From the UKAuthors Collection
Beard's Prose challenge --- Solitary
By e-griff · Originally published 25 February 2008
based on a random title and last four words (see Prose workshop thread)
also based on my recent poem, Castaway
edited Tuesday morning ...
Solitary
Today is stormy: clouds, rain showers, the sky moving rapidly. On the beach, the great curve of the bay eclipses the horizon on either hand. I stand, staring out to sea, and as ever, there is nothing.
I came to this place across the wide ocean, seeking something in my life, I know not what. Now I may never learn, for there is nothing here. I stand alone on this beach. The mountain that rises behind me is ancient, its wooded slopes populated with abundant small game, fruits, nuts, berries and root vegetables. It is clear I will not starve.
More’s the pity. For what am I to do? Simply survive?
I left Bristol on a schooner, ‘The Royalist’, the property of Sir James Brooke, the ‘White Rajah of Sarawak’. Plying her trade between England and the East Indias, she was armed and flew the white ensign, an honour rarely accorded to a private ship. It was a good berth which promised me much.
The first few weeks were routine. I gained a position as bosun, even when the rapscallion of a mate bore down on me for no apparent reason. He gave me cause to be on my guard, and a less than pleasant time ensued as we ventured into equatorial seas. He would take any opportunity to curse me, to find fault, and during one stormy night it became too much for me and I struck him.
The penalty could have been death. Justice is simple and quick at sea. But the first mate, knowing well the provocation I had suffered, sought leniency and they cast me adrift in a small boat, which drifted here after long days. Sometimes I wonder if death would have been preferable to this.
Many would think of the island as paradise. For sure, the climate is warm and pleasant. The tropical storms are harsh but they bring the fresh water that flows abundantly from the mountain, and I have made a good shelter, nestled in the trees. It is a wonder none live here, perhaps because this island is so far from anywhere, away from shipping routes. Otherwise I could expect a ship to arrive in order to charge its store with water, fresh fruit and game. But none has come.
Sometimes I recall a rhyme my mother used to recite to me when I was a boy:
O give me a day when the sky is filled
With a balm-scented wind from the south
And the warmth of the sun on my arms and my chest
And the taste of soft fruit in my mouth
The hell is the loneliness. The hell is being alone. The hell is knowing the world is running, leaving you behind, forgetting you: my wife, my parents, brothers and sisters, my children – what has become of them? They will know nothing of my fate, for it is unlikely anyone from the ship will tell them as I shared little of my history on board.
To live in paradise is every man’s dream. To live in paradise alone ....
But I hope. I have trimmed a tall tree close to the beach and, using a square of sailcloth from the few supplies I was granted, hung a flag, hoping it will attract attention.
I am realistic about my hopes. That is what they are, and all they are. I must create a reality, begin from a base of belief and construct my existence, my reason for living. I must start with a goal.
And so what must my goal be? My aim in life? I have none here to influence, impress or subdue, no evil to counter, no good to laud, no sanctity to revere. So what is left to me in this hell? Some hope lies in my father’s philosophy – my only hope – which I shall follow, day by day: ‘If you can’t be better than others, be better than yourself’.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
That was great. I really enjoyed it.
I have to say I didn't feel comfortable with its historical setting, for some reason I was looking forward to it being modern and felt mild disappointment when I got to the temporal placement. However, that is nothing to do with the writing.
I really like the last paragraph. In and of itself that was good and stands up on its own.
I wasn't comfortable with some of the language, but that is just me I think.
Great.
Cheers
Brd.
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
The sense of loneliness being the hardest thing of all to bear was what came to me most strongly from this, and I suspect it is probably true.
Would the ship's captain really have gone so far out his way though, to make you a castaway? The piece relates that the island is not on a shipping route and time was money to the traders of the sea. It would have been much easier to flog you, throw you in the hold to rot or just chuck you overboard. Why would the first mate seek leniency in this case? They were the two doubts that rose from this piece, for me.
Romany.
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
I liked the language and the setting. I wasn't keen on the first 'Nothing!' but that might just be my personal exclamation mark problem.
Towards the end, I think you've overused the word 'Hell' when once is really enough. It's such an emotive word that you need to underplay it to keep its impact. But the repetition of 'hope' at the end works very well, I think, stressing what am empty life the castaway has.
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
This is just an experiment e-griff - it might help or it could be way out of line - just pm me and I won't do it again - I thought I would try edit it in the way I would write it :
I came to this place across the wide ocean, seeking something in my life, I know not what. Now I may never learn, for there is nothing here - I stand alone on this beach.
The mountain that rises behind is abundant with small game, fruits, nuts and berries. It is clear I will not starve.
More’s the pity. For what am I to do? Simply survive?
I left Bristol on a schooner, ‘The Royalist’, the property of Sir James Brooke, the ‘White Rajah of Sarawak’. Plying her trade between England and the East Indias, she was armed and flew the white ensign, an honour rarely accorded to a private ship.
The first few weeks were routine. I gained a position as bosun, even when the rapscallion of a mate bore down on me for no apparent reason.
Nevertheless, I had cause to be on my guard, and a less than pleasant time ensued as we ventured into equatorial seas. He would take any opportunity to curse me, to find fault, and during one stormy night it became too much for me and I struck him.
The penalty could have been death. Justice is simple and quick at sea. But the first mate, knowing of the provocation I had suffered, sought leniency from the captain and they cast me adrift in a small boat, which drifted here after long days with only a few provisions.
Sometimes I wonder if death would have been preferable to this hell.
Many would think of the island as paradise. For sure, the climate is warm and pleasant. The tropical storms are harsh but they bring the fresh water that flows abundantly from the mountain, and I have made a good shelter, nestled in the trees. It is a wonder none live here, perhaps because this island is so far from anywhere, away from shipping routes. Otherwise I could expect a ship to arrive in order to charge its store with water, fresh fruit and game. But none has come.
Sometimes I recall a rhyme my mother used to recite to me when I was a boy:
O give me a day when the sky is filled
With a balm-scented wind from the south
And the warmth of the sun on my arms and my chest
And the taste of soft fruit in my mouth
The hell is the loneliness. The hell is being alone. The hell is knowing the world is running, leaving you behind, forgetting you.
My mother and father, brothers and sisters, my wife, my children – what has become of them? They will know not what has become of me, for it is unlikely anyone from the ship will tell them, there was no one who knew me on board and I shared little of my history.
To live in paradise is every man’s dream. But to live in paradise alone ....
But I hope. I have trimmed a tall tree close to the beach and, using a square of sailcloth from the few supplies I was granted, hung a flag, hoping it will attract attention.
I am realistic about my hopes. That is what they are, and all they are. I must create a reality, begin from a base of belief and construct my existence, my reason for living. I must start with a goal.
And so what must my goal be? My aim in life? I have none here to influence, impress or subdue, no evil to counter, no good to laud, no sanctity to revere. So what is left to me in this hell? Some hope lies in my father’s philosophy – my only hope – which I shall follow, day by day: ‘If you can’t be better than others, be better than yourself’.
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
An interesting one, based on a situation that everyone must have wondered about occasionally - how would we cope in that kind of situation?
It's well-written and convincingly detailed, but the ending didn't do a lot for me, with its note of heroic stoicism. The problem is partly structural of course, in the sense that in order to round it out you'd have to write a much longer story - but it's also too much what the reader expects: the stout yeoman touch.
I wanted a twist, or a bit of puncturing of the myth. Maybe that's because I've always found Ben Gunn ('many's the night I've dreamt of cheese, toasted mostly') a more convincing marooned mariner than Robinson Crusoe. I've got this feeling that it's more realistic to expect a person in those circumstances to go loopy and spend their time obsessing about toasted cheese than to retain a positive mental outlook. It's also more interesting. Perhaps that's just me though.
Rupe
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
cheers for your understanding John - a useful experiment I think. I may not have been right on some of the edits but I do think ultimately it has helped your story, and that can only be a good thing :)
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
I really enjoyed the authentic-sounding wording of this write..That last line is great advice. Any paradise alone is Hell, in my opinion..len
Beards Prose challenge --- Solitary
Hi e-griff,
an interesting story. I liked the voice of the character, his feelings came across well and I also like the descriptiveness of it too, especially at the begining. It gave off good imagery of the 'paradise' he was on. Towards the end though I don't think it read as well as it has through most of the piece. I think that after the rhyme it wasn't as tightly written and in some places found it a little repetative, but not much. In saying that though I still enjoyed the read.
Lis'. xx