From the UKAuthors Collection

Mrs. Jacobson's Niece

By Whale · Originally published 22 August 2008

Will he break through the dark beauty's reserve or will she remain impenetrable? Does she hide a dark secret? If anyone can reach her heart, it has to be Jonny, the young psychiatrist.

MRS. JACOBSON'S NIECE

Out of the blue came a letter telling me Johnny was hopping over to India for a long stay. Could he bunk with me?

Johnny was the only son of Professor Kenilworth, one of my teachers in a London medical college shortly after the war. I had been invited often to the Professor's home, undoubtedly because he considered me a promising pupil. Johnny had looked up to me as an older brother, seeking advice for his growing pains. His adulation was rather flattering.

Shortly after I started my practice in London, the Professor took his wife and Jonny to India. He had been engaged to lecture at the Medical College in Calcutta. A year later they were back in London and, almost immediately, I was summoned to his home.

“Trevor,” said the Professor, “I have recommended you for the position I vacated,” and he insisted I take advantage of the opportunity. I asked him why he had left India so precipitously. It was not until I was established at the Medical College in Calcutta that I realized I had received no answer from him.

Johnny wrote regularly over the years. He informed me of his decision to take up medicine; it seemed natural to follow in his father's footsteps. I was delighted to learn of his success in his studies and that he had gone on to Psychiatry. I rejoiced with him when he qualified. He was accepted into partnership on Harley Street. “I've taken the name of Kene,” he wrote, “so as not to be confused with my illustrious father.” I was touched that he never permitted the communication to break between us. So, when I received his letter concerning his planned visit to India, I wrote at once a welcoming reply.

I had long since left the Medical College and was now the Director of the Harrington Nursing Home. I greeted him in my air-conditioned office. “Johnny!” I couldn't help exclaim as I shook his hand. “Is it really you? You were such a skinny fellow when I last saw you. My word! Nine years already. Thinning a bit on top, old boy, but I must say you would pass for a Lothario and not a respectable psychiatrist. I'm willing to bet most of your patients are female.”
I led him, sweating and smiling, to my desk. I felt irrationally proud of this handsome young man. “Forgive my not being at the airport this morning," I apologized. “I trust the driver had no trouble finding you.”

“None at all,” said Johnny, dropping into the chair before my desk, “only I'd forgotten the heat. It's a relief in here.”

“Enjoy it while it lasts,” I said. “We endure power cuts several times a day." I parked myself in my chair, pleased to have his company at last. But what a waste of a good-looking fellow, I thought. "Look here, Johnny, you're pushing thirty. Among your patients, wasn't there one girl you could be serious about? Look at me, thirty seven and alone. Don't make the same mistake.”

“To tell the truth, Trevor, I've yet to meet someone I could live with for the rest of my life.”

“You're probably too choosy, like me.”

“Probably,” he laughed. “The girls I met seemed too superficial. The ones I liked were married!” Flippancy could not hide his earnestness. “It's the woman wiser for suffering, who interests me,” he said.

“That's the psychiatrist in you.”

“Perhaps.”

“I know just the girl for you.” I rose from my chair cloaked in an air of mystery. “But come. I'd like you to meet someone who'll interest you professionally. Brought in some ten years ago suffering from catatonic schizophrenia like you've never seen. I inherited her. How she's managed to stay alive is a story in itself.”

He followed me to a private room. I knocked, knowing it would make no difference, and led him in. He reacted with a start and his eyes widened. Considering the object seated on a wheelchair by the window, it did not surprise me. A very thin, very old woman, with skin of flaky parchment, with hair grey and unkempt, straggling down the sides of her face, with eyes fixed unseeing, a statue in the ghost world.

“She looks a hundred, doesn't she,” I commented. “Would you believe she's not yet fifty!”

“Let's go,” Johnny said, laconic and brittle. Outside, he said: “Why did you speak aloud in front of your patient?”

“Old Mrs. Jacobson!” I exclaimed. “She doesn't hear a thing. She might as well be stone.”

“You’re wrong, Trevor,” said Johnny. “She hears everything.”

I confess I felt a wave of annoyance. “Oh, come now, Johnny, you were in there not twenty seconds. I've looked after her for almost six years. What makes you so sure?”

“She blinked several times while you spoke.”

I was so irritated, more with myself than with Johnny, I did not expand on Mrs. Jacobson's history then. As it was nearing lunch time anyway, we drove home. I showed him his room and told the bearer to unpack the sahib's things while we ate.

Over lunch, we small-talked about London. The memory of the morning still lingered. I tried to stifle the awkwardness by encouraging Johnny to speak of his father, who had gone into surly retirement, and of his mother, for whom old age had unleashed a more forceful personality - to the chagrin of the old man. I had not been back since coming East more than nine years ago, and I confessed I hardly missed it.

“I know I would be a fish out of water there,” I said. “The Indian way of life quite spoils one.”

We adjourned to the lounge for coffee.

“What about your patient?”

“Hmmmm?” I knew whom he meant.

“Mrs. Jacobson.”

“Oh yes,” I said, “Mrs. Jacobson. Well, not much to tell really. Her daughter -
Sandra, I believe was her name - committed suicide in a most bizarre manner. Swallowed sulphuric acid. Collapsed on the broken bottle she’d dropped. A jagged piece of glass pierced her under the diaphragm and punctured her heart. A freak accident. Created quite a scandal. Over a love affair, I believe. Passions run high in this climate. The mother's mind snapped. One moment, a rational human being; the next, a vegetable. She was a leading figure in the city. Very rich. Her niece manages her fortune now. A charming young woman. Very pretty. Comes in twice a week to visit her aunt. Never fails. As a matter of fact, she's the girl I want you to meet.”

“Oh?” He lifted a quizzical eyebrow.

“She answers your requirements,” I said. “Been through a lot, that girl. Orphaned at ten. Taken in by her aunt and three years later, witness to the double tragedy - her cousin's death and her aunt's immediate breakdown.”

“How old is she?” asked Johnny.

“Aha!” I wagged a victorious finger. “I've got you interested.”

He smiled. “I'd be a fool not to be interested in a pretty girl.”

“She's twenty three,” I informed him, “and she's refused every proposal of marriage she's ever had. Even one from a Maharaja! She's friendly enough but there’s precious little else I can tell you. She has a way that discourages even the most innocuous personal probes. Her private life is … well … private. Believe me, even her servants know no more than what she discloses to the world. For the ladies of the community it's horribly frustrating. Perhaps, with your charm, (tongue-in-cheek) you'll draw aside the veil of her reticence. She's more than just pretty. She's deep... she's charming...” - it wasn't enough; I searched for the right phrase - “...and she's… serene. Yes, serene.”

“Has she a name?” asked Johnny.

“Estelle. Estelle Morrison.”

Estelle's visiting days were Tuesday and Friday at 10.00 o'clock in the morning. So, on Tuesday I took Johnny with me to the Home. I left word with the Receptionist to buzz me on the intercom the moment Estelle arrived. Promptly at ten o'clock, my secretary informed me Miss Morrison was waiting.

“Send her in.” I came forward from my desk to greet her.

She entered like royalty, her hand extended toward me. Her frock of green and white, whirled about her knees. Her hair, almost black and shining with health, attractively framed her light copper face. Her large brown eyes reflected bright intelligence. Her aura of sombre nobility never failed to affect me.

“Good morning ...” Her greeting was cut short when her eyes fell upon Johnny.

“Come in, Estelle,” I said; she did not react. I took her hand; she seemed unaware of it. She was staring at Johnny. Softly, almost to herself, she said: “Coco?”

Johnny looked at her with positive appreciation. “Meet Dr. John Kene,” I said. He threw her a smile to charm Circe herself. “He's on sabbatical from England,” I explained. “Plans to loaf for a month. Then get down to the serious business of gaining experience in his field. Believe it or not, he's a psychiatrist.”

Quite oblivious of my chatter, she accepted the hand he held out to her while her eyes searched his face. Suddenly she shook her head. “Forgive me, Dr. Kene,” she said, releasing him at last. “I’ve been rude. For a moment, you reminded me of someone I knew as a girl. But he was not nearly so good-looking.” This last was spoken without hint of coquetry. Had she not been quite so indifferent, it may have been less embarrassing.

“Thank you,” replied Johnny, not in the least put out. “I'm delighted to be able to return the compliment. It's always refreshing to meet a beautiful woman who speaks plainly.”

I had never seen Estelle Morrison blush, but here she was, crimson from her neck up. She turned away. “I was not seeking a compliment,” she said.

“Neither was I,” returned Johnny. “All the same, it's pleasant to receive one.” She gave him a fleeting smile. “I understand you are here to see your aunt,” continued Johnny. “I'd be delighted if, afterwards, you'll permit me to take you to lunch.”
“No... I'm sorry,” said Estelle.

He ignored her refusal. “It'll be infinitely more pleasant than staring across the table at Trevor.”

“Thank you very much!” said I.

“I...I'm afraid I can't today.” I sensed apprehension in Estelle's reluctance.

“Tomorrow, then,” persisted Johnny.

“No... not tomorrow.”

“I'll pick you up on Saturday night. Eight o'clock.”

“Call me.” She was evasive. “Trevor has my number. Now, if you'll excuse me...” She hurried to the door; I opened it for her. As she passed, she gave me a perfunctory smile and I could not help but observe that her cheeks still glowed.

The whole community was agog when Estelle did go out with Johnny. Who could deflect his persistence? They were seen at the cinema and, later, at a local nightclub. She had never before indulged in such frivolity. The more unkind commented they could not understand how her majesty could permit her royal person to be jostled by the rank and file on the dance floor. Those who thought her a premature old maid (poor thing!) were anxious to see if this caper would finally end in a marriage knot. Over Johnny, the women sighed: “Dr. Kene is soooo dashing, isn't he?”

For myself, I am mortified to admit I couldn't control my curiosity. I felt my relationship to Johnny - in loco parentis, as it were - gave me the right to probe. All I got for my pains was a charming snub.

About a week later, Johnny approached me in my office. “Would you mind if I worked with Mrs. Jacobson, Trevor?”

“Mrs. Jacobson?”

“Yes.”

“Johnny,” I explained, “an army of psychiatrists have tried to reach her. Estelle has spent a fortune - even brought Sir William Lewis-Barrington over from London two years ago. Incidentally, you've had quite an effect on her. I've never seen her so - um, what shall I say? - involved.”

“Involved in what?” said Johnny. He could be quite infuriating.

“Oh, I don't know. In life, if you like.”

“We're talking of Mrs. Jacobson,” he said.

“Don't waste your time, Johnny. You should know there's a dimension no one can reach. As she can't speak, it's unlikely we'll ever know what blocks her progress.”

“Nevertheless,” said Johnny, ever persistent.

“Save yourself the frustration. I've informed my friend, Dr. Abinash Mukerjee, who's in charge of the Calcutta Mental Hospital, you'll be round to see him shortly.
All I need do is lift the telephone receiver.”

“Thanks, Trevor, but I may be the one person who can help Mrs. Jacobson. I'd like to try.”

“Dr. Mukerjee is desperate for help.” I persisted.

Johnny grinned at me. I shrugged in irritation and blurted: “Very well. Go ahead. I certainly don't mind.” I wagged a boorish finger in his face. “Don't say I didn't warn you.”

“One small thing, Trevor.” He rose to leave. “Don't let Estelle know about this, please.”

“Why?” I asked. He smiled enigmatically. “Oh, as you wish!” My exasperation was evident.

He turned at the door. “Trevor...”

I raised a frowning face. He flashed a broad beaming smile. “Thanks!”

I had to smile back. “Get out!” I said. “And the best of British luck!”

Johnny was adamant none but Mrs. Jacobson's nurse be permitted in her room. He requested I too, observe this rule. I insisted the nurse report her progress, if any, to me. “Damn it all!” I expostulated. “She's my patient!”

Four days later, fluttering excitedly, the nurse reported: “She turned and looked at me! Oh, Doctor, she actually turned her head!”

Progress was rapid. She moved her fingers three days later. Hand movements followed. Shortly thereafter, the nurse found her with tear-stained cheeks; memories were returning. I was at a loss to understand. “You've done wonders,” I told Johnny over the dinner table. “What are you using on her?”

“Sodium Pentothal.”

“But that's been tried before,” I protested.

He forked a piece of curried chicken into his mouth. I eyed him suspiciously. “What else?”

He shrugged and produced his smile.

“When can I see her?” I pressed.

“Oh, in about a week.” He pushed his chair back.

“What about dessert?”

“I'm meeting Estelle. We'll grab an ice-cream at Magnolias.”

And he was gone.

Exactly seven days later he ushered me into Mrs. Jacobson's room. “Here's your doctor, Mrs. J,” he said, addressing the living corpse. “He's taken good care of you.”

Mrs. Jacobson turned. Her eyes, bleary but comprehending, searched for mine. Lazarus had come forth. She extended her hand. I took it and kissed it. “I am delighted with your progress, Mrs. Jacobson,” I cried.

“There's no need to raise your voice, Trevor,” said Johnny. “Mrs. Jacobson hears perfectly well. Don't you, Mrs. Jacobson?”

Lazarus nodded.

The following day, Johnny permitted Estelle to visit her aunt. I waited outside. When they emerged ten minutes later, Estelle was struggling to maintain her composure. “Thank you, Johnny,” she said. “You will never know how grateful I am.”

“Prove it,” he returned. Her answer was a faint smile. “I'll call for you tonight,” he said, leading her down the corridor. “This silliness must stop. In any case, you have to acknowledge we do have something to celebrate.”

“It's hard enough as it is, Johnny,” I heard her say. “Don't make it any harder.”

“I'll call for you tonight.” Forceful chap, our Johnny!

As I was finishing a lonely dinner, Jonny came in looking rather down-in-the-mouth. “Hello, Johnny.” I looked at my watch. “What are you doing back so early?” He sat down silent and disconsolate. “Have you eaten anything? Bearer, bring a plate for the sahib.”

“I don't want anything,” said Johnny.

“Come now, Johnny, this isn't like you.”

“I'm sorry, Trevor.” He pulled himself together. “I've no business behaving like this. You deserve an explanation. The fact is, I need some advice.”

“Anything I can do, old fellow.” I sat back to listen.

He had called for her early that evening and instructed the driver to take them to the Strand, a quiet, romantic road along the banks of the Hooglie River. The diamond ring he had purchased was in his pocket. He was happy and sure of himself. When the car was parked, he told the driver to take a walk. He turned to Estelle. “What say you to a honeymoon in Hong Kong?” She stared at him with a strange, hurt look. “I had planned to get down on my knees,” he continued, “but the conditions are a bit cramped.”

Two large tears slid down her cheeks. She kissed him chastely on the mouth, put her arms around him and drew her body close to his, laying her head on his shoulder. Presently she pulled away and began to shake.

“Oh, Johnny!” she sobbed. “I can't! I can't!”

“Why can't you?” he demanded. “You love me, don't you?”

“So much, it hurts,” she confessed. “But I must refuse you.”

“Talk sense, Estelle,” he said, forcing her to face him. “No riddles. No games.”

At this point in his narrative, Johnny rose from the dining table and began to pace. Lighting a cigarette, he continued through a cloud of smoke. “Her face was contorted; her voice barely audible. ‘I am guilty of murder,’ she said.” Johnny turned to my shocked, incredulous face and repeated: “Yes, she did say murder! And having said it, she sobbed with horrible intensity.” He scraped back a chair and, once again, sat down. “It was impossible to get any coherence from her. She kept repeating: ‘Murder! Murder!’ I had to slap her to bring her to some degree of control. I called to the driver. We drove to the Nursing Home, where I gave her a sedative. I then took her home and instructed her ayah to put her to bed."

“By the looks of you, you should have prescribed a tranquilizer for yourself too,” I said.

“Never take the damned things,” he replied.

The next day, Johnny insisted I accompany him to see Estelle and all but dragged me to my car. I noticed a pallor over the skin of her lovely face when she greeted us, but she seemed to be under control. I was not at all comfortable. “I came to see how you are, Estelle,” I said. “Johnny tells me you were not too well yesterday.”

“How kind of you,” she answered as she took her seat upon the couch. “Do sit down.”

The ayah, barefoot and clad in a white sari, entered with tall glasses of freshly squeezed lembu pani, iced lime juice, on a tray. Estelle accepted hers but left it standing on the glass-topped side table. I swallowed my drink and, in the ensuing silence, watched the ring of water form at the base of her glass.

“Well,” I said, rising with false heartiness. “You look well enough, my dear. I'm pleased you don't need my services so I'd best return to my duties.”

“Sit down, Trevor.” Her voice was calm but firm. “You'd better hear what I have to say. It may help in my aunt's recovery. Until yesterday, I believed it was hopeless.”

I sat down.

At first, she spoke unemotionally, never once raising her eyes from the carpet. Occasionally she paused, as if waiting for stabs of pain, provoked by each memory, to pass.

“From the moment I entered this house as a girl of ten,” she began “my cousin, Sandra, made my life miserable. She resented my intrusion. She was sixteen years old at the time and she could devise the most vicious punishments. She would frighten me in the middle of the night with awful, ghostlike sounds, knowing how timid I was. She broke an expensive vase and swore she saw me do it. She went so far as to cut herself and accused me of throwing a knife at her. Needless to say, her mother believed her and I became notorious as an ungrateful, incorrigible and hateful child. I learned to choke down my tears so as never to reveal to Sandra how much she hurt me. I swore myself to revenge.”

She paused. Johnny and I ventured a glance at one another.

“Two years of hell went by. Then she brought Coco home to meet her mother. He had arrived recently from England. All the girls in Sandra's crowd found him attractive. Even I, at twelve, made him the object of my first romantic crush. I adored him helplessly. But Sandra commandeered him. The flattered and bewildered young man must have fancied himself in love. He became a regular visitor. He never came without something for me. It might be a pastry, or a Ludo board, or any silly thing. If not a present, he would slip me a rupee and whisper it was for an ice-cream. I took to following him like a pet dog at his heels. This annoyed Sandra and on her complaints, my aunt would shoo me away. I peered at him from behind door curtains or I would hide behind the couch just to hear the sound of his voice. I was wildly jealous of Sandra.

“I'm not sure when I first noticed Coco coming over when Sandra was out. I began to observe things. As soon as Sandra would leave, my aunt would pick up the telephone. ‘Coco? ... Sandra asked me to call... Fifteen minutes? She should be back by then.’ I knew Sandra would not be home for hours, having been invited by an ex-school friend for tea.

“You may not believe it now but my aunt was uncommonly beautiful. She was in her late thirties then, but she could have dropped ten years. I can still hear her husky voice and that very sensual laugh, as she said to him: ‘You're a very attractive man, Coco. If I were twenty years younger, I wouldn’t let you out of my sight!’

“I remember every detail of that fateful day. It was raining heavily, the first day of the monsoons. Though the rain brought some relief, it was still hot and sultry. My aunt had her usual Mah Jong session and I remember the disgruntled remarks about her lack of concentration. It broke up at noon. She was restless. At the lunch table, she snapped at Sandra: ‘How on earth do you propose to go out in this rain? The roads will be flooded.’

‘Oh, Mummy!’ said Sandra. ‘If I were to wait for it to clear, I'll be stuck indoors for months! I'll need the car.’

‘No. I'm sorry, Sandra. Not today.’

‘It'll have to be a taxi, then. Slip me fifty rupees, Mum.’

“I gave my aunt a wide-eyed look. A taxi cost no more than three or four rupees. I was surprised when my aunt handed her the money without a word. Invariably, there would be an accompanying lecture on thrift and the plaint that Sandra was a spoiled child.

‘Stop staring at me, Estelle!’ said my aunt. ‘Haven't I told you a million times, it's rude. Finish your lunch and get straight to bed for your rest.’

“I went to my room but I did not sleep. I heard Sandra go out and, five minutes later, the tiny tinkle of the telephone bell. My aunt asked the operator to connect her to Coco's number. I heard her greet him and invite him over. She said she would not hear of it in this rain. She would send the car round. A half hour later, Coco was in the house. I heard whispered talk for a while, then silence. I slipped out of bed and tiptoed to my bedroom door. I peeped from behind the curtain and, with a thrilling shock, I saw them kissing with their arms tight about each other. I heard her cry softly: ‘Oh, my God, Coco! I never dreamed I could ever feel like this. Kiss me again.’

“She led him toward her bedroom. I waited and a few minutes later, I followed, stealthy as a cat. Because of the heat, the doors are never closed. I could hear the whirr of the ceiling fan within. I lay down along the wall and peered in from under the heavy curtain. I could not see my aunt on the bed but I could see his naked bottom rising and falling over her. My throat constricted and I could hardly breathe. I was so afraid I did not stay long. I slunk away and went back to my bed. I lay there trembling, remembering the slim white backside, like smooth marble, lifting and falling, and the sounds of my aunt's low moans.

“Later, I heard him leave. My aunt came into my room. After listening to my regular breathing for a few moments, she left. I continued to lie there, my mind awhirl. Slowly it dawned on me what a powerful weapon I held. Sandra wanted to marry Coco. She had often said as much to her mother. In her own way, she must have loved him. At any rate, she wanted him. To me she would sneer: ‘Coco loves me. He loves me, you hear. When he marries me and takes me away to England, you will never see him again.’

“I had no idea how very potent my weapon was but I determined to use it. And I did. That very evening.

‘Yah! Yah! Yah!’ I mocked. ‘Coco doesn't love you. He doesn't care two pins for you.’ I snapped my fingers in her face. All I could think of was how much I wanted to hurt her, to pay her back for the years of misery she had inflicted upon me.

‘You little brat!’ She grabbed me by my hair. ‘How dare you say that? Take it back. Take it back at once!’

‘Let me go!’ I screamed. ‘I won't take it back. Let me go! I saw him and aunty making love. So there!’

She released me. I was delighted to see her face had lost all colour.

‘Liar! What do you know about making love?’

‘He and aunty were naked on the bed together,’ I spat out. ‘I saw his bottom going up and down, up and down.’

‘Oh, my God! MOTHER!’ Her shriek was terrifying, her face horribly contorted. ‘MOTHER!!!’ A fire, a rage burned in her eyes that I shall never forget. She dashed into the bathroom.

“My aunt came running into the room. ‘What is it? What’s happened?’ Suddenly I realized what a terrible thing I'd done. I backed away. She grabbed my arm. ‘What happened?’ she repeated, anger shining from her eyes.

‘Nothing.’ I cowered against the wall.

‘Where's Sandra?’ she demanded.

“We heard the crash of a shattering bottle, followed by a thud. We both ran into the bathroom. Sandra lay face down in a red-stained puddle that hissed as it spread.”

Estelle stopped speaking. Her eyes were downcast. Johnny and I said nothing. There was nothing to say.

At last, she lifted her wet eyes to his. “You see, Johnny,” she said, “I am responsible for my cousin's death. My aunt is the living reminder of my culpability. I told you once you could not understand the depth of my gratitude for my aunt's progress. Now perhaps you do. I love you Johnny, but I could never make you happy because I could never be happy. How could I be? Try to understand. I love you too much to let myself ruin your life as I ruined... If only I knew where to find Coco. If only I could see him and beg his forgiveness for the pain I caused him. If only I could be sure he has put the pieces together again... If... if! That’s the worst kind of torture - not knowing.”

She hid her face in her hands. Johnny went over and sat beside her, putting an arm around her. She fell to sobbing against his shoulder. He let her cry and, when her sobs subsided, he said: “Look at me, darling.” She moved back and looked into his eyes with such distress, it had me fighting my tears. “Don’t you see," he said, "if anyone can make you happy, it must be me. Now don’t interrupt. Just rest your head here and listen.” He drew her head back to his shoulder and she lay there unresisting. “You owe Coco no apology. He was much too young to be in love. Sandra was obviously suicidal and would have found some excuse to take her life. You were simply the catalyst. I’m sorry it has caused you to suffer all these years."

His eyes moved to the back of her head. He seemed to reach a decision. "This Coco, who showed you so much affection that he brought you a present every time he came over - was his father a doctor who lectured at the Medical College?” Estelle lifted her face from his shoulder. “And did they leave for England immediately after this business?”

“Yes,” she said bewildered, “but how... ?”

“Was this Coco a gangly fellow with a few pimples on his face?”

She was staring at him, wide-eyed.

“Ten years is a long time, my darling. You were such a little girl.” He kissed her cheeks and her hair. “I was drawn to you then. I’m not surprised I love you now.”

She scanned his face incredulously. “Coco?”

“I too, had to see you again. To be sure you were all right.”

“Oh, Coco!” She put her arms around him, laughing and crying at the same time.
I rose and left them, dabbing at my eyes with my handkerchief. They did not notice my departure. I now knew why Johnny was succeeding with Mrs. Jacobson; why only he could bring her back to the land of the living. I let myself out and stepped jauntily toward my car, where the driver held the door open for me.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

What an interesting and involving story. I really enjoyed it. It had a traditional feel to it, in the writing, and was very clear in expression throughout.

I liked the opening paragraphs very much, but felt rushed through their first meeting, and things proceeded a bit too quickly to meeting Mrs Jacobson - I wonder if you could break this story down into sections in order to incorporate a sense of time passing between events. A few asterisks to break up between scenes would help the reader make sense of each event at a time, I think.

The long section of Estelle's dialogue can get a bit wearing. The voice is absolutely right, no probs with that, but hearing about such large events through a character distances the reader. Maybe go into flashback instead? Find some way to tell it that doesn't involve dialogue?

The ending left me uncomfortable as really the piece would seem to call for some sort of resolution between all three characters from the past, but I did like that discomfort. It left a feeling of hidden sections of the past to be resolved. However, if you wanted to extend to include that scene, that might work well.

I think this could be really good with only a few changes.

bluepootle

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

Yes, sorry - I wasn't very clear there. A scene between Jonny and Mrs Jacobson, with the narrator present, might help to get a sense of resolution, if you wanted to tie it up more neatly. I'm not sure it's necessary, though.

e-griff

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

a small suggestion - this is very hard to read. for screen layout it would be better to leave a blank line between each para. I'll print it out to read..

e-griff

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

As I began reading, I thought at first you were adopting the precise victorian dramatic style that I myself are so fond of (The Black Boy, The Talent of Julia Cramphorne, and others on site here) - the formal language, the old fashioned (for today) phrasing . However it quickly dawned on me that you are of indian origin, or very familiar with the style. Having just finished editing two books by Indian writers (see 'member's books' forum - The Dance is Over and Whispers at Twilight) the phrasing and word use is very familiar. Of course then, I saw it was set in India!

Right, this means you have an inherent style which may be seen by some as stiff and stilted (as is my victorian style I may say). However, there are many who appreciate precise and correct writing, and enjoy the character and flavour of non-english-english writing as something different to be relished.

technically this is excellent, one or two glitches only.

reading through, a few representative comments:

'Jonny' is apparently, english. I think 'Johnny' would be more convincing.

exclamation marks: currently use of these should be severely restricted - never in narration, only in speech and only when absolutely required. Never more than one!

'I rose from my chair with an air of mystery' - blimey! how do you do that? hold your cloak in front of your eyes and tap your nose. No, to be serious, things like this are errors, 'telling' the reader something in a lazy way, rather than 'showing', which is preferable (by speech, appropriate actions).

'like you've never seen' - 'such as you've never seen'?

comma after no difference (one of your only two errors! :-) )

'flashed a broad beam' - er, a 'broad beam' can mean a large backside.

I agree with Aliya that the long narrative by Estelle is confusing (and I feel the punctuation becomes confused along the way as well - that's no 2)

and using capitals for emphasis isn't necessary. you should be able to express what you mean in plain words without fancy effects.

What I liked: the clarity and completeness of the description and style. interesting events and a continued sense of wondering from the reader as to what it was all about, sustained well. Nice flow, no glitches.

What I didn't like: the uncompromising 'tell' (although this is a characteristic of this generic style). The final plot (he just had to be Coco, didn't he?) But many will love it ...

An excellent contribution overall, though, don't mistake me. Interested to see more and see how we go.

best JohnG

pombal

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

whale - I enjoyed this immensly - quite an old fashioned style and long for an internet submission - I started reading with the intention of not finishing but it held me to the end - great!!!!! - as griff and bluep suggested - some slight editing needed - particularly around the dialogue parts

Andrea

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

An old-fashioned style that we could do with more of imo. Wonderful stuff! I do agree with Pom, though, it's a bit long for comfortable on-screen reading. People get tired (or their eyes do). May I suggest submitting in smaller chunks? A good, palatable size, for in-screen reading is max of 2000 words. This way you will get many more reads and comments. It's an indication of the quality of this piece, I think, that you have so many responses now.

Welcome to UKA :-)

sirat

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

It's difficult to come up with anything extra to say, you've had excellent critique here.

This is a very unfamiliar style of writing to me, almost as far away from my own style as you could get. It seems to belong to a bygone age, but is none the worse for that. It's very formal and a bit wordy at times, and plot seems to take priority over character.

Griff has pointed out the uncompromising 'tell', and (rightly) says that it is characteristic of this kind of writing, but my opinion, for what it's worth, is that the style is a bit alienating and cold. Your writing is very good technically, polished and professional, whether it is entirely to my taste of not.

If I could make a suggestion, what I would like to see you do is create at least one character that readers can take to their hearts and care about. Regardless of the style of telling there's a sense of emotional distance here that stops me getting more deeply involved. Sorry if that's a bit vague.

A great opening submission. Welcome to UKA.

Whale

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

Thank you, you lovely people, for your kind words and for your honest look at my work. Let me try to answer some of your comments:

Jonny is short for Jonathan.

My style of writing evolved from the authors I read as a youth and still love, Dickens, Pearl Buck, the Bronte Sisters, Jane Austin, Zane Grey, E. Phillips Oppenheim (if you haven't read "The Great Impersonation" go out and get a copy this minute), James Michener, W. Somerset Maugham, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Rudyard Kipling, Ernest Hemingway, A.J. Cronin, Robert Louis Stevenson, Oscar Wilde, et al. All of them refused to compromise on the language itself. Oscar Wilde once said: "I worked hard today - I moved a comma."

Most of you commented on the way I presented the story and would have preferred had it been related by the narrator and not the girl (at the end). Others mentioned the length. The presentation is a matter of taste and style and the story itself dictates the length. The fact remains, you all read it to the end.

Some of you have mentioned that this style of writing tends toward 'telling' and not 'showing' and used the girl's narrative at the end as an example. The girl's narrative is, in fact, a good example of 'showing' and not 'telling' as she recalls vividly what happened. One 'tells' a story by 'showing' what happened. I believe I did that.

I am not sure I like my style being called 'old-fashioned.' I much prefer Bluepottle's description of 'traditional.' Yes, I want to keep alive the tradition of good writing. I get mad when I see split infinitives for no reason. Several times I have even seen 'to not do' when 'not to do' sounds better and is easier on the tongue. I cannot understand how anyone can say 'different than.' The word 'than' suggests a comparison. How can you compare something that's different? 'Different' takes 'from' and sometimes 'to' - never, never, never 'than.' (I seem to have climbed on to my soapbox - let me get off here.)

I love the exclamation mark and overuse it. I shall have to curb myself.

I tend to write longish stories. I would love to be able to set them in a more readable format but when I go to edit, I don't see the 'Accept' button anywhere. If someone can advise, I shall be grateful.

Yes, I was born and educated in India by Belgian and Canadian Jesuit priests. My being a Jew was of little consequence, just as little to them as the Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists, Protestants, Zoroastrians and boys of every other kind of religion at the school. That is why racists remain as strange to me (and my fellow schoolmates) as evil beings from outer space. I left for England at age 22. Spent 10 years there then moved to Israel with wife and baby daughter. Had 2 sons here who ironically, when they grew up, went to make their fortunes in England. We have been Israelis for more than a couple of decades now. My education in India taught me a love of the English language and it helped that both my parents were highly literate. My mother would read adult books to us when we were 7 and 8 years old.

I assume you guys are interested in all the above. If not, I apologise for taking up your time.

My story 'Shirley' is due to appear shortly. Another long one but you may be a bit surprised at the style. So someone, please hurry and tell me how to re-format my work on the site.

Once again, thank you all, you wonderful people.

e-griff

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

I didn't mind the length, and I don't like chopping up stories just to make it shorter. As pombal exemplified - if it's a good story, people will read to the end. The serious people who will give you most feedback will do so.

on 'Jonny': in the style/time of the story, he would be called 'Johnny'. It's all about how your audience reacts, not what you intended at the time. You should change it. There is no point in telling me it is short for Jonathan - that is not in the story and he is simply a character, and Jonny is alien to me (for one) as a reader. the Jonathans I know are called Jonty or Jon.

It's a bit like having an Elizabethan period drama with a hero called 'Wayne' or 'Darren' just a small distraction you don't need

best JOhnG :-)

Slovitt

Mrs. Jacobsons Niece

Whale: Beautifully paced, and written. The style is simply structured, literate English, and reminds me of Conan Doyle.

'cloaked in an air of mystery' stumbled me as cliche-ish. Perhaps get rid of at least one of the three 'with' 's, perhaps

with skin of flaky parchment, hair grey and unkempt, straggling down the sides of her face, with eyes fixed unseeing,

and really 'her eyes fixed unseeing' would eliminate two.

You created a world in this strong story of yours and I would only niggle by saying that the ending is a little easy, and a bit brief for the bombshell being dropped on the reader. Swep

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…