From the UKAuthors Collection
The World of Finance – Part 1 – Business Plans and Why You Lost Your Pension
By e-griff · Originally published 9 May 2008
'My Life' again ... This starts with a simple description of what a business plan is - so if you know, skip the start - the point being it ends up with a wee (true) story (hopefully amusing) about where the money went when shares crashed after 2000.
The World of Finance – Part 1 – Business Plans and Why You Lost Your Pension
If you want to start a business, apart from saying ‘this is a damn good idea’, it is wise to make a fair stab at working out if it’s worth it financially, wouldn’t you think? Surprisingly many big companies don’t do this. They listen to market analysts (who are basically gossips), who say, with no detailed knowledge ‘this is a great sector to be in’ and they jump in (as do the investors). They hire an MD, whose task is to blindly set up the operational business without question. The board who do this don’t get involved in detail, no sir. So often a whole business is set up and no-one has ever checked what might happen in any depth – or how many other people are intending to do the same thing. This is what happened in the telecoms industry around 2000, which resulted in a share price crash and blew a hole in pension funds (who had all been advised by market analysts that it was ‘a great sector to be in’ of course).
What is a financial model in a business plan? It’s easy, honest. Let’s consider a business I was involved in:-
Your marketing gurus work out how much money is going to come in from customers. This is a black art, but not a guess. They choose the price they are going to sell at, discounts, etc. This gives you a figure for the money you can expect to come in each month, the income. The forecast of sales is the first line of your plan, the one beneath it is the money that comes in as a result.
Under this you fill in costs. There are variable costs (costs per sale, like discounts, sales bonuses, cost of providing the product) and fixed costs (rent on the office, staff pay etc, electricity, etc etc). If you sell nothing, you still pay these fixed costs. These are worked out by people who know how much things cost.
So on a per month basis, you subtract the costs from the income, and get … profit? Easy, eh? That’s it. You have a profit, and what’s more it increases every month as your sales go up. Great!
No, that’s not quite all.
To start a business, you’ve got to ‘open the shop’ – hire people, get systems in place set up supply contracts, etc. So you are paying out with no income for some time. Where does the money come from?
Investors. They give you a lump of money. So you put that lump in at the start of your plan and it looks very healthy – you have a ‘float’.
But it’s a loan. Investors want not only payback but interest (significantly better than if they put it in a bank otherwise there's no point), and if there is risk, they want higher interest. So you’ve got to add another line that takes money away to pay back that loan on a regular basis, interest and capital, like your mortgage. Do you still have a profit?
You also take away taxes and add allowances.
The graph of profit that results from a business plan like this starts off dropping into the red alarmingly, increasingly getting worse for months. Put this against the starting lump sum and you have the ‘burn rate’ (ie, how fast you are spending other people’s money). When the first income comes in, the graph slowly (oh so slowly) slows its plummet, begins to level out, then climbs up towards the black. When it goes into the black, usually after some years, and the profit you’ve made pays off the money you’ve spent, you are at ‘break-even’ – after years, you haven’t made any extra money, just paid off the initial start-up cost and your employees and possibly something to the investors, etc.
But computer systems, furniture etc, don’t last forever. Computers? 3 years-5 years. So in your plan, you have to put many of those original start-up costs in again at various intervals for renewal – that knocks out a lot of the spare money.
Depending on the business, you may have to go out 10 years or more before the business is seen to be viable.
A good test for the kind of longer-term developing business I was involved in was to halve the sales and double the costs and see if the plan still worked. If it made it, it was probably okay. Marketeers are always optimistic, and cost estimates are always too low.
Anyway, now you are expert in business plans, here’s a little story:
I, and a couple of others were hired by a start-up company to evaluate their prospects, create a business plan and advise on strategy. The company was started as a joint venture between a US company and a European company. They already had a posh HQ building in a European capital and a hundred or so staff beavering away on stuff. We made a preliminary visit for the MD and others to brief us etc.
They had no financial people or business planners, just an accountant (also hired in). I’m not financially qualified, but I can write a business plan (with suitable disclaimers ).
‘Have you got a model?’ I asked, assuming the investment prospectus had included a reasonable model, or at least internally, they’d got one. ‘Oh yes, I’ll mail you the file.’ Off I go back to the UK. Sure enough, I get the ‘model’. Model, it isn’t. I get all the details of the costs so far and the ‘burn rate’ – the accountant has accounted for it very well. The model starts with a large sum (many tens of millions of dollars) they’d raised, which is melting away rapidly at an increasing rate as they swallow it up. Okay, I have the first bit of my model, but it’s clear they’ll need further investment to start the business as the float is running out even before the business is planned to start.
I take all the figures from their own marketing group, we check all the cost figures. I attend meetings with suppliers, regulators and agents and try to establish terms and conditions and costs for the future business.
I draw up a projection for 10 years with the best information we can get. It doesn’t work. It’s not just poor, it doesn’t work. No-one would invest in this business. I massage it, I let them get more optimistic, I look for ways to save costs and increase income. Nothing.
We call for a meeting to tell them. After we arrive, I tell the person who hired us about it first, face to face. They say, ‘That’s not your business.’ My heart sinks. I think they don’t look surprised. I think they’re taking the dosh while they can, hunting for another job, and waiting for a statutory pay-off.
We go into the meeting with the MD. I distribute copies of the projection. The accountant (naturally) picks it up and has a quick look. His eyes widen. He looks at me. I nod. He drops it hurriedly and looks down. We chat about inputs and markets and competition etc, and after some while, the MD picks up the projection and his eyes go to the bottom line (that’s all MD’s ever do).
Do you know what he says? Can you believe what he says? Not ‘oh dear’ or ‘blimey’ or ‘explain this to me quick’ but: ‘I can’t show this to the Board’!
My colleagues and I look at each other. We continue politely, I agree to some amendments (which aren’t gonna make any real difference).
On the way home, we agree to finish off everything and not take on any more work from the company. I check the burn rate in their financial info, and see that they have about three month’s money left. We wrap up our tasks, accept the MD’s thanks and bang in our bill. It’s paid within a month – they are good payers.
Two months after that I read the paper. They’ve gone belly-up.
Imagine this scene repeated all over the shop, which is what happened in the telecoms business as well. Is it a joke? No, it’s real, I assure you. It’s unbelievable, but real. In the sector of a sector this start-up was in, there were 20 hopeful competitors, all spending start-up money. My projection was based on my lot getting more than 50pc of the market and it STILL didn’t work.
That’s where your pensions went – into the pockets of MD’s, start-up employees etc etc – oh and consultants like me of course (but we were very good value).
Gobsmacked? Of course I was. But not surprised.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The World of Finance – Part 1 – Business Plans and Why You Lost Your Pension
Very informative write..Kinda sounds like the Dot Com. crash, although, a dozen angels could dance on the head of a pin and still leave plenty of room for what I know about business plans.. :o)...len
The World of Finance – Part 1 – Business Plans and Why You Lost Your Pension
Griff, I read this all the way through to my other half.
He listened, intently and at the end he said, "Yep - that's business all right."
Tina:-)