From the UKAuthors Collection
A Prayer To Oblivion
By Mandrake · Originally published 22 September 2008
Another non-rhyming, non-metrical sonnet to offend the purists, especially if you're religious. Instead of reading this, why not enter the flash prose/poetry challenge: http://ukauthors.com/phorum5/list.php?49 This week's theme is 'UNEXPECTED'.
A PRAYER TO OBLIVION
I would rather listen to the hiss of shingle
rolling in the surf than any holy sermon.
Each step along the shoreline cuts new stigmata
in my soles and the sea breeze brushes me aside
like a prayer on the way to oblivion.
I am baptised in effluent from rusted pipes
of Victorian vintage. The crumbling infra-
structure of the pier is still stronger than my faith.
At the turning of the tide, I feel nothing from
heaven but the moon's persistent pull; dumb
as a fish hooked on gravity's line, swimming in
helpless circles. I see bikini clad angels
with goose flesh, without wings, who would tempt me closer
to the devil, but for their melanoma scars.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A Prayer To Oblivion
well, as sonnet, in various forms, usually has something to distinguish it as such, ie the stages of progression of argument and the summation in the final punch-line couplet that a shakespearian sonnet (and others) exhibit.
This is a 14-line poem, with a break. As you say, it does not rhyme or scan as a sonnet, neither do is show those other characteristics of a sonnet.
I remain curious as to why (apart from simply being contrary) people choose to call a poem a 'sonnet' or any other form, when they clearly are not. BTW I don't think it's 'purist' to say that. Purist to me would be complaining that form diverges less than 10 percent (say) from the defined and known form. Here, your poem fails to match 90pc (say) of the chracteristics of a sonnet, so it's clearly not.
This is a serious query by the way. I really can't see why anyone should do it and I'd like to understand.
anyway, I thought this was a competent poem with some good images, but nothing that really grabbed me.
best JohnG :-)
A Prayer To Oblivion
This is a sonnet.
It has fourteen lines. The volta is clearly marked – literally – with the words ‘the turning of the tide’ where there is a clear change of mood. It is rich with sonics.
I’m a purist, and I wasn’t offended, so you’ve failed. Ha!
Seriously though, this is a great poem, whether it be a sonnet or not.
A Prayer To Oblivion
I understand what you are saying. No-one however is asking you to write iambs or forms - you can write what you like (and do). I enjoy all kinds of poetry - as free as you like.
Here's where we differ:
'If I say something is a sonnet, then it is a sonnet even if it isn't.'
This is patently untrue. Sure it's fun to play with words in a literary sense, I wrote a story with all the words wrongly applied - that was fun.
But this is not within a written work. You are telling us person to person 'this is a sonnet' - sorry, but until you become god, that doesn't wash. But words are used to convey meaning between people, for understanding, a 'common language'. Test it - swap 'sonnet' for 'dog' - so if you present us with a pic of a feline and say 'here is a dog' it is a dog, right? No wrong.
I'll tell you my concern, as I told MacJoyce. You are an accomplished poet - that is clear. There are people on this site who are learning, who trust people like yourself and will take as gospel what a sonnet is (wrongly) and perpetuate the error. After all, that's what happened to the haiku.
However,here, I'm expounding a general point - in practice in your intro you have indicated clearly (and deliberately to provoke I guess, in a lighthearted way) that this is not a sonnet. So I'm not pointing any fingers at you at all. No objections. Except to that one statement. of course, which I find curious.
nuff said from me .... :-#
A Prayer To Oblivion
Personally I can't understand the attraction of deliderately setting out to offend, even if it is deemed to be fun. I know I'm thought of on this site as a pratt of an old woman with out moded ideas but I still have an opinion. I like your work a lot as I've often said, but find it curious that a mature man of your obvious intelligence would want to set out to upset or make fun of people especially about something as personal as their privately held beliefs. I'm not complaining about your lack of faith or whatever, that's your business and yours alone, it's just this statement (Another non-rhyming, non-metrical sonnet to offend the purists, especially if you're religious.) So provocatively made in your intro' that I find rather childish. The poem is fine. Val
A Prayer To Oblivion
Whether this is a sonnet or a poem, I thought this was excellent. One of the better pieces that I've read on this site.
A Prayer To Oblivion
a very good poem
A Prayer To Oblivion
I certainly like the poem very much and fully concur with the sentiments too. Not so much with the blurb. Anyone with religious faith will either rise above what probably seems to them either your misfortune [and mine] or mild blasphemy [a matter between you and your god], but the intro does make it provocative. Personally on the matter of belief, I spent most of my childhood worrying about whether one should believe in God and then, aged about 15, decided that if he existed and if he made me, then he must have a sense of humour and therefore would see the funny side when I found myself face to face with him. Now I'm pretty sure I'm not going to come face to face with anyone after death and if I did I'd have some very unfunny matters to discuss.
Fact remains I really like your poem.
A Prayer To Oblivion
liked this poem very much - something about bucking the established traditions and rules is apt for this subject - that is what i understood you to be doing here -my relationship with sonnets is similar -i tussle with the form, or the form with me, and results are often called 'Sonnet, sort of..' or 'Allusion to a Purple sonnet' etc (abc) and i like to to see this writing process as a discussion/debate much like what is going on here on your page...anyway, rebel yells this is a good read - cheers, LD xx
A Prayer To Oblivion
I like Portobella beach aswell.
RODEL
A Prayer To Oblivion
Hah hah! I am VERY slow ... caught up in the debate about sonnets, I didn't actually look at the metre at the time. However thinking about the poem later I though 'It read quite well - how could that be so with no metre?' and came back to look at it.
So I looked again - lo and behold matey, like it or not, with a few minor variations, this is iambic - and what's more has a preponderance of pentameters, even. It has to be (iambic), as iambic is the rhythm of english speech, so if you compose a nice sounding sequence of words without consciously fitting another rhythm to it - it'll be iambic.
See, all this angst about metre is put in perspective .... *sighs*
best JOhnG
A Prayer To Oblivion
I'm not a purist. I liked the imagery, the sounds, the correspondence of the idea with the imagery, and the fact that you've taken the trouble to orientate the reader effectively towards your subject-matter.
Rupe
A Prayer To Oblivion
I've changed my mind about the pentameter. Like all metric scans, you can take various views. Reading this aloud, I now see it (althought essentially iambic in accentual-syllabic terms) as simply an accentual metre, using four beats per line, with the occasional short (three beat) line .
hah! what fun! anyway - enough from me, I think, on this one.... *exits* :-)
A Prayer To Oblivion
It’s rather weird that Griff declares himself not to be a purist because he allows some deviation from form, when he thinks that a ghazal that isn’t about lost love isn’t a ghazal; and that a Pleiadic Verse poem that doesn’t use exactly the correct number of syllables, isn’t in Pleiadic Verse.
I wouldn’t listen to him if I were you. He only reads Wikipedia. He probably hadn’t even heard of the ghazal before one showed up on this site, and then suddenly he fancied himself as an expert on and lover of the form, who had been reading, composing and singing them for decades, with a sitar on his knee.
Anyway, this poem did grab me, especially “I feel nothing from heaven”. Why don’t you end the line on ‘heaven’? Ending it on ‘from’ feels clumsy, and starting the next line on ‘heaven’ detracts from the force of the statement.
I take it you mean ‘effluence’. To be baptised in effluence is a good image, but it hardly makes for a positive or ‘uplifting’ idea of the seaside! Because of this, along with the crumbling pier, I didn’t get the sense that you were saying the beach is uplifting at all. Quite the reverse in fact.
Also, I don’t get the melanoma reference. The scars on the bikini-clad girls prevent you from wanting to shag them?