From the UKAuthors Collection
Green Magic
By e-griff · Originally published 16 May 2008
for Val's 'Rising Sap' challenge
This is the original. The only change I have made is the substitution of 'invade' for 'persist' as it brings a semi-rhyme for ways (see *many* comments below)
In woody boughs and willow canes the green blood flows
and drives the life of shoots and leaves in different ways.
There’s mystery and likewise threat within their springing growth:
the lashing bramble, weedy root and tangling vine invade
to creep within the dark of night. Red-blooded life must wary be,
for mingling green and red can lead to tragedy.
and here's an edit for the 'regulars' who didn't like the variable metre.
In woody boughs, soft plants, and willow canes, the green blood flows
and drives the life of shoots and leaves in many different ways.
There’s mystery and likewise threat within their springing growth:
the lashing bramble, weedy root and tangling vine invade.
So in the dark of night, red-blood must be on guard,
for mingling green with red can lead to tragedy.
I've recorded the two on audio as I meant them to be read - admit the second reading is slightly more dramatic as I was getting into my stride - haven't done this before :-)
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Green Magic
Green Magic
For some reason that didn't record what I wrote, that is twice this week it's happened to me. I wrote, O lord, another wise and wonderful one. I expected something daft from you this week but you caught me out and produced something wonderful. Val.
Green Magic
Very much enjoyed this excellent piece.
Green Magic
Thanks whoever nominated this!
I guess I was inspired by the various discussion on poetry that have taken place recently and thought I'll do something different. It was written in one late yesterday for Val's challenge, with only a couple of changes. But I've just noticed I've used 'tangling' twice --- bugger!! Can I get away with that? :-)
Green Magic
It's good, but I wish you'd kept to the same number of feet in each line. You set up an expectation of iambic hexameter with the first two lines, but then don't follow it through. Line four is too adjective heavy and reminds me stylistically of that lovely bit of overblown writing from 'Scoop' ("Feather-footed through the plashy fen passes the questing vole,") - but I don't think you were intending to write a humorous poem here, so maybe the line is a bit over-the-top.
There's a good poem here, but I think it needs some re-writing (mostly with regard to linebreaks/metre and care with descriptors) to show its true potential.
Green Magic
It has flow, yes, of course, but the uneven line lengths tripped me up, which is why I thought I should mention it. I'll be in the minority in this, obviously, but it was an instinctive reaction, and such things are often useful.
Regarding the 'overblown' line, perhaps I am guilty of a little hyperbole here - and your intentions are clear - but I mentioned it because that line from 'Scoop' really did jump straight into my head at that point and prevented me from reading the line 'properly'. Again, I may be the only person to whom this happens, but I had a feeling that this poem would produce a great heaving mass of gushy comments and I thought it might be useful to have a few thinking points, even if you didn't agree with them, if only for the sake of balance.
It's a good poem.
Green Magic
made me think of my garden which is under seige
Emma x
Green Magic
you must be happy with your poem's success Egriff, it is quite nice and interesting, but i didn't like the "must wary be" part, hmm.
Green Magic
Well, funnily enough I did think of Will the Bard, in fact Othello, when I reached the final line: "mingling green and red can lead to tragedy" has overtones for me of jealousy (green) and love/passion (red).
But apart from that and the awful "must wary be", I can't see what's Shakespearean about it. I really think you should get rid of "must wary be" because it just doesn't fit in with the rest of the poem. If it was all in jolly mock-Tudor language then fair enough, but it isn't, and so that bit of inverted syntax sticks out like a thumb sore.
Just because it's a couplet, that doesn't make it a "Shakespearean sonnet ending" and you know it. Pentameter???
Green Magic
right - I'll put it here, not with the original
Here's a 'regularised' version to please those rebels, artisus, Mac and delph, who (amazingly) demand convention and order! *gasps*
In woody boughs, soft plants, and willow canes, the green blood flows
and drives the life of shoots and leaves in many different ways.
There’s mystery and likewise threat within their springing growth:
the lashing bramble, weedy root and tangling vine invade.
So in the dark of night, the red-blood life must be on guard,
for mingling green with red can lead to tragedy.
Green Magic
An improvement, and heading closer towards sonnetry to boot. I like the half-rhymes of flows/growth and ways/invade. (Is that the reason you changed from 'persist'? 'Invade' is stronger as well.) But because of the half-rhymes, the final couplet doesn't work. It's not a couplet anymore. Also, the metre is off. I like the heptameter of the quatrain, and if you want a different metre for the couplet then great, but at present it's lopsided and clangs.
Maybe... and this has just occured to me... you could have pentameter, then hexameter, finishing on an alexandrine? Then you've still got your varying metres, but ones that work well. Something like (for 'dark of night' is something of a tautology):
So in the night, the red-blood life must be
on guard, for mingling green with red is tragedy.
Green Magic
A good one; you're definitely onto something almostinvisibleroselike here. But I agree with MacJ about the 'must wary be', which seems contrived and unnecessarily archaic. I also stumbled a little over 'likewise threat' - the glottal stop (is that it?) of 'threat' stalled me mid-line in what is otherwise a smoothly-written piece.
Rupe
Green Magic
Didn't understand it at all, needless to say, but was particularly fond of
'...the lashing bramble, weedy root and tangling vine for mingling green and red can lead to tragedy...'
Well, that's my tuppence worth, then.
(should there be a comma after 'vine' though?)
Green Magic
Your revised version with Mac's ending works. Much better.
Green Magic
Oh yeah, see wot you mean - silly me, eh?
What a life!
Green Magic
Ignore the three debunker's Griff and leave your poem exactly as you wrote it! I love it, that's why I normed it in the first place *Thumbs nose at the sticklers for rules* write as you feel, thats what I say and that's what gives each individual his/her unique voice. I'm sick of all the bloody nay sayers, that's why I've lost my own voice these days. We should all at least have the courtesy to respect each others styles and voices. (-; Val
Green Magic
Well that's the beauty of this site, people who offer advice and people who don't take it...like me.
Val's right, even badly written poetry (not that this is of course) can have something about it-the unstructured form has an inner beauty.
Anyway, back to the piece in question: I liked it and think you should leave it the way you intended.
Si...thinks he knows bleedin everything.
Congrats on the nib and nob...sorry nom :-)
Green Magic
Yes, as usual, people are talking bollocks.
I never had any problem with your original poem, Griff, apart from the "must wary be", which is rotten. Putting words in the wrong order is not rebellion against the rules, it's not an individual style, it's just lazy, bad poetry. It's just saying "Well, people put words in the wrong order 400 years ago, so why shouldn't I do it?" Because it's not 400 years ago anymore and the English language has changed, that's why.
But it was you, Griff, who expressed a desire to move towards something Shakespearean and sonnety, so I tried to help you to do that. That's why I encouraged you to rhyme and regulate your metre (which you had already partly done yourself by ordering the quatrain into half-rhyming heptameter).
It occurs to me that I can't win on this website. If I suggest that someone does something different, people whinge. If I suggest that someone does something conventional, people whinge. And if I encourage someone to carry on doing what they've already started doing, then guess what?
People whinge.
Green Magic
1st I'm not a lad, 2nd I'm not getting all feisty and flobby, merely expressing an opinion.I respect their views too, but It seems to me that sometimes certain people just shove a bit too hard. Well OK, what do I know anyway? Lots of comments get me down, but I don't usually blart about them and I am always eager for advice if it is given in the right manner, can't stand know it alls though. sorry if that offends. Sorry if my previous remarks offended too. Val (-;
Green Magic
Hmmm. Maybe, for the sake of politeness, I should just do what most people do and never say anything except:
"I have no opinions about this poem or about any poem, so I'm just going to say it's really really really good and that you should never think about rewriting anything."
Because that's all that most people seem to want to hear.
Green Magic
'yeh, but eddie, old boy, don't you think that's a bit of an excuse? Like people who say 'Oh, I can't be bothered, I'm no good at it anyway.' (and you know inside they are desperate to do something good)
If you think of a poem as a jewel, a rough diamond say - surely the inner beauty can be revealed more successfully if you polish the diamond and put it in a fine setting. Done properly, this can never HIDE the beauty.'
Yeah, I agree with what you are saying-just pointing out that a rough diamond is still something beautiful in the raw sense.
Si:-)
Green Magic
You have not created a non-regularized piece! it's very regularized with or without the must wary be bit! man, you're in the box regularizing everything. try to get out! write abstract prosetry!
Green Magic
'hey, I read that before somewhere ... :-)'
To ad a bit more Harry Enfield-From Tim dim but nice...
'REALLY!'
Si:-)
Green Magic
Ok, I will carry on. I'm just a bit fed up with the "I'm going to write the first thing that comes into my head and the fact that it's the first thing that comes into my head means that no-one is allowed to suggest changing it and anyone who does suggest changing it is a frightful bully" brigade.
I obviously don't "shove" you "too hard". You're a grown man with experience, not some jelly-kneed opinionless feeble teenager. You're always a picky stickler when it comes to commenting on other people's work (in fact you pissed me off mightily once by saying "Must try harder!" like some red-pen-brandishing schoolteacher), so you can certainly take it in return. You are a notoriously bullish stickler. You're famous for it. So why I'm expected to handle you with fluffy pink mittens I have no idea. It's a fucking joke.
As far as old-fashioned English is concerned, I'm obviously not saying that anything written in that way is no good. If I said that, I would be dismissing all literature written before 1700. What I'm saying is that such language belongs only to literature written before 1700, and shouldn't be used nowadays. Why? Well, it's obvious, isn't it? Wrong word order is unnatural, it's contrived, it's lazy, and it clangs. It doesn't reflect the way people speak in the 21st century. It was acceptable in centuries past because that's how people actually spoke, a legacy of Anglo-Saxon, and then Norman, syntax. But it's not acceptable now.
If you want to write a poem entirely in an old-fashioned style and give it, for example, a Tudor character, then that's fine. But this poem, for example, does not have a Tudor character. It's just one phrase sticking out and spoiling the poem, and I'm not going to pretend that it doesn't just in order to protect your poor, sensitive feelings, diddums.
Green Magic
Oi just a minute buster it was me who said " but It seems to me that sometimes certain people just shove a bit too hard." and I mentioned no names so cool it. Val
Green Magic
Yes, Val, I obviously know you're the one who said it, and my remarks are obviously directed at you.
You didn't need to mention any names. Who else are you likely to be talking about?
Green Magic
Griff, your inverted word order certainly looks lazy. It looks as though you've ended the line on 'be' just so that it makes an easy rhyme for 'tragedy'.
I don't know what makes you think the end of your poem sounds like the end of a sonnet. The fact that it's a couplet and has dodgy syntax is not enough. There is nothing else about it that makes it resemble a Shakespearean sonnet. There's no pentameter, no rhyming anywhere else in the poem, and the penultimate line is run-on from the line before it, which you don't get in Shakespearean sonnets. In a good Shakespearean sonnet, the final couplet is sectioned off after a volta, and acts as the conclusion. And there's no Tudor-style language or feel to any of the rest of the poem.
There is nothing sonnetish or Shakespearean about this poem, so you have no justification for your dodgy syntax. That is one darling (though I would prefer to call her 'bastard') that you really ought to kill.
Green Magic
You haven't changed them. The original version is the one at the top of the page.
"Sometimes an ordinary punter has a more open view than a 'poet'."
Doesn't make it the right view. Some people are open to ethnic cleansing.
The royal society can suck my cock.
Green Magic
I've been trying to see if I can do an audio of this, and in doing so, I've become more convinced that the original is better - never mind soddin' 'regularity' - it fits the mood better, it sounds better. still if it works out, you can judge for yourselves (does anyone listen to audios? )
Green Magic
Oooh that's quite woken me up. I was so tired I was reading in a stupor.
I've been back and read both versions again and still definitely prefer the original. I don't see it as Shakespearean but think it reads well and I don't mind 'wary be' ; but that probably doesn't surprise you. I too don't like really awkward twisted phrases but some old fashioned ones seem to me to fit. As to 'not acceptable' that is really rather authoritarian. I think I've muttered on elsewhere about 'unacceptable / old fashioned' words that 'people don't use' and mentioned that I do use them in everyday life. Maybe that makes me somewhat eccentric [probably comes of reading too much literature at too early an age] but nevertheless I feel that my style of speech is no less justifiable for use in poetry than that of the man next door.
Still on 'wary be'; if it was the end of the last line I would find it too much, but not where it is.
I love the poem, especially
the lashing bramble, weedy root and tangling vine persist
to creep within the dark of night -- adjectives included.
Daff
Green Magic
You are absolutely right, the original does sound better. Val
Green Magic
I didn't mind the variable metre of the original, which finishes octameter-hexameter. I only disliked the variable metre of the second one. Heptameter-hexameter doesn't seem to sound as good, which is why I suggested you change it to pentameter-hexameter.
The only thing I don't like about the original is the silly old-fashioned syntax.
If you're determined to end the poem on a couplet, then I suggest you use 'invade' instead of 'persist', so that you have a nice set of half-rhymes preceding it. If you've got flows and growth, it seems a shame to me to miss the chance for a half-rhymed quatrain.
Green Magic
Does this mean that you and the Bigmac are not at odds on this poem anymore?
Si:-)
Green Magic
That was the first time I'd ever heard your voice, Griff. You have an interesting accent. A sort of mixture of Welsh and West Country. I can just imagine you morris-dancing with a frothing flagon of real ale still in your hairy mitt.
The poem is certainly improved now, thanks to the insertion of 'invade'. But I shall never accept "must wary be". I mean, I know Daff is a mature lady, but I cannot believe that she or anyone else in the 21st century outside of lunatic asylums, goes around saying things like "must wary be" during the course of natural speech.
My own suggestion, not that I expect you to do anything but ignore it, would be something like:
"to creep within the dark of night. Red-blooded life must be
on guard, for mingling green and red can lead to tragedy."
Not because the metre is regular, but because the words are in the right order.
Green Magic
Sigh. Ok, then. I don't expect you to ignore my suggestion. Yes, I do. No, I don't.
Green Magic
permission to play a video as a comment Captain, in honour of your huge success.
Green Magic
Green Magic
who are all these SMILING people.STUPIDLY smiling!
Bollocky shit!
Explain yourself, Miss dolphin, est Y garanquetanque en BARDELPHINOSQUE perdue .....#
not happy with silly vid. Miss Prune!
Green Magic
(let us consider ourselves lucky Captain that I didn't play the notorious video "The amazing Greek duet aka Phenomenal Horrorwitz - Vers la Vers ")
maybe another time..
Green Magic
Okay, my favourite one.
now is it serious enough?
Green Magic
I never thought I'd agree with Griff as wholeheartedly as I did when he said this:
"who are all these SMILING people.STUPIDLY smiling! Bollocky shit!"
Yes. What exactly was the significance of either of those two extremely tedious clips?
Green Magic
i called Egriff "Captain", and i just posted a video of the Love Boat Theme, as if this is the UKA boat , so many comments, busy submission, and smiling people.
do you interrogate me? i hate explaining myself. so i'll post videos under my submissions or Nicky's from now on. have a nice day.
Green Magic
(if Egriff doesn't want the videos as I already told him he can report them and Andrea will remove them.)
Green Magic
So, what are you doing about this poem then? Anything?
Green Magic
Well, for what it's worth (which isn't a lot now that it's been so thoroughly dislumbobulated), I liked the first one AND I enjoyed listening to it to boot!
Ann
Green Magic
A nice interpretation of the challenge, I enjoyed the first one best.
Romany.