From the UKAuthors Collection

A New Beginning for UK Authors

By e-griff · Originally published 4 January 2008

A truly humble suggestion ...

A New Beginning for UK Authors by Hereward Taft (Humblewriter)

While the site is peaceful and temporarily freed from the dead hand that so carefully controls it, I'd like to make a small suggestion. Of course, I have no criticism of the lady or the admirable work she has done so far in bringing UKA to its present level. But there are times when a new hand is needed on the tiller so a ship can sail onwards, far, far further than previously imagined. Compare the present management, say, to a pilot – someone whose skill it is to navigate a ship from a particular harbour to the open sea, to make the first halting steps in what could be an infinite journey – if allowed. Sadly, despite the pilot's value and considerable skill at a basic working level, they have no higher skills which would enable them and their fellow travellers to cross an ocean, to circumnavigate the globe – and beyond, to soar to artistic heaven on sails of silken cloud!

For that, you need a Captain, a true captain. And I am such, humbly willing to dispose my services to the site with no thought of aggrandisement or personal gratification. Indeed, in my busy writing life it would be but a further burden. But – as ever, I am willing to give, selflessly and humbly!

My suggestions are simple and obvious to all men (and dear ladies) of intellect and wisdom.

One of the problems on this site is the admixture of those with little talent and those very few of us whose talent transcends the everyday. While accepting that it is indeed our duty to teach and throw crumbs of encouragement to others, surely we few need space to breathe and expand, to talk and write at a higher level without the muddiness of the idle comments of the hoi-polloi.

I am sure the lesser talents among site members fully recognise the giants who stride amongst you – towering talents whose light shines down, illuminating your own puny efforts. Be clear here, I am in no way denigrating these efforts, such as they are. I am sure amongst yourselves you gain considerable pleasure and enlightenment from your chitter-chatter. But that is your world. Just as an ant, toiling at its mundane tasks, might look up and for one tiny instant glimpse the wonder of the aetherial being that a good writer surely is, so I am sure most of you can appreciate that there is a higher plane which most of you will never (and can never) know more fully. That is the place that we good writers inhabit. And I am not ashamed to proclaim it, for it is a fact, an observation so clear as to be undeniable even to those of severely limited intellectual capacity.

Having stated the basis of my case (so clearly that it must be accepted by all but the deluded), I will go on now to present my proposals for the future of our UKA, a site we all cherish, of course.

First -

Let us class members into attainment levels. These will be:

Member (This is the lowest level of talent, to which most of you belong).

Writer (One who has higher level skills and intellectual capacity)

Author (The cream of the 'Writers' – those who shine, stand out)

Master (The ultimate high-level talent. Those whose smallest bon-mots are worthy of note, whose opinions are flawless and perfectly-based, whose every writing is a jewel, a treasure of infinite worth).

At present, of course, to any objective judgement, I stand alone in this latter class. But it is to be hoped that a trawl of Nobel, Pulitzer and other prize winners might, just might, throw up a few more candidates, for it would be tragedy for such as I to be deprived of the intellectual stimulation of their peers.

There are probably a few here who might fit in the category of 'Author', several 'Writers' of course, and the 95% plus who remain are clearly plain 'Members'.

It is my proposition that there should be mechanisms to prevent confusion on the site. Often advice from well-meaning but unskilled writers can despoil a burgeoning talent by giving bad advice or telling them: 'this is perfect – don't change a thing!' Thus, in the site mechanism, it will be impossible for those of a lower class to comment on the work of those in a higher class. Obviously the opposite will not be the case, as that would go against the whole principle of sharing and equality that this site stands for. It is our duty to help those less fortunate than ourselves, even though often such advice is either ignored or misunderstood by the limited talents on whom we bestow it.

Additionally, within each class, there will be a grading. Each person will have a place in the overall order. So within each class, a person of grade 3 may not comment on someone of a higher grade (ie 2 and 1). Also, no one of lower rank (grade and class) may contradict an opinion of a higher-ranking person, and of course, a higher-ranking person will have the right to remove previous comments by lower-ranking ones should they disagree.

How are these grades and classes assigned? How does a person improve, make their way up the ladder as it were? That is simple. Each person is voted for by those in the class above them, with each higher class having more votes than a lower one, and each person's grade giving them more voting weight than one of a grade below them. So those voted for may make their way upwards.

This is such a clear and simple idea that I wonder no one has before proposed it. But that is something that often happens in my life – what is simple to me seems incomprehensible to many.

In the 'Master' class, of course, no change in grade can ever take place, so just as an example, my humble self will remain as grade 1 in the premier class, a position I humbly and sincerely undertake to respect and use wisely in my vote (which currently, of course, would override all other votes).

The perceptive amongst you will see that this proposal is both wise and appropriate, socially just and far-seeing to promote a lively site of the highest quality. Others must simply admit that lesser intellectual skills and base personal pride may obscure their judgement on the matter, but let me say: I do not blame you for an instant! One cannot blame a dog for its inability to use a computer, or a cockroach for its failure to sing. Similarly, I treasure the experience of living amongst you – you, the salt of the Earth!. And I defend your right to remain ignorant and limited in your own way.

I have explained and defined the new scheme – a writer's paradise, I opine! But I am sure some of the more intelligent amongst you might have thought of a similar shining truth, given enough time.

So – when shall we introduce this new scheme? Today? I have a great respect for the current management, so surely it would be kinder to make such an improvement before the author of the present mish-mash returns? Being asked to consider this scheme could well be taxing to her limited capacity for thought.

What say?

Sincerely and humbly at your disposal,

Hereward Taft. (Humblewriter)

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Humblewriter

A New Beginning for UK Authors

How dare you post this without my permission!

Macjoyce

A New Beginning for UK Authors

I'm worried about you, Griff. You really do scare me at times. Not only did you waste a significant proportion of your life writing the above pointless bollocks (I didn't even bother reading to the end), you then felt the need to comment on it and then reply to yourself. Have you got nothing better to do with your time?

artisus

A New Beginning for UK Authors

your reply to Humblewriter is very enlightening. this is good satire by the way. one of the first things i read earl-ier. and maybe one of the best.

delph_ambi

A New Beginning for UK Authors

Trouble is, by these rules none of us is qualified to comment, so I'd best shut up and say no more.

Macjoyce

A New Beginning for UK Authors

You continue to worry me, Griff. You replied to my comment and then deleted the reply. Why? What's the point?

Do you actually think anyone is dim enough to think that Humblewriter isn't you? I don't understand why you're doing this. Why are you wasting your time writing such pointless and parochial nonsense? It's insular and not even funny. There's a wide world out there, Griff. Kindly emerge into it. I'm sure you can do better than this.

dylan

A New Beginning for UK Authors

Taft certainly isn`t one of your most entertaining comic creations.

I think my favourite was Topsy -it was superb the way you and he used to argue about your work.And then you forgot who you were logged in as and ended up arguing with yourself! Comedy genius-they still laugh about it on ABC.

Then there was Posy,when you pretended to be a young woman from Fife and offered all sorts of advice to yourself.

Brilliant!

Taft isn`t in that class-as satire this is as funny as a wet weekend in Airdrie. Still, knowing you, I`m sure you will come up with some new rib-tickling antics soon.

Macjoyce

A New Beginning for UK Authors

No, Griff, I think you are missing the point. The point of literature and all art is to reflect what's out there in the world, and to create something beautiful or at least entertaining. It is not to waste your life writing about the writers' website to which you belong, in a way that isn't beautiful or entertaining.

You're right, I don't have to read your meanderings, but I just expect better.

artisus

A New Beginning for UK Authors

this is an ironic piece it's satire based on irony, and unfortunately these are the main problems arising in writing communities between writers whether we like it or not. one of the best qualities in Griffy's character is his caustic irony that more than often turns against his own self. i disagree with him a lot on many things and i think that he has to relax a bit, but don't we all? none of these issues are critical for our lives.

cheers.

artisus

A New Beginning for UK Authors

*is* (and who knows what else)

peace (you too Egriff)

Romany

A New Beginning for UK Authors

I can't wait to read Andrea's comment on this!

Romany.

richardh

A New Beginning for UK Authors

>er .... you think I might be castigated?< IS that a typing error griff? ;)

teifii

A New Beginning for UK Authors

What do you mean Mr Taft, Sir, a dog can't use a computer? Clearly you haven't read my book. Please do so at http://www.merilang.co.uk/shop.merilang.htm

Yours respectfully

Teifi Dog

Humblewriter

A New Beginning for UK Authors

Madam, my erstwhile amanuensis posted this item in my name and I cannot edit or remove it. In fact, I was intending to solicit opinions from influential members of this site, privately, and happened to still have him on my e-mail list. I regret the fact that my apt and apposite assertions have caused you grief, but suggest maybe that your dog is 'the exception that proves the rule' as it were. However, as a man of learning and the highest intelligence, it is indeed hard for me to believe that a dog could have small enough paws, let alone the wit and intelligence, to operate a computer.

I understand you come from Wales, madam, the same part of the country as the despicable e-griff claims for his ancestry. This may indeed explain your aberration. Certainly you have my commiserations on that score, as well as my humble and sincere regards. Diolch and doris, as I believe you say.

Hereward.

e-griff

A New Beginning for UK Authors

Seriously though, there ARE real sites that have these rules (segregation, not allowed to comment, etc). Let's be grateful for what we've got :-)

Andrea

A New Beginning for UK Authors

'The author of the present mish-mash' has returned!

While the cat's away, eh?

I shall deal with you on the morrow!

(when I'm a little less knackered)

Andrea

A New Beginning for UK Authors

'The author of the present mish-mash' has returned!

While the cat's away, eh?

I shall deal with you on the morrow!

(when I'm a little less knackered)

Humblewriter

A New Beginning for UK Authors

So good you said it twice, dear lady!

Believe me, I have no brief to denigrate your efforts or minimise the (obviously mild) effect you have had so far.

Welcome back! Chaos still reigns, I'm afraid. That Daphne, and Bluebugger have held sway over our simple minds since you have been absent. Threats, blarts and shenannigins have been pluralised. I simply despair.

But we must all move on. We need a leader who can control this mayhem. Do they have 'homes' for older people in Dutchland?

Benevolently (and humbly), Hereward.

eddiesolo

A New Beginning for UK Authors

Mmmmmmmm...I have been pondering your wordage and feel that it is justified and should be taken on-board by all lesser beings on this website. However. I do feel that if you fall into the class of Master then you are finished as a writer...you can no no longer strive for perfection and with that ending in sight you must now accept that your work cannot get better, so your comments and crit become flawed as you strive to better and better yourself BUT FAILING HA HA HA...*wipes drool from chin*. I will leave it there and just say...I take it that my work, I know needs guidance but must fall into writer...if not author and if not- do you take bribes?

I liked this, (regarding) comments it drew out the anal in some.

Take care and hoped you had a good Christmas and are having a good 2008.

Si:-)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…