From the UKAuthors Collection

The Lovers

By Yutka · Originally published 11 April 2008

...They need no bed for feeling intimate...

This is not what they mean
when they say "die for love", or "burnt by fire,"
more stem a rising flood that reaches high
up to the chin, but does not let one die
or drown desire.

This is what’s written as in secret ink.
Held up it spells their words in lower tune
and makes a mark for walks more firmly in the dusk
and in the dark, facing their ghosts,
the whisperers of gloom.

They need no bed for feeling intimate,
just looking at an eye’s glint and a lip
that only arches slightly, with a hint of strength
and does not need a handle there to grip.

This is why they hold on,
when they fear things to drop or time runs out
but play a waiting game, where both will pass
the ball like players up unto the end
when one’s without.

This is why they’re so quiet
when they look at defeat and words have gone.
It is the way their eyes are holding on
to each other’s image, unchanged, complete,
till lines are drawn.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Corin

The Lovers

So beautiful and so well crafted Yutka - I presume that this is relative to Larkin's Dockery and Son - only much less gloomy than Larkin:-)

Life is first boredom, then fear.

Whether or not we use it, it goes,

And leaves what something hidden from us chose,

And age, and then the only end of age.

red-dragon

The Lovers

Wonderful. As Corin said, finely crafted and worthy of the nomination. Ann

e-griff

The Lovers

Overall, this is potentially an excellent poem, very rich in words and imagery, flowing.

But it raised a few questions with me:

Rhyme: I liked the internal rhymes, love/flood, eyes/ slightly, dread/bed for instance. But I was confused by the pattern. In verses 1,3,4,5 you rhyme end line 2 with the last line end. But out/without may be too direct, and in V5 you also rhyme line 3 with 2 and 5. Then in verse 2, you have tune/dread. This last one threw me ('doom' might work instead of dread), as did the others to a lesser extent. I'm just puzzled as to why you did it that way.

Then there are a few things I didn't understand:

There is a slight conflict of the tense of 'die' and 'burnt'

'More stem ...' - I can just about work out that this might be a dramatic protestation of some kind. It would be clearer to say 'more likely stem ... if I read it right, but the tense of 'does' also conflicts with 'stem' unless you replace the 'but' with 'that' . Then again, I may be reading this wildly wrong.

Just looking at an eye’s glint and a lip

that only arches slightly, with a hint of strength

and does not need a handle where to grip.

This seems incomplete grammatically. I was expecting a statement, assuming 'just ... ' was an opening, eg 'Just looking at .... can be enough.' for instance. Hope you see what I mean. I can't see it referring back to the 'bed' line.

and 'where to grip' simply doesn't make sense in the last line. 'for to grip' might fit, but it's not sparkling. 'there to grip' ?

'up unto'? who says that? you might mean 'up until', or better, simply 'until'

'they fear things to fall' -- didn't understand.

'when one's without' - just don't understand this at all.

Last verse: I don't like 'they're' but quickly let me say that is a personal preference, thinking of the tone of the speech in the rest of the poem. Similarly personal, I'd use 'face' defeat rather than 'look at'.

Okay, I've been very critical on this. Reason being I think it's mostly very good. If my comments help, I'll be very pleased. If I've got some things completely wrong, forgive me, please.

best, JohnG

Sunken

The Lovers

Well done Ms. Yutka. It's good to see you getting some positive feedback. I shall remain as inane as ever, if you don't mind. It's for the best. The last time I tried to be clever I got arrested. I still say my testicle vent was a good idea tho. Congrats on the nib and nom.

s

u

n

k

e

n

e-griff

The Lovers

Rhyme: I liked the internal rhymes, love/flood, eyes/ slightly, dread/bed for instance. But I was confused by the pattern. In verses 1,3,4,5 you rhyme end line 2 with the last line end. But out/without may be too direct, and in V5 you also rhyme line 3 with 2 and 5. Then in verse 2, you have tune/dread. This last one threw me ('doom' might work instead of dread), as did the others to a lesser extent. I'm just puzzled as to why you did it that way.

Then there are a few things I didn't understand:

There is a slight conflict of the tense of 'die' and 'burnt'

'More stem ...' - I can just about work out that this might be a dramatic protestation of some kind. It would be clearer to say 'more likely stem ... if I read it right, but the tense of 'does' also conflicts with 'stem' unless you replace the 'but' with 'that' . Then again, I may be reading this wildly wrong.

Just looking at an eye’s glint and a lip

that only arches slightly, with a hint of strength

and does not need a handle where to grip.

This seems incomplete grammatically. I was expecting a statement, assuming 'just ... ' was an opening, eg 'Just looking at .... can be enough.' for instance. Hope you see what I mean. I can't see it referring back to the 'bed' line.

and 'where to grip' simply doesn't make sense in the last line. 'for to grip' might fit, but it's not sparkling. 'there to grip' ?

'up unto'? who says that? you might mean 'up until', or better, simply 'until'

'they fear things to fall' -- didn't understand.

'when one's without' - just don't understand this at all.

Last verse: I don't like 'they're' but quickly let me say that is a personal preference, thinking of the tone of the speech in the rest of the poem. Similarly personal, I'd use 'face' defeat rather than 'look at'.

Okay, I've been very critical on this. Reason being I think it's mostly very good. If my comments help, I'll be very pleased. If I've got some things completely wrong, forgive me, please.

best, JohnG

Reply from Yutka

Thanks John for your elaborate and appreciated comments. Here is my answer:

My poem has no consistent rhyme, it does not have to be put into a straight jacket, has it?

There are lots of poets who do not adhere to a strict rhyming pattern.

“die for love” or “burnt by fire” are sayings. It does not matter that they are in different tenses, I think.

I do not think you are right about “stem” ( it belongs to: what they mean....they stem....)

May be you are right about "the handle where ..." and I better put "which"

The word “just” is used as “only”. Is that not clear? It is not a full blown statement. It is more as one speaks: just doing this, just doing that. Yes?

They hold on, when they fear….should be clear

'when one's without' - you said "just don't understand this at all"

It’s pretty obvious. Why don’t you understand this?

Re.:'they're' -You are right. It’s personal

You said "I'd use 'face' defeat rather than 'look at'."

I see this as a cliche, prefer "look at defeat"

But thank you again.

Yutka:)

 

This is not what they mean

when they say "die for love", or "burnt by fire"

More stem a rising flood that reaches high

up to the chin, but does not let one die

or drown desire.

This is what’s written as in secret ink.

Held up it spells their words in lower tune

and makes a mark for walks more firmly in the dusk

and in the dark, facing their ghosts,

the whisperers of dread.

They need no bed for feeling intimate.

Just looking at an eye’s glint and a lip

that only arches slightly, with a hint of strength

and does not need a handle where to grip.

This is why they hold on,

when they fear things to fall or time runs out

but play a waiting game, where both will pass

the ball like players up unto the end

when one’s without.

This is why they’re so quiet

when they look at defeat and words have gone.

It is the way their eyes are holding on

to each other’s image, unchanged, complete,

till lines are drawn.

 

Okay, sorry to come back again (and don't want to be boorish) but I'll explain as I go.

1. rhyme. Of course you don't have to fit any particular rhyme scheme. But, as they say, if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's a duck. Four out of five of your verses have a strict rhyme scheme (one with an out of place extra rhyme). One verse departs from the norm. You set the reader's expectations with the first verse. We all like order, we see patterns. You've told us – here is a rhyme scheme. Then in the second verse it goes haywire, THEN the next three go back to the regular rhyme scheme of the first. So 80pc of your poem follows a regular rhyme scheme and the odd one out looks like an error. Changing dread to doom would remove this objection.

THAT's my point. NOT that you HAVE to have one (a rhyme scheme). But you've mostly got one.

2. Okay, I see what you mean about 'stem'. I misinterpreted it, I agree now you have explained what you intended. But, for me it still makes little sense. Do you mean 'more of them' – if so, 'most stem' would be clearer in referring to people.

3. 'which' (handle) does not work either, I'm afraid. 'there' works, as I said, but you might wish to recast altogether if you don't like that.

4. Okay: 'just'. No, that was not clear to me, but I see what you mean now. The problem is partly the full stop after intimate, which effectively disconnects the two thoughts. I'd suggest a comma, and then say 'just to look … ' which immediately connects them. However, 'just to' is hard to say, with the 't' sounds and the rhythm, so I'd say 'only to' as more acceptable unless there's a better way …

5. 'when they fear things to fall' is not clear I'm afraid, unless I am being thick, nor is it grammatic. Think about it. Similarly 'when one's without' . I did say I didn't understand them – what they mean in context, so I'm no wiser as you haven't given me a clue. But in the latter, after several ponders, I think you mean 'left without the ball'. But that really is not clear. 'until one's left without' might be nearer. But there is still a confusion of 'without' (with the meaning 'outside').

6. 'face defeat' may be a cliché, but it's effective. 'look at defeat' doesn't say the same thing at all. Words like 'expect' 'presume' 'imagine' etc might be better than 'look at' …

that's all, best, JohnG ...

e-griff

The Lovers

sorry. Yutka, I posted the whole bloody lot again by mistake, and this stupid site won't let me edit it.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…