From the UKAuthors Collection
Sirat's Prose Challenge: Alared's Answer
By e-griff · Originally published 12 May 2008
One of the first stories I ever wrote (2002). It was full of 'telling' and exclamation marks. I have rewritten it substantially and hope it works better now. As it didn't for some, I've edited it again :-)
It's for David's challenge, the subject of which is self-delusion.
I wonder if people will know what it's really about?
Perception is everything..........
Alared’s Answer (edited version Tue 13 midday)
As Alared walked the stone passage to his cell, the brown-robed figure was ahead of him. Try as he might he couldn’t catch up. The occasional flick of the brown robe turning a corner and the click, clack noise of leather sandals slapping on the stones led him on, but the damn fellow eluded him every time. Wherever he went, the man seemed to evade him. Many times the brown-robed figure disappeared down an alley, slipped into a doorway, or vanished into a crowd before he could reach him.
*
Until last year, his life at the monastery had been happy. On arrival ten years ago, he was young, and unused to such society. Although his order purported to be a free and open one, he quickly discovered there was a pecking order with some of the older monks calling the shots. He’d adapted, eventually earning a place in the hierarchy.
When the old Abbot died, his replacement was a much younger man. Under his regime, things began to change and some of the older monks left. New arrivals seemed to show no respect, and got away with things that Alared hadn’t. The newcomers were so confident. They asked questions – questions that had been answered long before. Instead of accepting the answers, they debated. Alared’s gentle manner was welcomed at first, but his constant ‘can’t’, ‘shouldn’t’ and the sorrowful looks and head-shaking ensured people drifted away quickly. ‘You know, Alared,’ one of them said to him, ‘you’re probably the oldest monk here.’ They were always bright and encouraging. They made him sick. Didn’t they know the older monks just tolerated them to be polite?
One of them had taken Alared’s habitual seat for prayers. When informed, he had gazed pointedly around the half-empty chapel before moving. In their study sessions, another proposed a new interpretation and was allowed to expound on it. Alared’s traditional arguments were silenced when Berwyn asked him to let the new monk speak. How could this disrespectful upstart be allowed to speak when he was silenced? It was not just, it was not fair.
Berwyn had said, ‘These are fresh ideas, useful discussions. I can see it is disturbing for you, Alared, but things change. Everyone here has an equal chance to contribute. Even the smallest intellect may discover a bright jewel now and again.’
Alared had seethed for weeks until he eventually voiced his hurt and disdain for the administration. A long period of penance followed. At least the newcomers began to tread carefully round him, hesitating to voice ideas in his presence. That was correct – they did not dare to hold their pathetic mouthings up for his scrutiny.
More newcomers arrived – the Abbot was keen on ‘fresh blood’. ‘It’s a process of growing, learning,’ he said. ‘Our natural instinct is to mistrust something new. But we should be open and welcoming.’
Alared was convinced that one day the Abbot would have to admit he was wrong, and dreamed about a time when order would be restored. Outwardly, he was friendly, biting his tongue when cutting comments rose unbidden. When he was made Keeper of the Archives and spent most of his working day in the library, everyone breathed a sigh of relief.
*
But now there was this brown-robed stalker.
Some people thought him funny and clever. At the welcome for the newcomers, this one had walked straight in and begun a conversation with the Abbot himself, making the Abbot laugh. It was intolerable. He began to hate the man. In the following weeks, he became convinced the newcomer was stalking him. When he went to a meeting, the man was always there before him. Alared could not understand how he did it. But now he had him trapped. He had gone towards the forest where Alared liked to walk. Was he planning to tell jokes as Alared contemplated nature in serene, quiet study? Or make some supposed witty remark to him about the trees or the animals?
The brown-robed monk stood in a clearing, standing in silent contemplation. What an act. The newcomer was mimicking him.
Slipping the small knife out of his sleeve, Alared approached. A twig cracked, and the monk turned round.
‘Oh, hello Brother Alared, what are you …’ He trailed off, looking at the knife.
‘Why are you following me, why are you tormenting me? Leave me alone!’ Alared shrieked.
The new monk spoke in a calm tone. ‘But Brother Alared, it was you who followed me! You’ve been following me for weeks, ever since I got here, but I didn’t like to say anything as I’m new.’
Alared froze in confusion.
‘Can I help you?’ the man asked. ‘Should we go back to the monastery?’
Alared looked into the monk’s face, dropped the knife and fled.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
i think you should cut lines, but it's a good story.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
it is still full of telling. and slow. don't be afraid of brevity Egriff. micro-tales need it more than anything.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I found this quite enlighening, it's a reflection of life as each new generation comes along, we all resent to a degree the younger generations and new ideas, you have captured this very well here. Val
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I like the meaning, and the setting comes across well. I like the character of Alared. My probs start with the end of the story. These sections:
Why are you following me, why are you tormenting me?’ Alared hated this man, why did he not leave him alone? ‘Leave me alone!’ Alared shrieked. '
and:
Help him? This person wanted to help him. It was too much. He had no right – who did he think he was? How dare he, how dare he?
Alared looked into the monk’s face, dropped the knife and fled.'
Is pretty weak, I think. Lots of repetition and it seems to wimp out right at the end, where we don't really get a good confrontation or any insights in Alared at that moment. It needs a meatier ending. If he was so angered that the other man dared, why would he run? I'm not saying he should attack him - I think that would be a bit trite - but you need to build the motivation a little better, and extend. Where can he run to? If he's aware he has nowhere to go, you need to tell us, I think.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I can remember reading this a long time ago in an earlier form, and I think back then I tried to find things in it that weren't really there, and I still feel the urge to do this. I wanted Alared's supposed stalker to be literally his younger self, reaching out to him through some kind of time warp. I can see, particularly in this version, that the theory doesn't fit the facts, and we are back to the idea of people becoming rigid in their beliefs as they get older.
I like the exotic background of the Monastery (though I am doubtful if there has ever been a monastic community where all members were regarded as equals) and I enjoyed the actual unfolding of the story, but in the end I thought it needed a stronger theme or 'message'. I felt a bit like Peggy Lee asking: 'Is that all there is?'.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I enjoyed the read, but either it needs to be much longer or much shorter. With length, you could introduce lots of telling little incidents which all add up to explain his paranoia. With brevity, you could get to the point quickly, and have a pithy and effective tale.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
okay, accepting popular opinion, I've edited it now, cutting out some more tell and unecessary stuff. It's still not 'to the bone' yet, but hopefully a bit better. :-)
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I think the edit is quite helpful. What we seem to have now (maybe it was always there) is a story about paranoia plain and simple. Alared needs admiration and status. That is clearly what he is looking for in becoming a monk. He sees the newcomers as trying to take away from him what is rightfully his.
I wonder if it might be possible to introduce something in Alared's past that has made him this way? Also, instead of talking in general terms about how discourteous he is in debate, would it be possible to show him getting angry with people in an actual debate? I suggest the topic should be 'humility', which was a powerful concept in medieval Christianity, and would serve the added purpose of demonstrating his lack of self-knowledge.
I think you should present Alared as beginning to 'lose it' at the end, as you do to some extent, but maybe an irrational outburst would actually be more effective than his producing the knife. These are just random thoughts – for me Alared is an interesting character that could be built up into a full-blown nutcase, giving you a more dramatic story.
A couple of tiny technical points: I think this sentence: 'On arrival ten years ago, he was young, and unused to such society' should be in the past historic tense, like the one that preceeds it.
New arrivals seemed show no respect (missing 'to')
And finally, 'A long period of penance followed' doesn't sound right. Penance is a punishment imposed by the priest in confession (normally) in response to sins confessed. If you said 'self-imposed penance' the meaning would be clearer.
As we often say here, I hope this helps.
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I dunno...I like the story. Alrared definately has a lot of insecurities when it comes to changes in his cage. His neat and orderly life of ritual and lack of questioning the status quo seems to be his private santuary from actual life. What strikes me is that the prpose of his regious world seems completely lost in the politics of who runs the show and how....len
PS....Where does Vera fit into all this????
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
I dunno...I like the story. Alrared definitely has a lot of insecurities when it comes to changes in his cage. His neat and orderly life of ritual and lack of questioning the status quo seems to be his private sanctuary from actual life. What strikes me is that the purpose of his religious world seems completely lost in the politics of who runs the show and how....len
PS....Where does Vera fit into all this????
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
Sorry for the repeated comment, buddy...According to my computer, I stopped the first comment that I didn't spel chek from posting...but there it is.. :o(
Sirats Prose Challenge: Alareds Answer
Hi John,
An interesting story. At first though I thought it might be a ghost that was slipping out of sight and around corners away from Alared, but then came to realise as we go deeper into the story that it is a younger monk and that Alared is jealous, maybe even paranoid about the younger generation taking over and having more of the lime light than himself. I thought that the repitions at the end worked well and it was in keeping with the rest of the story. I think that you could 'show' a little more at the end of Alared's fright, confusion and realisation of what had actually been happening and that it was he that was following the monk and not the other way round. Still enjoyed it all though. Good story.
Lis'. xx