From the UKAuthors Collection

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

By Gerry · Originally published 19 October 2007

I am sure there is a place for Crit, but it needs to be approached carefully. If you give it on the basis of 'I am better than you' then perhaps you ought to think about it a bit more...

If anyone has missed me on UKA of late, I have been tied up trying to get my book ready for publishing and err, trying to find a publisher. Not an easy job. I have dropped in occasionally to read a few posts – but not many. I have posted a few old posts on Thoughtcafe, but have not written anything new.

On Monday I posted ‘On Being A Genius’ on ‘Google-groups Thought café’ site. I noticed an error and tried to correct it. Google in their wisdom have made this impossible—well for me anyway. I decided the way forward was to terminate my membership and start again. This went okay, but it didn't remove my article. On Tuesday the post started to get hits, and because I was no longer a member, I couldn’t respond. Maybe I wouldn’t have anyway.
To proceed further with this read you will have to be familiar with the said post: -

On Being A Genius

This post received a nib and some nice comments on UKA.

The following two comments were taken from my post on ‘Google thoughtcafe.’ I consider them to be offensive, insulting, nasty, cruel, arrogant, and totally uncalled for. The two people are obviously full of their own importance, but not bright enough to realise the 'tongue in cheek' intent of the post. (It was spotted by the very first reader on UKA when posted here) and was of course a take on ‘Walter Mitty’. The clue was there, as the author 'James Thurber' was mentioned; but the connections seems not to have been made. It is surely critique of this nature that puts people off writing--- especially young writers who are more sensitive to attack.

Anyway here are the comments, see what you make of them, and if you think they could in anyway be justified.

Comment one: -

“I found your writing lacked humour or relevance. It was a straight
bio and as such, lacked the emotional pastiche I love in writing. In
the writer you mentioned, Thurber, it is his tongue in cheek ability
to poke fun at himself and his encounters that make him such a
wonderful talent and wit.

A laundry list of your accomplishments without any context of how it
affected others is a journey through a cattle chute rather than an
adventure in wonderland. If you are writing for an audience of
yourself, fine. It is a resume of your accomplishments. It is
joyless and juiceless so in effect you are telling your audience that
having an outstanding mind vitiated the necessity to have a life.

If you are going to spew on for many paragraphs and expect that a real
reader will spend time reading it, you need to pay more attention to
how you phrase your writing. If I kicked a dictionary, I would expect
a similar torrent of words to pour forth. What makes writing
different from listing is developing a context within which the
material makes sense and importance to the reader - not the writer.

I would rather read that your mother died of typhus giving birth to
you than you were probably a genius at birth. You are your own
context. No one else is worthy to exist in your cold and
intellectually high-ceilinged but bleak establishment.

I spent a few wasted moments in Mensa listening to self-appointed
geniuses (genii?) bragging about how intelligent they were. To me,
intelligence is not what is measured by a test but what is used in the
context of a life well lived. You, instead, tell people you wouldn't
want to put yourself on a pedestal while building one to stand on ...
or stoop on if your ego is so large that it won't fit under the
ceiling.

If I were to diagnose this piece, I would start off by saying that the
writer had an "I" infection. “

Comment two :-

“Do not look down on, or patronise, those whom you consider may be
mentally inferior to you---you might just be wrong.'

Why did you write the above? What relevance does it have?
A first paragraph should engage the reader. You talk about your parents not bragging. You talk about not trying to feel superior. You talk about
devising a method so that other people wouldn't know. That's probably the most important thing about this paragraph yet you don't mention what it is.

Give us a reason to care about why you derived much pleasure from other
people thinking that you were just average, or why you just cruised through school.

Honestly this paragraph doesn't make much sense. By the time you go to
university or get a PHD most people would want to be though smart. Why didn't you? That's what would make this interesting.

You cover too much territory in this paragraph. I can understand wanting to be viewed as average in some work situations and that other people need more money but I can't understand wanting to be thought average in most work situations. You would have to explain this in depth to keep people interested

Are you talking about your holidays? Or how you speak five languages
fluently? Did you enjoy being with your friends or did you enjoy being
smarter than them? Wouldn't it be much more interesting to talk about an actual holiday? What you did? Why your knowledge of five languages came in handy in one locale or did it?

The above paragraphs are a book and an unbelievable one at that. If you
did those things talk about them One thing that is considered impossible--a mathematical formula to play a lottery. If you know one, tell it. If you don't want people to know don't say anything.

I would love to know about a space trip.
Don't know where James Thurber came from or what book you're talking about. I have no idea if this is truth or fantasy but it can't work on either level as you cram too much into it Almost every sentence is its own chapter or book. I chose to treat this seriously though less carefully than I normally would as I'm putting off doing things I have to do.”

Well there it is, it rather left me speachless. I am just grateful that I don’t know anyone who would be capable of penning such caustic nastiness. I think the writers of the above crit have proved their total lack of comprehension of the written word; they surely must be very unhappy people --- and totally without any thought for others.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Harry

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

When I heard Jonathan Beckett was taking his site to Google 'groups' I immediately canceled my membership with ThoughtCafe and requested all material taken off before the move. Google is notorious for attracting these basking sharks that have attacked Gerry.

Criticism is a very dangerous thing. It is especially lethal when it is unqualified and misapplied as these were. To a greater or lesser extent we all feel our opinions take precedence over those of others and that, (for some godlike reason) we are duty bound to give it. It takes a strong effort of will to keep one's mouth shut when our brain is absent.

Jen_Christabel

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

I can wholeheartedly agree with this. But I have had a different experience; that of comments by people who think that are sooooooooo superior. It stinks! Nice one Gerry.

Jennifer x

Jolen

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Hi Gerry:

I agree, I think that you can be critical of a piece without being pretentious and evil, but it seems to be a rarity. I have seen this sort of thing deter many talents from continuing and that is a shame. Thank you for sharing this and it's great to see you around here.

blessings,

Jolen

e-griff

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

gerry - I have a criticism of the title of your piece! ;-)

this item is not about 'critique' - this is about two bloody idiots so clearly dripping bile disguised as critique - they are trolls (whatever), not genuine critiquers/commenters.

freya

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Gerry, I saw this. It was vicious. What makes me despair is that these kind of attacks cause almost irreparable harm to both individuals on a personal level and websites like UKA, where the intention is to provide support to writers, whether they're beginners or accomplished authors. It's my observation that the latter may often just want to get some feed-back in order to polish up a piece before they send it off to various publishers and mags et cetera, or perhaps a feeling for whether it 'works'. I understand, too, that some merely want to share their work with an appreciative readership, while others may hope to get a discussion going about content - to philosophize, in other words.

The point is, we all have our various reasons for being on writing sites. But unfortunately, there are people like these two all over the place and we are wise to be wary of them. it would be prudent, too, if we (as a group) decided on a way to intervene immediately when they appear.

I was very disappointed when ThoughtCafe made the move to Yahoo. It came without warning ( at least to me) and it looks almost impossible to navigate. Then one reads comments such as you received. I have removed my work from TC, also, as a result. My sympathy, Gerry, but I'm glad you posted this: it's one subject we do need to address and talk over in a civilized manner. Shelagh

eddiesolo

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

No wonder you are upset and angry-well effing fuming to be honest!

Crit is leveled at the piece-structure, content etc. Questions can be asked, privately if the author has any expertise regarding the story. Crit is there to make us all take a look at our work and see something (maybe better) that we, as the author can use. We do not write the type of comments that you have received-these people are, thankfully, far and few between-but when they strike they should be banned! You need to inform the website you go to-utter disgrace!

With you all the way Gerry, as John points out-TROLLS TROLLS TROLLS!

I went to Thought Cafe to read you're piece but couldn't find it. I also was tempted to Join, months ago-glad I didn't :-(

Si:-)

Gerry

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Simon, well Thoughtcafe didn't last unfortunately, it just couldn't get the members. Hence its move to Google Group.

If you want to read the post in question you will have to cut and paste lol. I tried to make the URL active but it didn't work.

Thank for your understanding comment on this Simon.

Best--

Gerry.

littleditty

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Hi Gerry - i remember your piece - i read the first crit example through, the second didnt hold my interest im afraid...and i couldnt be bothered to finish it...:o)...sorry was that rude of me? with crit i find it helpful to feel i am a reader of this crit - more than the writer of the piece - even arrogant, twisted, nasty, boring crit becomes interesting only because it is then all about them - and not my piece of writing. i suppose we learn to be selective as to who, or is that 'whom'? lol, we listen to! It's good to support other writers and wag a finger at nastiness, because us hooomans are sensitive creatures - and some have forgotten this somehow - good to read, good for those writers who are stifled by the shitty things that people do to others on the net, and elsewhere - arrogance and anonymity...dangerous combo...xxldx

RoyBateman

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Gerry, if I'd had comments like that I'd feel exactly the same way, and the "commenters" would be lucky to be somewhere safe in the ether! I agree absolutely with you re your mother - that was a really beyond-the-pale stunt. It's a great pity - like you, I was on tc before uka and had fond memories - but it's obviously not in the same league as uka is now, and I for one am remaining loyal. I presume that you are too! I have an unread mail in my box inviting me to this tc google group, so I shall have a look just out of interest, but it's a very sad thing to happen - tc used to be fine, but I note what Harry says above. All it takes is one or two *"@!s to ruin it for everyone...and if they haven't even got a sense of humour, they're no more my sort of reader than yours!

SugarMama34

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Hi Gerry,

I'm appauled to be honest with you about the comments you have recieved. Some people don't care if they offend or hurt a persons feelings with the critique the dish out.

Comments like the ones you recieved can do a lot of damage to the writers' confidence and in some cases can even put them off writing altogether.

There is a certain way to deliver critique - politley and with without malice, sadley these people did not. I really feel for you going through this.

I can undestand your anger and frustration. I would feel exactley the same too. Thank fully though you have good friends on UKA to help you through times like these. As someone else mention on here (I think it was John) They are TROLLS. They prove it with their so called critique. Take it with a pinch of salt - Your mates on UKA know best and will always give you sound advice and crit. :0)

Take Care, Gerry.

Best Wishes,

Sugar. xx (Lis'.)

Gerry

The NASTINESS of critique. (You decide)

Sugar, sorry late in replying -- have been away in the sun.

Walter Mitty was of course a guy with his head in the clouds, always day-dreaming himself into fascinating situations. I tried to write the article the way Walter may have done.

Walter could have done anything ;-)

The two morons mentioned above had there heads so far up their rear departments they couldn't detect the intention ---so they just attacked. sadly quite a common occurrence.

Thank you for your support...

Gerry xxx.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…