From the UKAuthors Collection

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

By e-griff · Originally published 21 January 2008

Och, just a wee 'Russian Sonnet' for the challenge!

The Power of Words

'O would the power the giftie gie us'
The famous Scottish blokey said
'To see ourselves as others see us'
But now that Scottish blokey's dead.
It's hard to tell the man's intention
by any normal intervention.
The meaning's not completely clear
– among those words that sound so queer
and do not always seem too pretty.
But some men's thoughts will always win
a place amidst the wordly din –
they come out really sharp and witty.
It seems that worth lies not in word
but thought most carefully inferred.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

It's surprising how many different styles the russian sonnet will support, isn't it? The formal, emotional, modern, and here the witty poem that trips along so lightly. Great last lines.

red-dragon

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

Verrrryy clever!! A sharp and witty sonnet, which I really enjoyed! Ann

Bradene

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

Yes I have to hand it to you Griff, very witty and enjoyable. Val

delph_ambi

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

The form's fine. Of course. Be highly embarrassing for you if it weren't.

First quattrain - excellent. Love the tone.

Second quattrain - good. No problems.

Third - loses steam and is a little forced. 'and do not always seem too pretty' has a load of words that don't do anything in particular, but are there to make up the syllable count. You've already spotted the repeated 'some'. 'they come out really sharp and witty' is another weak one - 'really' is a word that rarely has a place in prose, let alone poetry.

Last couplet is a good idea, but 'word' should be 'words' to make the phrase sound more natural - which you haven't used, because it mucks up your rhyme with 'inferred'. I would have used 'words' anyway, and then 'thoughts' in the last line. Would have felt less forced that way.

I'm being a bit mean. It's a fun sonnet. Very enjoyable. However, given your skills as a wordsmith, I think it could have been a wee bit better.

teifii

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

Very witty. You certainly rose to your own challenge. I expect most of us had to find out the rules before attempting this.

I was relieved you didn't stick to Scots as I find it unreadable so not a fan of the Scottish bard [sorry sorry Scotland!]

Thanks Griff for giving our brains a gentle push.

Daff

Macjoyce

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

This is alright, I suppose.

Romany

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

Clever indeed and very good!

Romany.

Sooz

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

This is very polished and 'professional' I can understand that a lot of thought and work went into getting the bloody words to fit in their little places. I have a question. I presume firstly you decide what form the poem is going to be, then you must have an idea. So within your idea you then know that you want to say this, this, this and this, And then you have to chip and chop at your idea until it fits the form. Is this how it works? See what strikes me there is that the poem is more important than the words. It's like that mouse trap game that takes half a day to set up and two minutes to play. Or like buying a child an expensive gift and then watching them play with the box. Nope, rigid form isn't for me... but I don't half admire the work that goes into it.

Sooz

Poetry Challenge - The Power of Words

I do want to understand and I did try quite a few different forms a few years ago. What I don't get though is male and female words. I've just read this one again, it's witty AND it's clever and even has a message to deliver. I can see that you've got the from and managed to do it without that awful thing where poets take a word, any word as long as it fits or rhymes. But you've talked about female and male words or word endings ... I don't understand. How do I (the ignorant reader) know which is which?

Right try this another way. I know there are rules because I've followed one or two of the threads. I know that this line has to rhyme with that one, or this one is repeated three times, or whatever .... I don't understand the female and male thing at all. What I'm getting at is ...with rigid poetry you are catring for such a small number of people. somebody who has no idea about poetry at all could come along and enjoy it .. but if they don't undrstand the rules he isn't going to know just how clever it is, or how much thought and work has gone into it. And now I've wafled myself into a mes and don't even know what point I was trying to make myself.

Anyway I enjoyed it in my limited capacity and think that it's one for publication.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…