From the UKAuthors Collection
Mountain Poems
By e-griff · Originally published 4 February 2008
Prompted by BBC Radio 4 again (a programme on mountain climbing).
The first one has been removed, as has the hybrid one. There is always a time when you have to listen to your audience :-)
Mountain 2
The trouble with a mountain
As I’ve found over the years
Is every ridge you conquer
Another one appears
You climb each slope. The skyline
Is there, so clear and bright
And just as you approach the ridge
Another comes in sight
But finally you reach the top
And stand there with a frown
Because that's when you realise:
The only way is down.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Mountain Poems
Mountain 2 is really good but I didn't like Mountain 1
Mountain Poems
I think you should merge them together as you use the same rhyme in your stanzas - and leave out some of version 1. Mountains are very much like life, I've found! I think I'm over the hill! Ann
Mountain Poems
Mountain 2 is spot on. An excellent short poem. Mountain 1 has a good idea, but the flow just isn't there.
Mountain Poems
How about trying them together stanza 1 from M1 then stanza one from M2 (like K2, eh?) but in italics, so they sort of answer each other - 2 different 'voices'.
Just an alternative way of looking at the it. Ann
Mountain Poems
could work, but now it is obvious that the third stanza of the first poem is problematic or not good enough. and that's why i didn't like the first poem at all. i simply don't like it. mob? i don't even like the job line. is there a right place? i don't know much about mountaineering but is it important this *right* place? unless you have become philosophical in this stanza in which case you must be careful - you didn't return to the right place poetically speaking *a fiasco is the outcome of your effort (first poem), or let's say disappointment..*
if you manage to edit this stanza then it could work! and would be very good. well.. hmm. you can always keep the second poem.
Mountain Poems
In which case (yes Egriff I saw what you were trying to do but an oversimplistic notion won't help your poetry here)
There’s something about this mountain
The climber said with a frown
It’s not about the getting up
It’s all about coming down
Ascending, you can see the way
– it’s always in your sight.
Descending then, you tend to think,
Should I go left or right?
Climbing up this mountain
Is only half the job
It’s returning to the right place
That separates you from the mob
now your first mountain poem works. don't forget to try them together as well. brilliant idea this one Ann.
ps: i didn't complicate it.
Mountain Poems
do you accept critique from me Egriff or do I belong to the foreign* language group? clarify this first and then i'll see if i can do something for your case.
*not second. foreign. wiki
Mountain Poems
This: (Informal) Used as an emphatic substitute for the indefinite article
This is often used in speech and informal writing as an emphatic substitute for the indefinite article to refer to a specific thing or person: You should talk to this friend of mine at the Department of Motor Vehicles. I have this terrible feeling that I forgot to turn off the gas.
that's all Egriff. bye now.
Mountain Poems
Combining the two poems was an interesting experiment, but it doesn’t work. Mountain 2 is a seriously good poem. Leave it alone. Don’t dilute it.
Okay, Mountain 1. Here are a few possible changes. If I were to do it again in five minutes time, it would probably be completely different, but here you are. It’s more interesting, has a jauntier rhythm, and avoids the ghastly rhyme you used to complete the poem:
There’s something about a mountain,
the climber said with a frown.
It’s not about the getting up,
but rather the coming down.
Ascending, it’s easy to see the way
– it’s always in your sight,
but on the descent, you must ask yourself
is it left, or is it right?
Climbing a difficult mountain
makes you feel that you’re the best
but finding your way back down again
is what separates you from the rest.
Mountain Poems
Hi griffy -i really like Mountain 2 -although the comma after 'Is there,' really broke the flow for me and not in a good way - it is easier for me to read without the comma, leaning on the rhyme scheme and break at the end of the line - that's how it felt. Mountain one -i didnt like because it didnt seem to say anything at all to me - will pop back to see what happens to a mix of the two -but as Dave the Heating Engineer said to me over dinner the other night 'Sack the Poet', i say to you - 'Sack no.1 Mountain' - and Mountain 2 is a keeper :o) xxldx
Mountain Poems
the last two lines of that verse are deliberately disruptive. No, they are not 'smooth and conforming' they signify a change in tone, a hard insistence, a jump out of the quiet, acquiescent tone of the preceding ones ...
that's what you said, you mean this hard insistence this jump out of the quiet, this acquiescent tone of the preceding ones
doesn't make a mountain this mountain??
i'll rate the second poem. and rest my case...
Mountain Poems
I like poem 2 as well.
Think that here 'Is there, so clear and bright ' you need another comma to close the clause.
I didn't really like the mixed version. It confused me but I'm probably extra confusable today as I have migraine and should really not be meddling.
Daff
Mountain Poems
Okay, I've tried different ways and bow to public opinion - Mountain no1 (in all its forms) goes. end of story
thanks all.
G