From the UKAuthors Collection
Castaway
By e-griff · Originally published 25 January 2008
I was on a beach once ...
Castaway
Upon a sudden morning,
as wind and rain blew free,
I found myself, a sullen man,
beside a sullen sea.
Out on the far horizon
I saw no thing to spy,
The blank and vacant skyline
cast all my hopes awry.
And in the bitter sunlight
that plays upon the sand,
the curve of the great bayside
eclipsing either hand:
Behind me lies the mountain,
Before me, bleak and bare,
the ocean wide that brought me here
returns my vacant stare.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Castaway
What can one say it's purrrfect (-; great rhyming and rhythm, I'm jealous. Val
Castaway
Brings to mind Aberffraw beach on Anglesey and the Anthony Gormley statues on Formby beach, gazing out to sea. Mesmerising...... Particularly liked the repetition of 'sullen' - a great word! Ann
Castaway
Nice to know that decent rhymed poetry is not yet dead. This made me nostalgic, if one can be nostalgic for sad times. I remember often going to the coast often just to stare like that.
Daff
Castaway
*Strong critique warning.*
Ouch. Archaic as hell. Don't like it. However... I need to justify such comments, so here goes.
Nobody says 'upon a sudden morning'. They might say 'on a Sunday morning', but that's as close as you'll get in 'real' speech, and okay, this is poetry so you can use heightened speech to a certain extent, but this is too OTT for my liking.
'as wind and rain blew free'. How else could they blow?
The repetition of 'sullen' would be effective except that you've used 'sudden' earlier.
'I saw no thing to spy' is tautologous (or however you spell it). 'I saw nothing' is what you're trying to say, but again, you've lurched into this nasty archaic way of speaking that insists on spare and superfluous words.
'The blank and vacant skyline' is fine, except that you've just said you couldn't see anything on the horizon, so you're repeating yourself.
'cast all my hopes awry' is a nasty cliché put in to rhyme with 'sky'.
I like the 'bitter sunlight', but was surprised that it's sunny given your earlier statement, 'as wind and rain blew free'. Which is it? Sunny or rainy?
Can a bay have a side? It's a bay. A curve. Not a side. Seaside, okay, but bayside? Nope.
'eclipsing either hand' doesn't mean anything at all as far as I can make out.
The grammar in the last stanza's wrong. It works if you put a full stop after mountain. It works without a full stop if 'returns' is 'returning', because 'lies' is the main verb of this sentence. Of course that mucks up your rhythm.
I've now read everyone else's comments. I see I'm in a minority... lol. That should cheer you up ;-)
Castaway
Ok then...
Upon a sudden morning,
as wind and rain blew free,
I found myself, a sullen man,
beside a sullen sea.
I don't have a problem with 'sullen'. That bit reminds me of Coleridge's 'Rime of the Ancient Mariner'. But I don't get 'sudden'. How can a morning be sudden? Also, yes, delph is right, 'upon' is too much, and 'blow free' doesn't really mean anything.
Out on the far horizon
I saw no thing to spy,
The blank and vacant skyline
cast all my hopes awry.
Yes, again, she's right about this verse. And 'awry' is a very silly word in itself.
And in the bitter sunlight
that plays upon the sand,
the curve of the great bayside
eclipsing either hand:
I don't get the last line. But a bay can of course have a side. Otherwise it would just be a body of water surrounded by more water, like the Sargasso Sea.
Behind me lies the mountain,
Before me, bleak and bare,
the ocean wide that brought me here
returns my vacant stare.
That's ok. But yes, a full-stop is needed at the end of the first line.
Castaway
when writing this, I deliberately completed the rhythm in the first and last verses in the third line with masculine endings, to create an opening and then a close.
Castaway
I like this, it has a nice pace and flow to it. I personally would do away with the first comma in the third line, first stanza:
I found myself, a sullen man,
But perhpas that comes down to personal taste and it's a small thing anyway. I like the analogy of the cliffs returning a vacant stare, too.
Romany.
Castaway
I fear the ancient mariner
Doth turn round in his grave
To find himself dressed in pastiche
With his wrong foot in the wave!
Castaway
You're welcome to comment on my work whenever you like, Griff. I find you amusing.
Alone, alone, all all alone, alone on the wide wide sea,
Mac
Castaway
When I read Delph's comment it was as if I was reading my comment that I backspaced. Of course it didn't sound natural and maybe that's why I have been backspacing lots of comments lately. Anyway...
Castaway
You probably know that I detest most rhyming poetry, it's the sing-song silliness of it that I can't stand. You can take a serrious subject give it a few rhymes and suddenly you're singing a nursery rhyme. However with this one it didn't feel that way at all. It struck me as all being a long time ago and far, far away and the words were lulling enough that the rhyme complimented rather than jarred.
Liked this and especially the first verse or stanza or whatever the hell it is.
Castaway
I am so glad that I don't read anybody's comments before reading the piece and posting my own. All that disecting would have put me right off the poem, which I thought was lovely. I know diddly squat about how a poem should be written, but this came across to me as being written in a certain style and because of that style a distinct form of language was used that fit. As to something not actually meaning anything... hell what does it matter if the rest does and it preserves the mood and style and carries the poem on. I'm sure you found the crit useful Griffy, I would have too if it was one of my pieces, but it's good to read and commnet first before seeing what other people think.