From the UKAuthors Collection
The Irish Argument
By Aurelio · Originally published 25 February 2008
actually inspired by my friend and colleague John Bede in Northern Ireland...
Going down the bleeding heart of Ireland
the depth of history reveals innumerable wounds
like of a raped mother,
since Ireland was christened long before the English,
who for centuries were arduously compelled to seek protection
against civil wars and barbarism in most remote and isolated places
such as Lindisfarne and Iona just to survive,
while Ireland was gloriously alive and making harps
committing all their life to culture and to music.
All we could do about Britain was to pity their barbarity
as they oppressed us in the middle ages,
occupied us and turned Ireland into endless civil wars
and slaughtered us through centuries
to crown their senseless cruelty by ethnic cleansing,
planting protestantic Englishmen in Ulster,
the worst thing that England ever did to Ireland;
and so we pitied them and even more
when they went into the Great War
partaking in the massacre of humankind
and of civilization,
at which point the best thing we could do
was simply finally once and for all to leave them on their own;
and thus we still continue pitying them today
but think they should be better off without us.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Irish Argument
Aurelio,
I'm sorry, but I have to be frank.
This is not poetry. It is completely literal and factual, using no imagination and leaving nothing to the imagination. You are entirely telling and not showing. There is no wordplay or linguistic subtlety, and it is generally unpoetic.
As someone of mixed Irish and Welsh descent myself, it's not as though this is an instinctual 'English' reaction. You might as well have written an essay on Irish history and put it in the 'non-fiction' section.
I think you should go back and start again, and I don't mean to be rude or disrespectful.
The Irish Argument
I find this unsatisfying because it is simply a one-sided recitation of the supposed 'crimes' of the English (ie the Irish are perfect harp-playing angels and always right and the English are evil and always wrong - Life isn't like that) In that way (only, not because of the language) it is unsubtle and unsophisticated. A poem/view that also understood the motivation of the 'English' (but see later) and indeed the Normans and the other Norsemen who had influence in Ireland would be far more powerful, insightful and appealing, IMO.
The people of England were also 'wronged' by various powers in their own country, they too were forced into war, and at various times starved, suffered and died at the whim of others. It is not really useful to talk about 'The Irish' or 'The English' as if each individual was defined by some common template of each - they are not. It is more about powerful people or factions oppressing others.
Anyway that's my view. :-) best , JohnG
The Irish Argument
Well, yes, there is that as well. Even leaving aside the lack of poetry, there is the fact that much of this is historically inaccurate. For example, confusing 'England' with 'Britain'. The Saxons did not colonise all of Britain, and Celtic civilisation continued in Wales, Scotland and Cornwall, just as it did in Ireland.
Also, "planting protestantic Englishmen in Ulster". This, again, is the sort of historical inaccuracy and generalisation about British history that you'd expect from a foreigner.
Most Protestants in Northern Ireland are of Scottish descent, not English. They ought to recognise the greater historical, racial and linguistic link between Scotland and Ireland, but instead the bigotry is based on religion.