work out why.

Turns out the reason Charlene an Billy Joe dint want nobody else involved was Charlene reckind the baby was Billy Joes child and that was an awful sin an they could never hold ther heads up again if it got out, an if there Pop found out he would like as not kill the two of them.

I was a might shocked when Billy Joe told me about that an I hardly even believed him an I'm not sure I believe him an Charlene even yet. Anyhow he said the two of them used to fool around from when they was kids an used to creep into each others bedrooms. There folks caught them a couple times but dint know how far it had got to. I reckin thats why his dad bought him the farm on Chocktaw Ridge, to get him out of the house and away from Charlene. I dont rightly know how Charlene MacAllister could even tell whose kid it was cause evreybody in school knew shed tried out more boys that the Anarene Tigres Football Club, but she said it was likely his an sure enuf when I saw that baby I reckind she was morein likely rite. It was an ugly little critter with a screwedup face and it hardley moved an dint cry at all even once. That child werent right, like when Stenny had the five pups an one was small an weak an had to be drownded.

I wasnt there when Charlene had her kid cause it came a bit sooner than we was expectin an Billy Joe was on his own with her an I reckin he panicked a bit. Charlene was in an awful state, screamin enough to wake the dead when the baby finally come an there was blood all over the place, even hit the ceiling Billy Joe said. he cut the cord with his huntin knife cause hed heard you was supossed to do that, but he said the blood just kept comin an comin an he couldnt find no way to stop it an Charlene just lost all her strenth an was dead inside of about half an hour. The day after he buried her someplace up their an he never told me where an I never asked. He burned all the bedding an the mattress an him an me tried to clean the blood off the room best we could.

Well you can imagen how Billy Joe felt cause he was a reel gentle soul an he loved his sister morein anybodey else I ever knew. He was gibberin like a madman, sayin how he'd killed Charlne with that huntin knife an how he was fixin to use it on himself. It was crazy talk, the way I saw it even Doc Ransom couldnt of saved Charlene her insides mustive been tore up pretty bad. Well I had feelins for Billy Joe like I said an I tride to do the best I coud to make him feel better. That tiny kid was near dead, she was hardly movin an her breathin sounded awful. I told Billy Joe there werent no point tryin to do nothin for her, most kind thing would be to put her out of her misery. First we baptised her an give her the name Mary cause that was the most holy an innicint name ether of us knew. Billy Joes folks is Roman Catholic an he reckind anybody could baptise a baby, dint have to be no preeacher. It made him feel bit better an I didnt argue. When wed done that we took her to the middle of the Tallahatchie Bridge an put her in one of them brown net onion bags that dont rot an tied a big rock to it. We said a prayer, then we held her out over the railing an let go the bag. She fell reel slow. must have been ten seconds before she hit the water. Went under straight away. Dint suffer. Just like Stennys runt pup. After it was done Billy Joe just stood there. I couldnt get him away from them railings. He still had the hunting knife an he got it out an picked up a bit of stick from the ground an started whittlin. He just went on an on whittlin it into a point, sharper an sharper, an he wouldnt say nothin. In fact I don't think he said a single word to me after that, or like as not anybody else ether. Billy Joe just stood their whittlin an lookin into the water, all that way down. Next I heard hed jumped over an done himself in. You know all the rest.

Ive had nighmares ever since that day. Been scared to close my eyes at nite cause of what I'm goin to dream. Guess it musta been even worse for Billy Joe. Werent no way Billy Joe could of brought up that child even if shed been normal. His pop woulda found out pretty soon an it all woulda come out an like as not thed a killed Billy Joe. Either his pop or the neighbor folks up there. Wernt like it was a normal child. A child born of a brother an a sister is an abomnation. It says so in the bible I think. Wouldnt of lived anyhow. All we done was put it out of its misery. That was what I said to Billy Joe. An what I said to myself to. But I know right well it werent true. Mary MacAllister was a human bein with a soul same as you or me. What we done was murder, cold blooded.

So now you know why this family has had a curse ever since that day. The Lord is angry with me an he has a rite to be angry. Hes waitin for me to own up to what I done an to pay the price.

Ive got to meet my maker an give an account of my life an then itel all be over an you an Ned an Becky can get on with your lives an their wont be no curse. Thingsel be just fine again. So now Ive got to make my last journey to the Tallahatchie Bridge. Dont wory none about me Mama. It cant be any worse on the other side than it is on this one. An God is all merciful. Even Judas Skarriot got forgiven cordin to Brother Taylor. Say a prayer for me Mama. Its not so bad. In just a half an hour or so Im goin to be out of my misery, like Stennys pup an Mary an Charlene an Billy Joe,

I just ask one thing. This here is family matters. I dont want nobody else to read it but you an nether would Billy Joe or Charlene. An when you've read it I want you to burn it. Pleese dont let me down Mama.

Good bye Mama. Throw a few flowers over the railing of the Tallahatchie Bridge for us now and then. Aint much thats beautiful an innicint in this world cept flowers.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Rupe

Family matters

Dark, as you say, but in a good way - it's highly effective in making the reader feel the narrator's anguish. And it does have a kind of 'Southern Gothic' tinge to it.

I suppose my crits boil down to:

(1) Because the story is basically a suicide note detailing irrevocable facts, it doesn't leave the reader much space for interpretation, hope or much else besides. It's very self-contained. I think this is really the nature of the beast - and it has its good side too (a highly effective downer...) - but it does straightforwardly manipulate the reader's mind so that one's reaction is very black and white (mostly black).

(2) I wondered about the method of composition. Personally, I found it worked quite well - but there are obvious dangers in the use of repeated mispellings to indicate the narrator's lack of education and simplicity: i.e. do they replicate the idiom accurately, and is there a mismatch between the apparently poor use of English and the underlying articulacy of the piece? As I say, I thought it worked well (and quite liked the effect created by ambiguities such as 'he has a rite to be angry' - the confusion of 'rite' and 'right' is potentially effective here) but the technique itself is a little risky.

Rupe

e-griff

Family matters

another premature poster! What is going on?

I'm not reading this or Romany's until the due date. :-)

Bradene

Family matters

Although I found it a little difficult to read at first I was soon well into the story I thought it was a great interpretation of the song, you even got the voice just right in my opinion. Thoroughly enjoyed this David. A great read in my view. Val x

Corin

Family matters

Brilliant David - I like the way you slide into letting the reader realise that its a resolution to the mystery in 'Ode to Billy Joe'

As you don't know that it's a suicide note until the very end I think you keep the reader guessing right the way through.

I really enjoyed reading this.

David

sirat

Family matters

Thanks very much to all who commented and for the nomination. I'll answer all of you at once because I'm in an Internet cafe in Thrisseur, Central Kerala and Jean and I are hoping to get to a local temple festival (with elephant parade) by bus in the next couple of hours, which may be a major undertaking!

First, sorry John, I forgot that although it was Monday in India it was still Sunday in the UK and posted a bit early.

'Ode to Billy Joe' is a song I always liked, and the challenge phrase started me thinking about offering my own interpretation of the back story. I believe there was a film based on the ballad as well but I haven't seen it and don't know if their interpretation was the same as mine. It was good fun to write but I know it's a bit derivitive. I've never really tried writing in that semi-literate English before either (except when I do it unintentionally!) and in fact I think it works well for some subject matter. I might have a go at re-doing 'Lilac Wedding' in the same style.

Anyway thanks for all the kind words and I'm glad people got something out of it. I know the song itself is a better short story than this one, with a far richer subtext.

niece

Family Matters

David,

Loved this dark story...I thought the dialect may be difficult to follow, but it wasn't that bad...hope you are enjoying Trichur. Which temple festival are you attending? Did you travel by the local bus?...I'd call you very brave if you did...

Regds,

niece

bluepootle

Family Matters

I thought the semi-illiterate approach was very well handled, and it had the effect of increasing my interest in the story, rather than putting me off. I enjoyed it very much.

By the way, I love my Eee PC. Great, aren't they?

Romany

Family Matters

Interesting idea, to base prose around a song. In effect you've given the song a background. I enjoyed that. I think you caught the language well and I could picture the scenes quite vividly actually. One small typo I think:

"Seven Judas Iskarriot got forgiven cordin to Brother Taylor. "

Do you mean 'even?'

Romany.

e-griff

Family Matters

A very good story in many ways. I found it convincing, even though this 'voice' has been done quite often. At first I thought it wouldn't be that interesting, just following the song, but you made an interesting story of your own which took over and had its own life.

However, that being said, the 'tell' got to me after a while and (sorry) after having my interest piqued, I started losing it again. It seemed too long for what it was, and I think shortening it by editing would sharpen it up a lot and make the key points much punchier.

In terms of the challenge, I really did think the last line (the key line) didn't fit at all - it was simply tacked on. and the knife was only marginally part of the plot, rather than being essential, which I think is what these challenges call for.

But nevertheless, a well-crafted story.

G

e-griff

Family Matters

oh - BTW I'm on my Acer Aspire One - bit flashier than the Eee - but I mainly got it cos it only cost £160 in a sale (think there's a 10" model coming out, but I didn't want one that big anyway). Marvellous little thing.

G

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…