From the UKAuthors Collection

Bus Trip Home

By Squiddlydee · Originally published 21 April 2008

...

Bus trip home from school on Thursday
Glossy, dark and rain outside
Smearing swear words on the steamy
windows where the worlds collide

Jostling, humid, dog-eared pages
Pencils, muddy boots and books
Girls sing ‘oh, she's just outrageous’
Burn the boys with icy looks

Clap on shoulder, see ya smelly
Shoot him with their finger guns
Warm front rooms (hot tea and telly)
Gobble up the lucky ones

Bus stops come and go. The voices
Dissipate. He stays on top
Thinks ‘of all her nutty choices
Why live by the furthest stop?’

He’s alone. The plastic bottle
Drunk and empty, dances ‘round.
Hang on when the burst of throttle
Throws him with a panic sound

Up the hill and corner-tipping
Then the brakes, the wheezing door
Puddle splish and drizzle gripping
Chills him to his dismal core.

Cold, cocooned in bus-stop gloom, he
Looks towards that sombre place.
Peering from his mother’s room, he
Sees her weakly smiling face

Vodka slops, she lurches, crumbling
Scrapes away an errant tear.
Now he’s home with splintered, mumbling
Wretched, ruined Mother-dear

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

rhyme and rhythm fine in this one, in fact this rhythm is very appropriate for the subject and fits well. I think the scene was set well, small details - the mood carried to the reader well, and then the telling ending. an excellent poem overall, IMO.

the verses are set syllabically in 8/7/8/7 in (generally) Iambic tetrameter. Looking at it accentually, you have four beats (strong stresses) per line.

In the last verse, however, lines 2 effectively has only three beats (wine/fag/other) and in line 4 there is an unstressed syllable missing between 'This' and 'mother'. Just to illustrate what I'm saying (not necessarily a suggestion for adoption)- these changes below would square the rhythm - see if you can hear the difference:

And a glass in one hand, slopping

Wine; a fag held in the other.

Wonders ‘has she done the shopping,

She who used to be my mother?’

'other' and 'mother' have very soft feminine endings, so although you may now count 8 syllables, in fact the '-er' isn't

counted (it almost disappears when you say it). Note that in every other verse you have used masculine (hard/stressed)endings for lines 2 and 4 - this is what creates the 7 rather than 8 syllable count in an iambic tetrameter as the trailing unstressed part of the iamb is omitted.

If in doubt, just think how many beats per line, that's the essence of it. 'Baa-baa black sheep' is all over the place syllabically, but sounds fine because the beats (accentual) are right. ... end of ramble. best JohnG

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

on the basis that you fix the last verse (and as I've indicated, but not stated as such, changed other and mother somehow), I hope you wil accept this rare 'Griffpick' :-)

Photobucket

Albermund

Bus Trip Home

Well, at least he lived by the bus stop! Very nice poem mostly, squidds. You really got me on board with this guy. Particularly liked verse/stanza.3 and esp gobble. Not sure about "Throws him with a panic sound" but what buggered this completely though was the ending. Rhythm completely up spout left me floundering. Also I think you really have to enter the room to see wine & fags. Still, despite my girns, very promising. cheers Albert :)

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

My fave verse is also the third, with its finger guns in particular.

Yeah, you really ought to sort out the final verse, it's metrically all over the place. Also, I don't see the merit of ending lines on 'gloom, he' and 'room, he', when you can just end them on 'gloom' and 'room', which would make more sense.

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

'Tim' for your next post then?...

OK, the last verse is a lot better now, though the punctuation's still a bit of a mind-fuck. But not being one for pedantry, I can't be arsed to talk about that.

I think you need to understand syllables better - it's not all about a simple matter of counting. I don't know what Griff's been saying to you (I tried to read his comment but it looked so technical and snooze-inducing that I couldn't), but it doesn't matter shit if there is one more or one less syllable in a line. The important thing is that there are four stressed syllables per line. Lines ought to end the way they do for good reasons, and in a rhyming poem, rhyme counts as one of those reasons. If you were rhyming 'room, he' with 'gloomy', then it'd be OK to end a line on 'he'. But as you're just rhyming 'room' with 'gloom', there's no justification for it. It just looks shit.

Like I say, don't worry about how many syllables there are in a line. As long as it scans and there is a consistent pattern of stressed syllables, it'll be fine. When poetry becomes merely a matter of counting syllables, it stops being poetry and becomes mathematics.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

I think Mac said some of things I did about accentual rhythm. He is right in that you don't use analysis to judge whether a poem is good or bad, you use your ear. But when your ear say 'Oi! summat's wrong ear' ( :-) ) you use analysis to see what the problem could be, and then to suggest a remedy.

Syllables do matter, sadly. If you were Greek, Roman or modern day Spanish (I am told), you could count syllables and be spot on. (Dylan's 'do not go gentle...' is entirely syllabic). In english, you have to cobble together the essential anglo saxon base of accentual verse, and explain it with various modified 'rules' for accentual-syllabic which mainly duck and weave, trying to account for the fact that english has variable-length syllables and therefore cannot be simply quantified.

Anyway *yawns* - cut to the chase. I complained about your last verse (as did others) because it didn't read right, full stop. You have produced a driving poem with a characteristic rhythm. How does the last verse serve it?

And a glass in one hand, slopping

Wine; her fag pinched in the other

Wonders ‘has she done the shopping?

Her; this used-to-be-my-mother’

Hmmm - bit bitty ... How about (as a stab)

Wine glass in her right hand slopping

Left hand holds her fag in it

Wonders ‘has she done the shopping?

She's my mother. Bloody shit!'

this, IMO. while in content maybe not correct, hits the rhythm and mood of the rest of the poem. Bang!

so this is a 'kill your darlings' moment - forget the attempt to slow or pause the poem, let it rip to the end like a tide, and end with a bang.

best JohnG

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

"Hemistich consonantal rhyme"? Eh? Where? Do you mean the lines beginning 'wine' and 'her'? As these lines are broken up very early indeed, I don't think that just 'wine' and 'her' constitute hemistichs. Or maybe I've missed something.

Anyway, I don't want to blab on too much about this poem, but I do like it (the poem, and the blabbing) so I might as well continue.

"I have this thing about using (or abusing) the consistency of the metre for effect."

Eh? Do you mean you are deliberately sticking 'he' on the ends of lines for effect? If so, then I don't think it works.

If you mean you are conforming to or messing up the syllable-count for effect, then that works even less, because no bugger (apart from a pedant like Griff) is going to notice or care about the number of syllables in the line.

Mathematics may be all well and sexy, but it doesn't mix with poetry...

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

ah, and you were doing so well lately, Mr Mac.

sense and politeness, eh? Of course you can have your own opinion. Others can have them too, yes?

I don't mind the 'he's' at all, Squid if that's what you want to say. It has an effect.

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

I'm not being impolite, Griff, but you ARE a pedant. That's not such an insult, is it? Flaunt your pedantry. It goes towards making you the amusing character you are.

There is no good reason or proper artistic justification for sticking those 'he's on the end of those lines. That's not a damning verdict on the entire poem, it's just me noticing an artistic mistake. Why single that one verse out for odd endings? Why not do it in other verses as well? There's no reason for it. Can you, Griff, explain the 'effect' it gives? Because I can't see one.

I admire Squid's poetry a lot, in fact I'm the only person to fave-author him and give him consistent and extensive encouragement. But if he does something that doesn't make sense, he should be told so, not misled and advised to keep doing it.

Griff, you are of course entitled to your opinion about this 'he' business. But your opinion is wrong...

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

I like things to be 'correct' if they are meant to be, but I also accept things that are 'incorrect' quite happily if they work. The word 'pedant' means someone who is overkeen on 'correctness', to the detriment of the content, and in that sense it is pejorative, therefore impolite. If I were indeed a pedant, I might be saying 'no, those 'he's are wrong!' but I happen to accept them as creating a nice little effect in the reading and approve of them. That's my opinion. Your OPINION is that you disagree - that's fine - but it's your opinion.

Squiddly will make up his own mind. I went on a bit about the metre to convince/explain to get that last verse fixed, which I think we all agreed was 'wrong' :-) . That was not 'pedantic', I feel, just good sound analysis. The aim of course is for the author to improve their work by considering comments and judging them, understanding, not blindly following what others say, which I'm pleased to see he has done.

eddiesolo

Bus Trip Home

I really like this-last verse correct or not-doesn't matter one jot-the feel of the poem is clear and deep. The tension of the bus ride and descriptions are spot on-this took me way back to my school days on the bus.

Great stuff and a fave and a 10 from me. So down to earth and real and to be honest I thought a top write, well done.

Si:-)

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

OK! At last, last verse is vastly improved.

I also think the oxymoronic "Burn the boys with icy looks" is really clever.

I still don't like them poxy 'he's though.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

Since you asked ....The rhythm in the last verse is indeed now 'right' for the whole poem and you've managed to include a good end line which is effectively just four stressed syllables (ie it is not iambic) but that works well in this context as a termination to the driving rhythm - you screech us to a halt successfully.

You've been suffering a lot with this - I am not completely sure why it's been so difficult for you. But it is worth it - this IS a good poem, worth getting right IMO

so ...

My only slight qualm with the last verse are the words used - splintered is not immediately appropriate, and it is puzzling until you read the rest. This introduces an uncertainty (at least for me) just where you don't need it (in your finale) :-)

Now he’s home with splintered, mumbling

Wretched, ruined Mother-dear

as an example only:

Now he’s home with her, his mumbling,

Wretched, ruined Mother-dear

- has (at least) a continuity of meaning with no surprises, the 'his' making sure the reader reads the following adjectives as belonging to a word they haven't got to yet - a clear signal. And it leaves your final punch line clear and free.

*

the other thing I've just noticed (I don't know if you've changed it) is the third line:

Cold, cocooned in bus-stop gloom, he

Looks towards that sombre place.

Peering from his mother’s room, he

Sees her weakly smiling face

- I completely misread the subject of 'peering' - as 'he' , very much encouraged by following it with 'his mother's room, he sees ...' - I agree many will read it as you intend, but this time I read it 'HE IS peering from his mother's room AND he sees ...' do you see what I mean? I'm there thinking 'surely he's in the bus stop?'

please don't let me drive you over the edge .... :-)

Cold, cocooned in bus-stop gloom, he

Looks towards that sombre place.

The window of his mother’s room

Reveals her weakly smiling face

would do it, but then, I guess you'll either disagree or write a change yourself - so this is just a prompt ... am I picky? yes of course :-)

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

By Jove, I hadn't even noticed that. Too busy being annoyed by the 'he's, no doubt.

Griff's right, the syntax of that line makes no sense, as obviously he can't be peering from his mother's room. Griff's rewrite makes more sense, apart of course from the fact that "gloom, he" doesn't rhyme with "room".

How about:

Cold, cocooned in bus-stop gloom, he

Looks towards that sombre place.

The window of his mother’s room re-

Veals her weakly smiling face.

?

But I jest.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

'gloom, he' and 'room' rhyme fine for me (gloom/room are the key sounds). perhaps we could call the 'he' 'prejambement' ?

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

sorry, I meant to add that the 'he' is needed for the 8 syllables line (Unless squiddly wants to change it for summat else), to maintain the strict 8/7/8/7 structure. My proposed third line does have the eight syllables of course, but no 'he'.

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

No. Let's just call the 'he' 'the start of the next bloody line, for Christ's sake'.

Would, Griff, you rhyme 'left' with 'hefty'?

Actually, you probably would...

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

"sorry, I meant to add that the 'he' is needed for the 8 syllables line...to maintain the strict 8/7/8/7 structure."

You see, this is what I mean when I talk about pedantry. Who the fuck says there has to be a "strict 8/7/8/7 structure"? What purpose does it serve?

Poetry is about language, not numbers.

If you can't end a line on a feminine rhyme, then come clean and end it on a masculine one. Don't try and 'get away with it' by sticking an extra little syllable on the end. It's pointless and it doesn't work.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

For Mac (among others)

It IS the structure it is. No one has said it HAD to be anything, certainly not me. :-) Squiddly chose it.

Surely you can hear the rhythm? It's a driving rhythm, dependent on the alternating masculine/feminine ending couplets. Suggesting a faltering of this in the very last verse would undermine the finale. Squiddly has done a great job (rhythically) with the new last verse, especially the (acceptable to the ear) shift in the last line.

Don't get hung up on the 'he' , eh? I reckon even if you put it on the next line, people would read it rhythmically as intended. That's life.

Analysis is only a tool, it doesn't lead, it follows. You use it to discover why something sounds 'off' and cure it. No good poet writes to metric rules, they write by ear.

Rhythmic poetry IS numbers. Most music is numbers. That's natural, nature is numbers. Numbers describe rhythm, patterns. Poetry is patterns (even when they don't rhyme, the metre is patterned), music is patterns.

That's life. That's natural. Numbers/patterns/life, eh? Fractals.

Best. G

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

"It IS the structure it is. No one has said it HAD to be anything, certainly not me. :-) Squiddly chose it."

With respect to Squiddly, and I respect him and like his work a lot, he is a new poet who is learning the tricks of the trade. He is sticking rigidly to this numerical pattern because he thinks he has to, when he doesn't. For some reason you, Griff, are encouraging him to take this wrong-headed, clinical, numerical, approach. You DID say the poem has to be in that particular structure. You said "the 'he' is needed for the 8 syllables line...to maintain the strict 8/7/8/7 structure." You're saying it's 'needed', it's necessary, that the strict structure ought to be 'maintained'.

"Surely you can hear the rhythm? It's a driving rhythm, dependent on the alternating masculine/feminine ending couplets. Suggesting a faltering of this in the very last verse would undermine the finale."

Of course I can hear the rhythm, and of course it would be better if the feminine/masculine rhyme rotation continued all the way through. But the truth is, the 'room, he'/'gloom, he' rhyme is where it falters anyway. Neither are proper feminine rhymes. There are natural pauses before the 'he's, there are not only spaces but also commas between the words, so 'gloom' and 'room' don't even feel or sound like feminine rhymes. They sound like the masculine rhymes they are. So, if Squiddly can't think of proper feminine rhymes for this verse (penultimate verse you mean, not the very last one), then he should admit it and use masculine rhymes instead. Otherwise it just looks shoddy. There is obviously a pause after a comma, so that is the obvious moment where the line should be broken.

"I reckon even if you put it on the next line, people would read it rhythmically as intended."

It's not so much a question of how the line is read, as a question of how the line is written. You don't put 'he' at the end of a line without a clear and important artistic reason, and Squiddly doesn't have one.

"No good poet writes to metric rules, they write by ear."

Well, why then do you insist that he maintains a strict 8/7/8/7 structure? And why contradict yourself straight away by saying "Rhythmic poetry IS numbers"?

Poets can either write by ear or follow structural/numerical rules all the time. Which should they do? You seem to be suggesting they should do both at the same time.

e-griff

Bus Trip Home

you do the first (ear), the rest (numbers) follows as a consequence ... that's what I mean. I think I said that though.

read what I said again ...

I think squiddly can make up his own mind, I'm happy for him to do that ... and I don't think he's the kind of person who can be browbeaten or persuaded against his will, so I am very open with him.

But I've said me bit, and rejoindered too much. Will leave you to it now. :-)

Macjoyce

Bus Trip Home

I'm not browbeating him. I'm just trying to give him some good advice as an alternative to the bad advice you are giving him.

Andrea

Bus Trip Home

Poor ol' Sqiddles - bet he's having a job keeping up :-)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…