From the UKAuthors Collection
HealServ
By e-griff · Originally published 15 August 2008
‘Please sit down Mr Carmody.’ The smartly-dressed man indicated the chair in front of his large desk. ‘My name’s Harker. Call me Bill.’
Donald sat. ‘Where’s Mr Dennison?’
‘Mr Dennison?’ Harker’s face was blank.
‘My consultant.’
‘Oh, of course. Forgive me, I should have known that.’ He smiled so charmingly Donald relaxed slightly. But then his puzzlement returned.
‘I have an appointment …’
‘…with Mr Dennison, yes.’ He consulted a file in front of him. Donald noticed an unfamiliar red and blue logo on it. ‘I see here you have an, er unfortunate condition, needing surgery.’
‘Yes, I have a growth here.’ Donald touched his side. ‘But what is this about, where is Mr Dennison? Is he ill?’
Harker leaned back in his big chair. Donald noticed it was new, a high backed, impressive leather chair. Mr Dennison had always used the same battered, comfortable-looking old chair.
‘Has he left?’
‘Mr Dennison has been relocated to our central facility.’ He leaned forward and smiled. ‘For greater efficiency.’
‘But I need to see him.’
‘Why?’
Donald was lost for words. Eventually he said, ‘Because I’m ill and he is my consultant.’
‘He’s already diagnosed your problem.’
‘Yes, but he is going to fix the operation. He said he would tell me today.’
Donald could not quite read Harker’s expression, but it reminded him of a father with a naughty child.
‘Mr Dennison is a highly qualified – and highly paid – consultant. Would you rather he spent his time ‘fixing’ operations for individuals such as yourself rather than diagnosing other unfortunates, using his skills fully? Would you, Mr …’ He leaned forward and consulted the file. ‘…Carmody?’
‘Look – who are you? Are you a consultant, a doctor?’
A smile creased Harker’s face. ‘Lord, no, Mr Carmody, I don’t have the skills for that kind of specialist work. I am simply a humble Senior Client Assistor. Well-trained of course, never fear. You are now under my care.’
‘But … you have no medical knowledge.’
‘True, but why do we need that? We have the diagnosis, we know what must be done. At this point you need an administrator, not a medical specialist.’
‘But … last time I had an operation …’
‘Times have changed, Mr Carmody. Would you like a cup of tea?’
‘Pardon?’
‘Tea? Coffee? A drink?’
‘Tea would be nice.’
Harker flipped a switch on the shiny new-looking device on the desk. A woman’s voice answered in a crisp tone
.
‘A tea for Mr Carmody please, Sarah.’
‘Certainly, sir.’
The switch flipped back.
‘While we wait, let me tell you of the current advances in healthcare in this country of ours. Have you heard of HealServ?’
‘What?’ Donald felt he’d somehow let Harker down.
‘The English Government recently decided to improve health care: central clinics, specialist hospitals …?’
‘Yes, I’d heard of that.’
‘Good.’
‘But how does that affect the NHS?’
Harker’s eyes looked away from him for a moment, then stared straight at him. ‘No, Mr Carmody, we now have HealServ, the health service for the 21st century. It was inaugurated just last month. Did you not see it on the news?’
Donald shook his head.
‘Really Mr Carmody.’ His tone held disappointment, Donald thought.
*
There was a tap at the door and a young woman in a catering uniform entered with a cup and saucer on a tray with some other items. ‘Your tea, sir,’ she said, dropping a placemat on the desk in front of Donald and putting the cup on it.
‘Thankyou,’ Donald said.
‘My pleasure, sir. That will be one pound fifty.’
‘Pardon?’
‘One pound fifty. For the tea, sir.’
Donald was amazed.
‘Please hurry, Mr Carmody,’ Harker said sharply, ‘I have another appointment at half-past and I haven’t briefed you yet. She has change if you need it. Biscuits are fifty pence.’
Donald shook his head, fumbling in his pocket for the coins. Harker was now tapping on the desk.
The tea was lukewarm.
‘May we continue?’
Donald choked on his tea and nodded, unable to speak.
‘I’ll have to hurry. Really, Mr Carmody, you should keep up with developments, especially those that affect you because of your current problem. We do expect our clients to be responsible and involved. After all, we do our own bit efficiently. It is not too much to ask, is it?’
‘No … no,’ Donald mumbled, recovering his voice and placing the half-empty cup on the desk.
Harker tutted and moved it onto the placemat. ‘Right, let’s get on.’ Reaching into a drawer, he pulled out a folder and pushed it across the desk to Donald.
Donald looked in bewilderment at the array of forms and leaflets it contained and took one or two out to glance over them.
‘Never mind that now.’ The tone was abrupt. ‘We don’t have much time.’
Donald pushed the leaflets back into the folder and fixed his attention on Harker.
‘Good. That is your training pack. It contains all you need to know to arrange your operation.’
As Donald’s mouth opened, the man held up a hand to silence him. ‘What you need to know is that in the new, efficient HealServ England system, you will not rely on a highly paid consultant to arrange your operation. You now have personal choice !’ Donald could hear the emphasis on these key words and wondered what they meant. Harker was now beaming triumphantly. Before Donald could react, obviously well into his stride, he continued, ‘Your treatment is in your hands. How much better could things get? You have complete choice, complete freedom.’ On the final words his hands flew up, arms apart as if embracing something joyous.
‘ ... my operation?’
‘Exactly! You personally will choose a hospital, deal with the administration, request an appointment, etcetera. One hundred percent satisfaction on your part – no more complaints about administrative tardiness or errors, it is all under your control now.’
‘But I can’t! How ...?’
Harker’s face fell. ‘Mr Carmody,’ he said slowly, ‘if you can’t take responsibility for yourself, who else will?’
‘Yes, but I need the operation urgently. Mr Dennison said there should be no delays.’
‘Exactly.’ Harker began to rise. ‘I suggest then that you get to work on the pack as soon as you get home. I hear there are backlogs of requests at the more popular hospitals – you need to get your applications in quickly.’
‘But I’ve never been good with things like this. How do I choose a hospital?’
Harker sat again and spoke carefully. ‘They are all on the internet. Find one that specialises in your problem, look at their statistics, it’s easy ...’ He waved his hand dismissively. ‘But sometimes it may be better to pick the second or third most suitable hospital to increase your chances of success. Or even lower ranking ones in less popular areas of the country. But that’s the point – it’s your choice. Perfect for you!’
‘But can’t someone tell them it’s urgent? Can’t you ask Mr Dennison?’
The man thumped his hand down onto the table. ‘Have you not been listening, Mr Carmody? Read the manual and the information leaflets I have given you. HealServ England has freed the health system from centralisation and bureaucracy. The hospitals are autonomous. It is your job to get the treatment you need. We have done our job. What more can we do? ... Look …’ He consulted his watch. ‘I really have to cut this short now, I have another appointment.’
Donald felt lost. ‘But ... this is really too much at once, could I come back?’
‘Yes, of course, fix an appointment as you leave. Or maybe you’d wish to engage a CRA, a Client Representation Assistor? It may be more affordable on your budget.’ Harker was consulting the file again.
‘But ... isn’t the NHS free?’ Donald shouted in desperation.
‘Please calm yourself, Mr Carmody.’ Harker rose from his chair and moved to the door, opening it in invitation. ‘Of course all diagnosis and treatment is free at HealServ England, as is this first advisory appointment. But I’m sure you will appreciate that clients who fail to take responsibility for their own affairs beyond that should contribute some effort, for the good of all. It would be unfair for some to receive special treatment or help, would it not? We are all equal in the new HealServ system, Mr Carmody.’
A burly security guard appeared in the doorway. ‘Problem?’ he grunted.
‘I don’t think so, Carl. Mr Carmody is just leaving. Perhaps you would see him to the door. He might wish to pick up a price list and finance plan details from Sarah on the way out.
‘Have you ever done this then – all this stuff?’ Donald shook the folder under Harker’s nose.
He smiled. ‘Ah, I have a health plan, Mr Carmody. I can give you details should you wish to join our excellent service.’
Donald left meekly with the guard. He could think of nothing to say.
Harker’s voice floated down the corridor. ‘Don’t forget he’s still got to pay for the advisory pack, Carl.’
The security guard nodded.

Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
HealServ
Wouldn't surprise me at all. Universities used to be free too. Lovely piece. There is another way, told me by my cardiologist jogging partner in Belgium, who couldn't understand why a bloke who'd been diagnosed as needing a triple by-pass would take the Eurostar with his last breath and collapse on the platform at Brussels. Ask him, I advised, if they'd scheduled his op. yet.
HealServ
Very good piece and most alarming. Thank God it hasn't quite come to that yet. On Thursday I kept an appointment with a cardiologist and was most impressed. the hospital, to which I am no starnger was ticking along even more efficiently than I remembered. My consultant had changed but his replacement was a delightful friendly Indian gentleman who even bothered to consider where I lived [about 30 miles away at least] when deciding what instructions to give me. He actually noticed the impracticality of suggesting I pop in for a heart check whenever it plays up, and suggested instead that if the surgery in the village is closed at the time, I should dial 999 and the ambulance team would check it. And that on top of assuring me that it isn't dangerous. I don't think I have the cheek to do as he says, but it was nice to still be so obviously treated as a person.
Daff
HealServ
Brilliant piece of writing John, A scary view of a possible senario for the future of health care. Superbly written. Val
HealServ
This is eerie in a funny kind of way or vice versa...Interesting read, John
Regds,
niece
HealServ
This is good satire, but it went on a bit too long. Once the reader gets your message, and I got it quite soon, I simply wanted to see how you would end it. I liked the end too.
HealServ
I could easily plagiarize by substituting with Indian names and publishing it on some website out here, and get away with it. Amazing how officialdom everywhere in the world picks up an identical jargon. Here it was Macaulay who started it, so I guess the origin is the same. And I had thought you people were better off!
Soman
Good read.
Soman
HealServ
I was "offered a choice" for my op between Poole General, The Royal Bournemouth or the Royal Dorset County Hospital in Dorchester. Plumped for Dorchester as a) it is nearest and b) they have the best rating in the country at the moment.
Having chosen I got my appointment at - Guess where?- Blandford!
Spookily close to real life already...